dimreepr

You don't need god to know the shape of one's soul, you just need to be brutally honest with yourself; confessions need no outside observer.

Is that an extract from mien kampf? If history teaches us anything, it's that every war ends with excessive pacifism. Watch from 25 minutes https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VM3Pb3ejA54

I would have answered, but apparently he doesn't like or listen to my discourse, whatever...

You should read again, when did I ask a loaded question? Or redefine a term? It's remarkably easy to offend people with a joke, especially when they don't understand it: “The Moving Finger writes; and, having writ, Moves on: nor all thy Piety nor Wit Shall lure it back to cancel half a Line, Nor all thy Tears wash out a Word of it.” ― Omar Khayyám

Let it be a lesson, from the book of Reg... This lesson is from the book of Dennis. Your confusing fake with communal integration, to fake is to cheat your fellowship (see above). Age isn't an analog of wisdom, but it does get used as an insult, by the befuddled elderly... 🙄

According to google, or at least your understanding of the question I answered...

Obviously, please read again... Is Google the soul arbiter of understanding?

I think that rabbit hole deserves it's own topic, feel free to start one...

What's the difference?

That's a fake, no wonder you're struggling to keep up/-to-date... Did g/God teach you that? I have... That's convenient... 🙄

My iron-e-meter just went pop, again... 🙄

Call it what you like, but a soul seems concise enough...

Well, the evidence suggests that if I do something horrible and I know that I have, then I'll suffer a consequence of some sort, PTSD and the like...

Because my computer told me too... I didn't say that I need a soul, I'm just happy to accept that I have one; assuming a soul and god are different... Now, please answer my question.

Indeed, it becomes a cascade of guilt, with very little open for debate about justice.

Why? Did you stop cheating?

That's not what I said. A more pertinent question, I think, is what happens to our soul's while we're alive. @Phi for All This is what I think we're missing, in our modern age, that a stone aged person just saw as a fact. A good person has a good soul and is therefore in heaven, alive or dead; when seen as a fact it becomes a reason to celebrate their life, in their death; morning becomes easier, as does forgiveness. This is what I think Nietzche was searching for, a scientific explanation of the soul, that can replace a need for god; in our age of enlightenment. There is no value in a fake. Why do you need God? Genuine question Maybe Buddha, understood... 😉

That ignores the context of the entire post, bc there are passages in the bible, that suggest we do good thing's to/for others. And Santa really does bring a smile, to a grateful child.

I think we're at cross purposes, I'm not suggesting what religion (edit, just for clarity I'm talking Abrahamic) has become has anything to teach us; just that there are passages in the bible that are still relevant today. My point is, science knowledge is not always relevant to one's life issue's; science isn't designed for empathy. When dogma settles into a profound script, only the politicians benefit; Just look at the gun law's in America. Indeed, they were both intended to bring a smile, when you've been good at some point.

Indeed, but when the bathwater is dirty it's hard to see the baby; religion still addresses the things we are yet ignorant of, the human condition and why the placebo affect is effective etc.

+ 1

The reality in this case is, hamas poked the bear and now it just wants to kill the humans. Like I said many pages ago, a far more aggressive approach to the situation is to smother their army with pacifism, that's heroism; killing babies is much easier, because the cowards among us demand it... As long as they don't have to look...

Why not on this one?

I think not, it's a conflation. "heaven on Earth" is perfectly possible to achieve, for an individual; utopia is impossible because, there's always one... Maybe, but maybe religion started with the exact same message, but politicians got confused. 🤒

Never gamble with more than you can afford to lose; the freedom to eat, for instance.