Skip to content

Trurl

Senior Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  1. I have not defined crypto but I think it would help in the billions of data sets. There can be patterns that are purely mathematical. I will research this to find evidence that agrees with my argument. And remember it is only a debate. I don’t want to annoy your beliefs as a scientist I am only suggesting there could be pure math relationships in biology, especially the formation of cells. As stated before the reason I use SFN is to present ideas. I could just type it in google and Gemini would give me an answer and I would be dependent on AI. I don’t know what the current definition of life is, but to me thinking machines would apply. Would there communication be a form of crypto. Where does their thoughts exist? Is it the memory, GPU, or CPU, the wires, the operating system, the binary? Not to mention their communications are spread throughout a network. We have math to explain all these processes. The human body is a machine. Why would we be any different. Of course I just made this up right now as I type this in my phone. But consider the idea and not if it breaks some scientific rule. You can do that latter. I propose that pure mathematics can explain biology patterns. As we already discussed bioinformatics. I will see what AI says in how this is being done. I am not the first one to have this idea. Cryptography is used to secure genetic information and some researchers have enciphered information in DNA.🧬 We are a science forum. My question is: Have you ever used cryptography not to encipher a set (say thousands) but to organize a set into meaningful patterns?
  2. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=czp0bb3HlGQ&pp=ugUHEgVlbi1JTg%3D%3D&ra=m President Trump, You should have watched this video. There is a lot of truth here in the link I posted. Trump won because he wasn’t a standard politician. His screw ups were many and no one cared. He beat Hillary because people were tired of traditional politicians. But that worked out to be even worse. But what he was good at is improving industry. He randomly placed and set rates of tariffs which U.S. citizens pay. But tariffs mean Americans can buy a $10,000 dollar EV and bankrupt the U.S. car industry. Military and industry were in his view what made America great. To be great you have to have a great economy to influence the World. But that is a strong business model but people have more needs than a strong economy. People don’t mind standing behind Israel if there was a legitimate reason and every policy wasn’t a lie. And Bernie touched on AI. Why do we spend billions to replace us? AI makes billions now but why have a race to our demise? No of it makes freaking sense and is why I was studying to be an engineer and not a politician. But as I have be told that good politicians are important but they will never fix all the world’s problems. What is the scientific way to solve problems? Logic does not apply to everything problem. People have conflicting beliefs. Some times it best to not act on a problem. Doing nothing doesn’t fix a problem. Scientifically can you prove we’d be better off with Harris than Trump? If you are familiar with the sci-fi shoe Quantum Leap where he fixed things right that went wrong, does changing one outcome always mean an improvement. Is that the theme of all science fiction? Trump is arrogant and is pissing everyone off. But maybe that was needed. Part of his strategy is making everyone mad and confused about what he is doing. But as Bernie said act like he is on the ballet. None of it makes any sense. Trillions to AI and cut an inexpensive billion to food Aid; building monuments and placing his name everywhere. I you like or hate Trump it shouldn’t mater. We should be able to debate. It is just Trump cause division in any opposition every speech. Bernie was right the republicans were a rubber stamp. But that is how Trump forced his policies through. It is probably a good thing the midterms turned out blue. Because there are other issues than the economy. If you think I am defending Trump in this post, I’m not. Bernie is making sense. I am just giving the reasons people voted for Trump and why politics is a trap. We should be doing science, but you can’t avoid politics because it affects all our lives.
  3. One more reason I think cryptography applies to genetics which may sound insightful or completely absurd is that we are only looking at the result of the reproduction and formation of proteins we do not have a language. Just as with AI training we know the information it was trained on and the output but with billions of processes no one can explain the results. Do we look at the genetic process as a machine? Do the chemical reactions occur based on the information of RNA? And how do the reactions in the cell relate to the overall design of the organism? And how do different cells interact with each other to complete the organs and then the organism? Again billions of processes and if cryptography cannot find patterns we are reliant on computers.
