Everything posted by dimreepr
-
Faith (split from How atheists often misunderstand and misuse the theory of evolution)
I'm happy to acknowledge your right to neg my post, but without a reasoned argument, I really don't care; but thanks for participating... 🤒
-
New studies on the brains of flys with an interesting animation
What struck me as I read this, imagine how much more powerful AI could become if we copy n paste that wiring diagram into a supercomputer?
-
Exploding Pagers Injure Hundreds in Lebanon
It always starts somewhere, then the ripples grow...
-
Faith (split from How atheists often misunderstand and misuse the theory of evolution)
The one that fits the persons ability and intelligence on the spectrum of faith, you are certain of your position bc what you've built can be seen to be working, no faith needed, but you're an outlier; the outlier at the other end of the scale is a baby. All I'm saying is that most of us are dotted around the middle, whatever ism we follow, requires a fair bit of faith. For me, this statement applies to everyone on the spectrum equally. There's no evidence that science will continue to evolve, tomorrow.
-
Is money and wealth evil?
That's a very shallow definition of rich, money is an ever more arbitrary measure of wealth distribution, it could change overnight and you have no money, you've still got the house and and a larder that can feed the family for six months. For me the truely rich are happy with that for six months.
-
Exploding Pagers Injure Hundreds in Lebanon
They're not helping, they're prolonging the agony by giving Israel a 'world' license to carry on regardless. WWIII isn't beyond reason...
-
How atheists often misunderstand and misuse the theory of evolution
Fair enough; scienceism = people who put their faith in science; I count myself among their numbers. That includes a lot of people who don't really understand the science, bc we don't speak the language properly; the great thinkers evolve our thinking, sometimes against the prevailing/dogmatic understanding. Ditto religions. I'm not sure how else one could interpret that word, in the context of my post.
-
How atheists often misunderstand and misuse the theory of evolution
Baruch Spinoza - Wikipedia Given the context, isn't it obvious?
-
Is this a recognized fallacy or tactic?
It's still basically the same question, in that nothing offered that you consider to be true.
-
How atheists often misunderstand and misuse the theory of evolution
Which ones are you talking about? Religion's may lag behind sometimes and resist fundamental changes in their belief, but they also contain great thinkers that challenge the dogma and lead to better explanation's. Ditto scienceism. How does it prove your point? Evolution is the very definition of chaos, and your premise is that atheist misunderstand evolution. IOW no need for a god to guild thing's... 😉
-
Is this a recognized fallacy or tactic?
Philosophically speaking, language's can be misinterpreted, maybe the premise offered is valid, even when both appear to be speaking the same language, the smallest nuance can be the switch between the truths. If memory serves, it a Wittgenstein type question.
-
How atheists often misunderstand and misuse the theory of evolution
We are all indoctrinated, it's an inevitability if we survive our birth, please don't assume that your particular indoctrination is superior just bc; have a think about why your immune to the notion of god, just bc you don't believe in an ism...
-
How atheists often misunderstand and misuse the theory of evolution
They both are, which one is most acceptable? That depends on the culture/state/village, one grew up in...
-
Proportionality of military actions
Which circles back to my post, morals is an individual thing that depends on what we can see, which in 99.999...% of the time nobody actually does and so it's disconnected from objective justice, ethics is designed to interject and objectively view the scene. No, I said not really, in the context of actually seeing the scene. It's not Israel that's likely to get the message, they are so much stronger and therefore so much less likely to look for an alternative in fighting their corner, it's Hamas that needs to learn the "rope a dope" technique. We can't expect people to think morally, without ethics defining the rules of the game...
-
Proportionality of military actions
Of course they can, with a reasonable argument...
-
How atheists often misunderstand and misuse the theory of evolution
Well dark matter and dark energy, could be invisible pink unicorns, it depends on the story...
-
Proportionality of military actions
Indeed, but I'm not using it. Indeed, that's the role of ethics...
-
The Dawkins delusion...
That depends on the eddy, in the flow.
-
Exploding Pagers Injure Hundreds in Lebanon
That depends on how they chose to do that, the world is watching... Ouch, but aren't we equally capable?
-
Bad criticisms of religion
Religion is easy to deny bc it generally needs a god to be the arbiter of, whatever... God is an easy target, bc it can't exist... If you want religion to make sense to those who don't believe, then take god out of the argument and explain what the people who wrote the bible, actually meant...
-
How atheists often misunderstand and misuse the theory of evolution
Yes, but he entirely missed the point, eugenics is not something we can control bc the enviroment changes in a future we have no idea about, no god need be involved, so whatever ism you choose, it has no bearing on the reality in front of you... 🙄
-
Violence committed by God as opposed to violence committed by nature
Is a virus evil for causing a cold? If God's exist, it would be irrational to assume that they work for you, given the success of the virus... 😉
-
Proportionality of military actions
Not really, "when we can clearly see who took my vision.", it would be foolish to offer the other eye, and I'd be entirely justified, even as a pacifist, in plucking one of theirs in order to profide context and consequences. Indeed, it's always easier when we can clearly see, who the actual bully is. It's not democracy that's the road block to ethics, it's capitalism and the accountant, they own the system.
-
Proportionality of military actions
The ethical argument is very different to the moral one: The moral argument is "an eye for an eye", which is justice when we can clearly see who took my vision. The ethical argument is "how do you know who took what, with only one eye?". Proportionality lies somewhere in between and I don't think the military is best placed to judge...
-
Exploding Pagers Injure Hundreds in Lebanon
No, it sound's like you're refusing to acknowledge that bullies are created not born, they all live in basically the same place where the boarders is an arbitrary measure; they don't even have the excuse that they're living on an island and have evolved slightly differently. Everyone has condemned Hitler for the bully he was, isn't it time Israel stopped citing him as the reason to be the bigger innocent???