Skip to content

Kerch Strait Bridge Severely Damaged

Featured Replies

Ukrainian missiles have destroyed one of the two main arches of Russia’s Kerch Strait bridge which links the Crimean peninsula to the Russian mainland.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FZHJbhEGzwM

The bridge had come under sustained attack over the last 48 hours from at least 150 UAV drones which overwhelmed the bridge’s air defence systems, before a larger Ukrainian missile destroyed the southern arch, and dropped an estimated 273 metres of the roadway section into the shipping channel of the Kerch Strait below, thereby blocking it completely with rubble and steel. The northern part of the bridge which carries a railway line is also damaged, but still capable of carrying some traffic according to Russian sources.

Construction of the 18.6 Km long Crimean bridge was completed in 2018 at a cost of $3B following Russia’s illegal annexation of  Crimea in 2014, and it was inaugurated by Premier Vladimir Putin in person. The bridge has been a top priority target of Ukraine’s mlitary forces ever since. The roadway was severely damaged on 8 October 2022 by a truck bomb, and the piers have been attacked by seaborne drones on a number of other occasions.

The damage this time is however much greater. Structural engineers who have studied photos of the latest damage say it may be almost impossible for Russia to repair the bridge this time, especially under wartime conditions when salvage and repair crews will be under constant threat of more Ukrainian attacks. The fallen arch and roadway sections completely block the Kerch Strait shipping channel, making it impossible for Russia to move grain freighters between the Sea of Azof and the Black Sea.

Kerch_Bridge.jpg

50 minutes ago, toucana said:

Ukrainian missiles have destroyed one of the two main arches of Russia’s Kerch Strait bridge which links the Crimean peninsula to the Russian mainland.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FZHJbhEGzwM

The bridge had come under sustained attack over the last 48 hours from at least 150 UAV drones which overwhelmed the bridge’s air defence systems, before a larger Ukrainian missile destroyed the southern arch, and dropped an estimated 273 metres of the roadway section into the shipping channel of the Kerch Strait below, thereby blocking it completely with rubble and steel. The northern part of the bridge which carries a railway line is also damaged, but still capable of carrying some traffic according to Russian sources.

Construction of the 18.6 Km long Crimean bridge was completed in 2018 at a cost of $3B following Russia’s illegal annexation of  Crimea in 2014, and it was inaugurated by Premier Vladimir Putin in person. The bridge has been a top priority target of Ukraine’s mlitary forces ever since. The roadway was severely damaged on 8 October 2022 by a truck bomb, and the piers have been attacked by seaborne drones on a number of other occasions.

The damage this time is however much greater. Structural engineers who have studied photos of the latest damage say it may be almost impossible for Russia to repair the bridge this time, especially under wartime conditions when salvage and repair crews will be under constant threat of more Ukrainian attacks. The fallen arch and roadway sections completely block the Kerch Strait shipping channel, making it impossible for Russia to move grain freighters between the Sea of Azof and the Black Sea.

Kerch_Bridge.jpg

We have already have a thread on this: https://www.scienceforums.net/topic/140669-kerch-bridge-in-crimea-damaged-split-from-putin-and-the-reasons-of-trumps-loss/

But, curiously, your photo shows a different degree of damage from the one @Sensei posted. There is a lot more splintering on your picture. Also, there are extra piers in different places on the two pictures. Something does not add up. I have a horrible feeling one, or both, of these may have been doctored by AI.

Edited by exchemist

I'd suggest it's this one that is AI.

The extra pier under the span of the railway bridge is (I'd guess) a result of the AI getting confused at having seen the end pier of the road bridge in parallax.

Other photos of the collapsed bridge don't show so much of the collapsed roadway above water.

This pic also doesn't show the scorching seen on the railway bridge arch.

  • Author
1 hour ago, exchemist said:

We have already have a thread on this: https://www.scienceforums.net/topic/140669-kerch-bridge-in-crimea-damaged-split-from-putin-and-the-reasons-of-trumps-loss/

But, curiously, your photo shows a different degree of damage from the one @Sensei posted. There is a lot more splintering on your picture. Also, there are extra piers in different places on the two pictures. Something does not add up. I have a horrible feeling one, or both, of these may have been doctored by AI.

Interesting - I hadn’t actually seen that split thread, and was coming at the subject from an engineering point of view, in particular the challenge of trying to repair the bridge under wartime conditions as outlined in the linked report by Caolan Robertson of The Sun.

The picture I used came from a YT video by  Ryan Mcbeth

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X4YP9HGY8fI

The extra truncated piers are known as ‘Dolphins’ and they have come up here before in a thread from March 2024 about the collapse of the Francis Scott Keys bridge in Baltimore harbour after it was struck by a ship. The “Dolphins” are basically island buffers that offer a form of collision protection .

Your point about AI manipulation of images is well taken however, and unfortunately both sides in this conflict have strong reasons for meddling with them. The Russian media has reportedly imposed a total embargo on daylight images of the damage, and the Ukrainians will be tempted to exaggerate the structural damage to raise their own morale, and lower that of Crimea.

Edited by toucana
corrected "in a thread" in p.3

1 hour ago, pzkpfw said:

I'd suggest it's this one that is AI.

