Everything posted by studiot
-
Alien origin thought experiment.
Yes that's the story, though I seem to remember it was slightly more detailed when I first read it. +1 I have never heard of Pandora's Legions , though if there are more like this one they could be good. You link give 2002 as a publication date, but I first read this one in the mid 1960s. I used to look forwards to receiving the Gollanz Worlds Best SF annual (book) every year at Christmas. This would have probably been in the 1966 or 67 one.
-
Alien origin thought experiment.
Thank you to both of those who replied to my post. The point about thestory in the second part of post was that humans were more intelligent but wated it squabbling amongst each other. I wish I could remember the name of the story. It was really good.
-
How unsafe are the gullible ?
Dutch find 'anti 5G' devices (dangerously?) radioactive. Anti-5G braclets found to be radioactive https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-59703523
-
By which physical properties do isotopes actually differ
Indeed you did. But John is right that you seem to be a bit confused about what is an isotope. Perhaps you are mixing this up a bit with allotropy or perhaps it is just a language difficulty. You also mentioned physical properties only. Physical properties are rather more affected than chemical ones because the extra neutrons add extra mass, but not charge. So properties that depend upon atomic or molecular mass such as colligative properties do vary a bit. International tables such as Lange give values for these for different isotopes where they are known. Within the atom most electron orbitals stay the same and the number of electrons stays the same to spectra from these (X ray and UV) are pretty much the same, as are the actual chemical reactions involved. So dielectric and magnetic properties that depend upon electron spin will be unaffected but NMR spectra are changed. https://www.osti.gov/biblio/6389648-proton-deuterium-tritium-nuclear-magnetic-resonance-intramolecular-hydrogen-bonds-isotope-effects-shape-potential-energy-function But IR spectra are dependant on vibrating atomic masses so will change the most. As already noted by exchemist mass spectra are clearly affected and a very important method of both istope detection and separation. However some bond strengths and/or angles can be altered. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15137048/
-
Alien origin thought experiment.
Or just very long lived. or the perhaps the Scifi story in Analog SF is true. That is the one about invading monkeys from outer space. A monkey scientist wrote a paper entitled 'why the loptails don't have space travel'
-
Was Pangea, a Moon?
Interestingly we have the following figures. Estimated mass of continental crust (ie mass of Gondwana) is 2.20 x 1022 kg Mass of existing Moon is 7.34 x 1022 kg
-
Hijack from Units?
This is about the most ineffecient learning method I can think of, especially if you are learning for yourself. The sheer amount of material to learn is far greater than can be simply looked at in more than one lifetime. So everyone needs some reduction scheme. We periodically have those who ask the (sensible) question "If I am learning for myself how to I go about it ?" And we try our best to help them. But that would be a topic for another thread if you are interested, please start one. You might be pleasantly suprised at the response.
-
Hijack from Units?
So why are you trying to tell me 'what I was taught' ? You have no knowledge of any 'teaching' I may or may not have received or how I received it. We actually have a couple of self taught members here with impressive knowledge, one has a knowledge and understanding of Physics well up to postgraduate level. These members also command great respect because of the attitude in being prepared to listen as well as offer their thoughts. In turn others are interested in their thoughts which are generally well worth listening to. The rest of your quote was question about imaginary numbers. No I was not thinking about imaginary numbers. You can use the decimal system with imaginary numbers. But there are numbers called irrational numbers and others called trancendental numbers that cannot be expressed in the decimal system. However some can be expressed in other systems. For example the number 1/3 cannot be fully expressed ind ecimal, but can be in a ternary system. Furthermore the numbers useful for counts can all be expressed in a decimal system. For example the number one hundred and one is exact. As to you examples about apples, you are trying to preach again instead of finding out. Isn't find out truth more interesting than holding to being wrong? How many electrons are there in a helium atom ?
-
Covid vaccination reaction figures.
Thank for telling us. +1 We should all do what we can to progress the situation, even if it is just swapping data. I'm glad someone reads my posts properly. +1
-
Hijack from Units?
It would be better if you listened a bit more and preached a bit less. The highlighted statement in you post is just plain wrong. There are many quantities in Science where the unit is 'counts'. In that case the unit is exact to any number of decimal place you care to mention. You do also realise there are many other numbers than are present in the decimal system ?
