who in your opinion would win?

 

Edited November 19, 201015 yr by Abreu

i wasn't aware that there was a difference

In the fight face to face , the Samurai is the winner , because Ninja is perfect more in the assassination .

 

And Ninja is less qualified with swords

Let me re-phrase your question: Who would win? A highly disciplined killing machine or an assassin thug? I go with killing machine. < Samurai wins>

 

Ninjas weren't as cool as people stereotype them.

i beleive the samurai would kill the ninja beause ninja isnt a sure thing he works in stealth,the samurai in the other hand has honor and pride who would boost him mentaly but would a samurai be able to slice a ninja in half with one sword hit?

The Ninja would have killed his opponent last night as he slept.

A bit thin on "honour" perhaps, but effective.

What if the ninja didn't know who his opponent was? They had only met that min/hour...

if the samurai saw the ninja he woud be good as dead

if the samurai saw the ninja he woud be good as dead

Nice use of a pronoun there.

Which "he" did you mean?

the ninja would be dead

Which "he" did you mean?

 

The one carrying a gun, I presume.

In a standoff with ninja and samurai i presume the samurai would be the most effective in hand to hand combat. As stated prior the ninja is based on stealth and this scenario is arena based? sword fighting etc... I wadger 50 yen for the samurai side....... popcorn anybody??? c - :

it would depend on which samurai and which ninja because if chuck norris is my ninja......ill take you on that bet Josh =D

who in your opinion would win?

 

 

 

Well it would really depend on the ninja's skills wouldn't it? You see, the samurai is heavily armoured, and therefore, protected. However, popular belief says that ninjas are expert fighters, and so maybe don't even need armour. If both subjects had equal skills, then the samurai would have the better chance because of his protection. Yet, one might believe that the ninja, is in fact, quite stupid if he is to turn up to a fight with no means of protection at all... but both subjects would have learned several different styles of martial arts, so then it comes straight back to skill again.

ninaj's because of the sand and egg trick

Ninja because they are really effective in killing and they can use gravity effectively.

Well it would really depend on the ninja's skills wouldn't it? You see, the samurai is heavily armoured, and therefore, protected.

 

Well...

 

I wouldn't say a samurai was heavily armoured, for one, Japanese steel at the time of the samurai ~ 1100 to 1600 AD was of inferior quality and hard to come by compared to steel of western europe. In this scenario i'd go with the samurai anyway as ninjas are indeed geared towards infiltration, assasination and spying and not all out warfare.

 

A matchup i'd really like to see is a Samurai vs the same time period equivilent from western Europe. Lets see just how those magical/Legendary and able cut through concrete Katanas are against full plate armour.

Well...

 

I wouldn't say a samurai was heavily armoured, for one, Japanese steel at the time of the samurai ~ 1100 to 1600 AD was of inferior quality and hard to come by compared to steel of western europe. In this scenario i'd go with the samurai anyway as ninjas are indeed geared towards infiltration, assasination and spying and not all out warfare.

 

A matchup i'd really like to see is a Samurai vs the same time period equivilent from western Europe. Lets see just how those magical/Legendary and able cut through concrete Katanas are against full plate armour.

 

Too right! We might see how much the ability to craft a fine poem, or a knowledge of calligraphy really helps a fighting man.

Edited May 6, 201114 yr by imatfaal

Too right! We might see how much the ability to craft a fine poem, or a knowledge of calligraphy really helps a fighting man.

 

I think perhaps you are thinking of scribes or bards.

I think perhaps you are thinking of scribes or bards.

 

No I am thinking of Daidoji Yuzan's instructions to wannabe Samurai to avoid being merely a rustic warrior and take up poetry, calligraphy and the tea-ceremony.

I tried google fight as the end all for vs. question... but sadly, it seems to be broken

Samurai 293 results

 

Ninja

283 results

 

Samurai wins, technically.

 

 

Both of those words should be hitting in the millions, doesn't seem to matter what you make 'fight' everything is hitting 200's... doesn't make sense... conclusion: broken

Should allow for 3 way fights between Pirates, Samurai and ninjas

It's fixed!!!

 

Ninja Kicks Samurais BUTT with 17,600,000 over Samurai with only 720,000

 

Round 2... Ninja Vs Pirate

With only a hit of 8,580,000... Pirate didn't have a chance.