  4. Well I think they are already using cryptographic methods as I have mentioned earlier. To me it is like crypto because of the magnitude of the combinations of data. I tried to give examples through my posts. It wasn’t just a bunch of bs. DNA has an original code it is communicated in RNA to form new proteins. I know that no one has made the communication and message and building into a cryptography process, but maybe they should. I know the chemistry is hard to relate to and define mathematically, but I think if we don’t do it AI will. I have an elementary understanding of genetics. But I believe math applies to everything. I mean I can’t think of anything we’ve encountered that doesn’t have some application of mathematics. I am interested in cryptography in genetics because cryptography sorts one in the billions. For humans we can’t brute force trillions. We need a correlation or pattern to make sense of things. And the pattern would have to be complex to work. I believe the more we found patterns the more patterns would present itself. Once it is found the easier we could sort more and more data. Discoveries are often based on a need. Here the need is to understand the billions. We could rely on AI, but I would prefer humans were in the lead in genetics. In the book Crypto by Steve Levy he describes how public key cryptography is based on the need of planes needing to define friend or foe. Cryptography had never been used in such ways before. But information, messages, and communication all relate to cryptography. Why would we believe it can’t apply to biology?
  5. Well if we agree it’s not random there has to be a distinct pattern. We agree life is a special case and that it has something that is a map. Such as DNA there are patterns. The pattern is just a description of how it works. We haven’t found every pattern. I am suggesting using math like in statistics or cryptography to find new patterns. I don’t believe I talked about an entity secret code. Although DNA is one of the biological properties unique to an individual. But that is not the crypto aspect I was arguing. I am saying we have undiscovered patterns. And patterns relate to cryptography because crypto protocols are just rules to a set of functions that are based on pattern that through experimentation and mathematical we added description to a phenomenon that otherwise would be a mystery. Exactly. The reason that DNA is so complex is just the amount of information. That also is what happens in cryptography. We have large data and are looking for patterns that will lessen computation. I am not interested in a code left by an intelligent being. I am looking for a code that is hidden because it hasn’t been discovered yet. Shout Out to Rosalind Franklin—-the real reason behind the helix model.
  6. Well that is the question. I have written here and probably exhausted the reasons I think that patterns in genetic information will not be random. It would be difficult to determine the value of a pattern. Like with electricity how do you know to measure resistance if you don’t look for a pattern? And once you have found a pattern often it can be backed up mathematically. But sometimes the value of the pattern is how the scientist chose the rules. Patterns are how we understand things. AI may find patterns we don’t understand. I heard it described that when the computer plays Othello it starts in obscure places on the board. I my approach to science I really don’t believe in random patterns. It is ok to disagree. I just don’t think as life as random. But if one believes in evolution they don’t have to believe genes are random. Even if I am wrong and cells are totally random I would not be deterred, because it would only mean look elsewhere for a pattern. It would also mean genetics isn’t as useful as believed because there would be no reason to decode it and learn how to modify it. But patterns and manipulation are already being done. So we know patterns already exist. The question is can you describe the patterns mathematically?
  7. Of course it does There will just be more political battles. I am not against secure borders but deporting immigrants isn’t the way to go. There is no middle ground. All the current policies just stopped is as bad as letting them play out. I mean the Iran war, how do you fix that? I say the change of power doesn’t matter because stopping current policies is just as dangerous if not more than Trump finishing his term.
  8. Should not have bullied to get your way. Not your policies but how they were implemented. Democrats rallying doesn’t fix anything.
  9. Yes that is the question: would a math pattern correlate with some physical pattern? But can you think of mathematical patterns that explain physical things? Physics is full of them. If someone looked at electricity 200 years ago put it into equations it would be a challenge to describe it. They kept it simple or at least it seems that way because we learned it in school. Is there no simpler approach to genetics? And could a pure math solution or pattern help to simplify what’s going on? Again do you get patterns from experiments or from analyzing the data? I would say if you have enough knowledge and data math should definitely find patterns. Isn’t that what data scientists are doing now? It works for statistics. Something like during a football game where the announcer gives a stat that the running back is the first to have rushed 80 yards and have 40 receiving yards in 20 years. There point is it obscure statistics. The lump of data now finds all sorts of otherwise unseen descriptions. What comes first the math or the experiment? I saw a thread on SFN before if math was invented or discovered. Do we define the model that describes genetics or genes work in a certain way that defines the models we have? I got you. I agree that this is the language relationship again. I know that a crypto scheme works because all the data involved is numbers. But why can’t I substitute variables for different proteins? Or whatever chromosome? Suppose you were programming a program with class dog. You put in the definition dog =3. That may not sound important but with different algorithms dog=3 might create important relationships. That is like AI training. I a dog goes for a walk it tells you something more important than you think. Dog is many things and walk is one characteristic. But I get your point. I just can’t throw patterns into sets of billions of data. But like electricity everything looks that way from the beginning. I just hope we get the chance to look into this before AI. Why is feeding AI everything always the solution today?