-
The Nature of Reality
I've seen nothing yet to make me think you understand those quite difficult concepts you are throwing about. Energy Infinity Singularity They all have very particular meanings in Science that are similar to but much more restricted than in general English. Please also take note of this excellent statement by swansont. +1
-
Does length contraction imply a superposition of particles? [answered: no]
A point worth making is that even a pancake has thickness.
-
Possibly a little closer to controlled fusion
I'm glad to see someone has the entire history of peaceful fusion at their fingertips. Not so glad to see they couldn't make better use of it than petty quibbling.
-
Possibly a little closer to controlled fusion
Whilst gravitational sources include some hydroelectricity generation collecting natural rainfall for the lake, no I was referring to tidal generation. The largest tidal generator in Europe was installed in Orkney a couple of weeks ago. 'Most powerful' tidal turbine starts generating electricity off Orkney - BBC News also see some older ones (Shetland) Case study: Nova Innovation - Shetland Tidal Array | Scotland's Marine Assessment 2020 Australia has lots of sun, we have lots of tides.
-
Does length contraction imply a superposition of particles? [answered: no]
Most people do not understand the origin of the term 'frames' and what makes them special and different from just coordinate systems. I am sure the OP is not listening to anything I say so I can't tell him. +1 for your previous post about the finger and eye experiment. Do you know about the second part of that experiment - the flying double thumb ? I think I am going to win that bet with myself that this thread will reach 5 pages of silly argument before the Moderators get fed up and close it.
-
Was Pangea, a Moon?
As a mechanical engineer you will be familiar with tech drawing and projections, perhaps less so with cartographic projections. You seem to be using a Mercator projection which does not preserve shape in the large. For that you need something like a Goude projection. (fig 18 here) https://www.cbsd.org/cms/lib010/PA01916442/Centricity/Domain/1691/Map Projections- Text.pdf Shape is actually a poorer indicator of continental fit than the rocks themselves. Are you aware of isotope distribution analyses we have for Earth material different extra terrestrial bodies ? Animated Mercator pictures that rotate large landmasses must of necessity distort the shapes as they rotate them, something you can see in your animation. Perhaps you could also offer some calculation of the masses involved in your 'ball' of extra terrestrial material and compare these with the masses of continental material on your map.
-
Does length contraction imply a superposition of particles? [answered: no]
This is a really clever trick, though I have never seen any conjuror perform it. Here is a picture of particles in superposition.
-
Human Rights in a pandemic
I have always loved this Norman Rockwell picture 600 × 635
-
Possibly a little closer to controlled fusion
Thank you for listening. It never was a mistake IMHO. But you missed some tricks out of your list. Geothermal and gravitational sources are both more reliable proven technology with a much greater service life expectancy than either wind or solar (of course both wind and solar rely on the same source).
-
The Nature of Reality
Surely this belongs in the stories section ? Sounds like a job for an EE Doc Smith's Lensman.
-
What does 'emergent' mean in a physics context (split from Information Paradox)
Sorry, that's nothing to do with pressure. Mistake. I wondered if you meant to refer to Curie temperature as emergent ? It is certainly a tipping point.
-
Was Pangea, a Moon?
I can't see why you merit a downvote for you opening post so I have added a balancing +1. It is clear from your second post that you are using old data, which is not only incomplete but in part incorrect to draw your conclusions. So you seem to have a genuine misunderstanding. Yes there have been many hypotheses over the years concerning the origin of the Moon and we still cannot be sure of the true origin. But, as we gather more data we can at least rule out those which do not fit observations.
-
Possibly a little closer to controlled fusion
I didn't say otherwise, did you not read the thread title ? This is completely off topic which is about using fusion energy to generate electricity. Read my comment you replied to again and you should be able to see that you have misread it.
-
Was Pangea, a Moon?
A water planet ? Where did the water come from ? With Techtonic plates ? How did they arise on a water planet? Where did I say there would commonality between moons ? But the composition of the Earth, Moon, comets, meteors, asteroids, and of course the other planets and moons in the system are all different. But comparisons can be drawn. There was a hypothesis the the opposite happened. The present Moon separated from the Earth, leaving behind the Pacific basin. I think lunar geology has since disproved this one.
-
Possibly a little closer to controlled fusion
The reason I mentioned steam driven generators at the end of the exchange line is that we don't have many other feasible generation methods to hook a fusion reactor to. MHD direct has not yet been made to work, although feasible in theory. Wind and water turbines, or solar panels are not really suitable.