Everything posted by Phi for All
-
How famous do you think Feynman would have been had he not written any popular science?
This seems like a false dilemma, and I'm unsure why you feel the need to box him in like this. Do you dislike Feynman, or do you dislike popularity, or do you dislike intelligent people who become popular? Is it a requirement for you that physics be anonymous, or that studying science be free from a popular approach?
-
Would it be possible to capture an atmosphere fully, comprising all the chemical compounds?
! Moderator Note You can discuss it here, but don't try to sell it here. That will get you banned.
-
Would it be possible to capture an atmosphere fully, comprising all the chemical compounds?
1 part mud, 2 parts plant oils, 6 parts earthworm.
-
Segregation in sports (Split from Transgender athletes)
! Moderator Note I'm tempted to pin this as an example of bad-faith arguments for posterity. You've obviously reached the bottom of this particular barrel, so rather than watch you continue to scrape, I'm closing this.
-
Does Distance Decrease between you and an object as your elevation increases?
Some version of Skitt's Law will get you if you misplay the ridicule card. If the box on the ground is full of stones, and the tree is next to a glass house....
-
Evidence that we're in the Matrix or something like it
We still don't delete it. We Flag As Spammer, and the software hides it and adds the IP address to an Invision Community database of suspected spammers. The protocol for Speculations is adequate support of the claims made, and the OP has had a couple of weeks to respond, so we can close this per the rules. This is what we do most often, rather than trashing or hiding. Sometimes a bizarre perspective can help others form a better argument, but this OP clearly doesn't define evidence the way most here do. ! Moderator Note Thread closed.
-
Evidence that we're in the Matrix or something like it
! Moderator Note We delete NOTHING, ever. We hide inappropriate posts, we throw posts in the trash, but we don't delete it if someone took the time to write it. We like to give people the time to develop a discussion, and they can't if the mods have a hair-trigger when it comes to what they think is a waste of time. While posts are required to be reasonable, many members struggle with language and precision, so we give them a break. Long answer to a quick question, as long as a member doesn't break the rules, they should be able to post without staff guessing about their motives and temperament.
-
difference between upvote and like vote
"Like" and "Upvote" give +1 to reputation (pick one or the other), "Downvote" gives -1. If you trigger the auto-destruct sequence, the whole site goes on red alert and you will be given a warning point which will never expire.
-
If highly advanced civilization were found to exist other than the solar system what would its effect be on humanity?
I'd love to believe that, but unfortunately extremism is at an all time high, and there are far too many who would claim it's part of the government's attempts to forcefully vaccinate us and take over our minds with their technology. The Jewish Space Lasers are aimed at the planet, not at aliens in space! Aliens aren't abducting children, it's Democrats!
-
difference between upvote and like vote
Like has been available since the last software update, iirc. I don't use it. I think Like is part of a positive-only system of reputation, for those who want to focus on that. I think the Admins have it set where both are active.
-
Banned/Suspended Users
Anand_Haqq has been banned for avoiding science, soapboxing, and hijacking threads, all behavior that is anathema to a science discussion forum.
- question movement
-
Banned/Suspended Users
Alex Mercer has been suspended for a month for an unforgivable violation of our civility rules. If he comes back, he'll be in the mod queue.
-
Well who'd a thought...
There's a scientific term for this, what is it? Oh yeah, chicken-shit weasel. Remember when they were screaming about ad homs? Good times.
-
Can you be a scientist and still believe in religion?
We can be mindful of the distinctions between "beliefs". Are they based on faith, where belief is extremely strong but purposely avoids reason and critical thinking? Or are they based on hope, where belief is less strong, but the reasoning is little more than wishful thinking? Or are they based on trust, and trustworthy information, carefully tested and determined to be worth that trust?
-
Toyota dropping political contributions to some Republicans
With only two major political parties, corporations probably have a better chance of representing Americans on specific stances. I would applaud any major company that announced they would no longer support candidates using fascist tactics like the 50 Republicans above. Pepsi should denounce Mitch McConnel and FOX News for their hypocrisy in wondering why more Americans won't get vaccinated. And wouldn't it be great if Wal-Mart or Amazon stopped donating to Q-Anon candidates, and instead called for some reasonableness?
- question movement
-
Genetics essay question
Finally, someone who isn't from one of those obnoxious essay writing companies that spam us all the time!
-
question movement
You need to watch each of those movies again, start to finish (with all the bonus features), then come back and tell us if movement has caused them to malfunction. Gather evidence, please.
-
Could the Internet become self aware?
Kinetics may be the answer. When I search for "rail guns", Amazon cleverly changes it to "gun rails". Be afraid, internet!
-
Personal Attacks (split from Transgender athletes)
Being able to use reason to discuss various scientific phenomena requires an arena where that reason is respected. True personal attacks show me that the attacker has reached the limits of their reasoning power, and have resorted to lashing out emotionally. I've been exposed to some fantastic discussions in the time I've been here, and the common vein running through all of them was critical thinking and knowledge winning out over fallacies and ignorance, and members who are eager to practice civility and learn as opposed to just being right.
-
Could the Internet become self aware?
Now I'm getting ads from Amazon for "phased plasma rifles". The internet can't be aware if it's willing to arm us like this.
-
M theory, String theory, Theory of Everything
Good. Do yourself a huge favor then, and focus study on fields so you understand more about the research we already do. You're assuming the research necessary isn't being done. Remember that much of what you don't know relies on how much you understand. Focusing on learning as much as you can will help you avoid learning a little bit and guessing at the rest. Other than the 1:1 ratio of time travel we observe, it sounds like you can safely cross this off your list of concerns then. You have more important things to focus on. You should choose a better term than "belief" for things you can't possibly know the answer to. You aren't doing science if you're firmly convinced you're right about guesswork. I believe you say this because you have not understood the λCDM model it's based on. I think you're making the mistake of assuming something is wrong because it's not easily intuited. The universe has no obligation to make sense. This is hard stuff, and it requires focused study. These are not familiar terms. What do you mean by them? You can't find it by dismissing accumulated mainstream physics knowledge. If you don't understand something, it's MUCH better to ask questions than to make stuff up based on a lack of understanding.
-
Could the Internet become self aware?
You have that poster somewhere in your house, I just know it. Don't count Tom out though. Have you ever seen what an atomic physicist can do with a Breville BTA830XL Die-Cast 4-slice long-slot toaster? "Come with me, if you want to eat toast!"
-
If highly advanced civilization were found to exist other than the solar system what would its effect be on humanity?
! Moderator Note Are you proposing some kind of behavior or phenomenon? This is more opinion and guesswork than a Speculation you have to support. I can move this to Politics if you want to discuss the impact there, or Religion if you'd prefer that.