  10. Ok another question which may or may not relate to crypto and genetics. I listen to a podcast with Leo Laporte and Steve Gibson. Steve said forget cookies the web browser settings can narrow the user down to single digits. Like 6 billion users then millions who use Firefox then 1000 who disable cookies to what firewall. That becomes a unique finger print. Those numbers are paraphrased because I don’t have an easy way to look it up. But just as the browser settings identify and authenticate the user could you guys see any relation to grouping different DNA traits into categories?So instead of billions you have an 1 in a thousand instead of 1 in a billion. I haven’t researched it but I think this is how scientists go about it. To me this is where a pattern comes in. You would not have to know genetics to find a pattern mathematically. It would certainly help, but you don’t need the properties of the biology to use statistics on the patterns or groups the biologist grouped them in. CharonY I believe was arguing the point that a pure math solution would be meaningless and would not relate to the biology. And may be right. I don’t know enough about genetics to base my pattern. But this is how I envision scientists are approaching the problem. And don’t you want there to be a pattern? Not to just be mathematically beautiful but explain one aspect of our lives.
  11. Yes, thank you that is the stuff I am looking for. The only problem is that I don’t have the data. By that I mean a database of genetic information.
  12. That was just an example of cryptography use in DNA. The link is supposed to go under the first quote of yours but I couldn’t get it there on my phone. But do you think that those scientists that genetically engineered food don’t use some kind of recipe or cipher? Remember this is just an idea to apply cryptography to genetics. I am only saying it could be useful. You are thinking in terms of an entire protocol. Which could be good. But crypto is about communication and messages. I am only saying that we can apply it to the messages of cells. Obviously I don’t have the solution. I’m only saying it would be a worthwhile subject to study.
  13. Patterns in any genetic information. I believe that the genetic information can be organized by patterns that would make sense to cryptography but not biological logic. Of course I believe people have tried similar things. Like how certain genes are linked to cancer. Or how AI would approach protein folding. If AI is as able to find seemingly non logical patterns in folding as it does cyber security we’d have new patterns with some patterns that seem like crypto. Treating genetics as a form of cryptography does not seem to be a fruitful approach. The second link I posted gives an example of using DNA as a form of cryptography. Not exactly what I was describing but you may find it interesting. The pattern of genes could be found in what we already know. I am not looking for a biological function that acts as the private key. It would be great if it exists but treating patterns should be more simple. I am thinking what a sine curve is to an electrical signal. It describes electricity and retains all the useful math we know about sine. Here is the link for crypto in genetics: https://villageb.io/ResourceDetail?id=11
  14. I’m just trying to show correlation between crypto and genetics. I appreciate the post though. If we agree or disagree it doesn’t matter. You guys are more knowledgeable about genetics anyway. I am just saying crypto and genetics are both billions of instructions happening instantaneously. Without patterns they are both meaningless. That is why I believe crypto and genetics relate and want to look for patterns. I realize that may not be a completely scientific reason. And I should be looking into RNA, but when I say DNA I should specify I mean all genetics.
  15. https://assets.answersresearchjournal.org/doc/v19/cryptographic_analysis_origins_DNA.pdf You are correct it is creation science. But that isn’t my point. I was just trying to post support on crypto used in genetics. The other link is using genetic information to encipher messages. My point was that in creationism or pure science a pattern exists, because if it didn’t we wouldn’t be here. These links are by Gemini on google. I don’t google everything first because when you google the brainstorms you had are buried under an information overload. I am trying to do a self study on genetics. Years ago I did a self study on crypto. I understand that I must take into account the chemistry and biology. But I don’t know why no one sees the correlation of crypto and genetics. Isn’t that how AI will approach the problem? I mentioned the million person study where all medical records of each person are stored. AI could compare traits of track statistics but if genes were compared and there were no patterns we’d learn nothing.

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.