The extra pier under the span of the railway bridge is (I'd guess) a result of the AI getting confused at having seen the end pier of the road bridge in parallax.

Other photos of the collapsed bridge don't show so much of the collapsed roadway above water.

This pic also doesn't show the scorching seen on the railway bridge arch.

You're right! That extra pier under the railway bridge makes no sense and must be fake. Also the railway tracks don't look like railway tracks. So with that and the extra dolphins in different places, it is clear that @toucana 's source is using a faked image. As it comes from YouTube it is hardly surprising. There is however a BBC clip from their "Verify" team which substantiates the basic outcome, viz. the road bridge has indeed collapsed into the water, blocking the only navigable channel.

Edited by exchemist

1 hour ago, exchemist said:

... which substantiates the basic outcome, viz. the road bridge has indeed collapsed into the water, blocking the only navigable channel.

I saw YT clips the day before about the initial damage. Then later saw YT clips claiming collapse. My first thought was "click bait!".

But was very happy to find out that there really had been a collapse after the second attack. Russia go home.

4 minutes ago, pzkpfw said:

I saw YT clips the day before about the initial damage. Then later saw YT clips claiming collapse. My first thought was "click bait!".

But was very happy to find out that there really had been a collapse after the second attack. Russia go home.

Whisper it but there may have been 2 or more hits just now on the railway

https://twitterviewer.net/Maks_NAFO_FELLA

Edited by geordief

13 minutes ago, pzkpfw said:

I saw YT clips the day before about the initial damage. Then later saw YT clips claiming collapse. My first thought was "click bait!".

But was very happy to find out that there really had been a collapse after the second attack. Russia go home.

👍

3 hours ago, pzkpfw said:

ut was very happy to find out that there really had been a collapse after the second attack. Russia go home.

Makes it kind of difficult for the Russians to go home.
They have no way out of Crimea without the bridge; it's either swim, or go through Ukraine.

31 minutes ago, MigL said:

Makes it kind of difficult for the Russians to go home.
They have no way out of Crimea without the bridge; it's either swim, or go through Ukraine.

IIRC In the early days, Ukraine decided to leave the Kerch Bridge to allow the Russians an orderly exit, But looks like they had second thought and took the bridge out.

  • Author
9 hours ago, geordief said:

Whisper it but there may have been 2 or more hits just now on the railway

https://twitterviewer.net/Maks_NAFO_FELLA

Preliminary reports on social media indicate that the surviving railway arch of the Kerch bridge was hit at  least twice and possibly four times last night by a sustained Ukrainian attack using Flamingo FP-5, Neptune, and Dutch made Ruta jet drones.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fcczkWt1b44

Interestingly the Ukrainian forces are said to be using a chain of relay drones or  “flying modems” to control and coordinate their attacks on the bridge rather than rely on the Starlink system which has repeatedly been throttled by the Kremlin’s friends in the White House in recent weeks, in an attempt  to prevent such attacks taking place during the current 33rd APEC summit meeting of American, Russian, and Chinese leaders in Shenzen China.

Although the the surviving railway arch looks like a twin copy of the fallen roadway arch, it is in fact about  1000 tonnes heavier in order to sustain the load of the  twin train rail tracks which have to carry long supply trains of fuel and ammunition across the Strait to maintain a Russian military presence in Crimea and the land corridor linking it to the occupied Donbas territories further north.

Repairing the destroyed arch will be no simple task. The arches were originally fabricated on the mainland, then floated out into position on barges, and then jacked up 35 metres into position. Structural engineers estimate it would take at least 18 months to accomplish this task in peacetime (they would also have to clear the shipping channel first). With a threat of ongoing Ukrainian missile attacks, it would be practically impossible to accomplish this in any finite amount of time.

The puppet governor of Crimea confirmed that railway shipments have stopped. So, given the load requirements of the railway arch, even just being "a little bent" (as one report put it) could mean considerable downtime. If critical supplies have to move by ferry that would seem to a pretty effective choke on transport of bulky goods - and way more expensive for what they can move across.


Україна — назавжди!

As the Kerch Bridge is effectively out of commission for the extent of the war, and the captured/occupied land corridor that runs through Mariupol and Melitopol is constantly and easily targeted by Ukrainian drones, Crimea is cut off from Russia proper.
This is easily the largest Ukrainian territory take-back since the beginning of the war; all Ukraine has to do is march back in once Russian forces can no longer be resupplied.
Someone should point out to Elbridge Colby that long range strikes do work, even if his Government 'hamstrings' the Ukrainians bt throttling StarLink connextions.

18 hours ago, MigL said:

Makes it kind of difficult for the Russians to go home.

Swim or die.

7 hours ago, MigL said:

Someone should point out to Elbridge Colby that long range strikes do work...

Colby is completely committed to his China (Yellow Peril ) doctrine, is convinced we shouldn't bother with Europe or the Middle East at all. It will be up to the new Congress to reboot better support for Ukraine, and NATO, something most Americans want. Turnip is indifferent to us honoring our obligations and alliances, ever the amoral toddler who lives to break things. I hope you're correct that this transportation collapse will eventually allow Ukraine to march back in and retake their land.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.