Skip to content

swansont

Moderators
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by swansont

  1. https://physicsworld.com/a/earths-gravity-and-magnetism-have-unexpected-effects-on-the-human-genome-and-mitochondria/ The team’s results show that after 24 hours in the simulated zero-gravity environment, the genome’s organization and dynamics held up unexpectedly well. This result could be important for assessing the cellular-level effects of zero gravity during space travel, though Zidovska acknowledges that these aren’t the only genetic hazards that space travellers face. “In addition to zero gravity, we are also exposed to cosmic radiation in space, which is known to cause DNA damage,” she says. “Until now, however, it has been difficult to decouple the effects of zero gravity and this
  2. The first link is saying it’s a dead/bad link, but Answers in Genesis is a creationism organization and not a credible source. In any event you should quote the salient points of a link. In evolution DNA changes happen from generation to generation; they need to be inherited. If you have a DNA change that isn’t passed along, that mutation dies with the organism. You simply must make en effort to understand the basic science if you hope to comment on it.
  3. I can see where it might inform someone investigating foundational issues, since it’s possible it might inform someone of what experiment to pursue. If “what is its nature” tells you how it behaves, since the latter is what we can observe. But there are lots of things in physics where the model is just a mathematical construct and that seems to be objectionable to some We had someone talking about ontological purity (or something like that; was it Anton?) in recent memory so maybe there’s some OCD involved
  4. As I had recently mentioned in another thread, the broader theme of suggesting you can’t do physics without explicitly incorporating more philosophy has been around for a while. A lot of physics has been accomplished over the years, so I guess the way that could be true is that there is some physics we can’t discover without doing so, but the people insisting on that scenario never seem to have any workable new physics to offer. Part of that may be a lack of appreciation of how few are working on foundations of physics; pop-sci stories seem to over-emphasize certain areas like that and high-energy particle physics. I agree that access to consumer-grade ai likely feeds this.
  5. I think it also needs to be pointed out that doing good and being good are not the same thing. One might do something considered good but the motivation for doing so might be neutral, or perhaps even evil.
  6. And yet you’ve proposed an absolute reference frame
  7. That’s not how this works. Are you under the impression that anybody else here is a professional blogger? The burden of fact-checking before you post and including support for your claims is expected of everyone.
  8. There are things some people consider good and that others do not. Some people can be persuaded by the carrot, some compelled by the stick and some do not care. Some will be contrary just for the sake of being contrary and some owing to other motivations.
  9. How about addressing all of the objections raised thus far before adding to the entropy of the discussion.
  10. It could be that time travel requires an existing machine at the other end of the trip, and an object of equal mass has to be sent in the other direction A clock moving in a circular path at speed v will slow down uniformly, but if the center is moving at a speed u with respect to the background frame, the speed of the clock depends on u + v so it will vary along its path. GPS wouldn’t work (unless the earth is at rest in the background frame)
  11. The Zeno thread was not started by you. This was split because you responded to a comment about math having no ontology; it was an invitation for you to discuss it further, since that was off-topic for that thread. If you have a better name, you are free to suggest one If that’s what you want, you should have started a thread to discuss it, or see if any of the existing ones are still open. Which you can still do But I will point out that foundations of physics is only a small slice of the physics pie. As I said, I split this because of your tangent in responding to the comment that math has no ontology.
  12. This implies two clocks that are translating at equal speeds relative to the background frame will see their clocks slow down equally and tick at the same rate, even if they are moving relative to each other.
  13. We do this out of convenience, but there is no “must” One could e.g. evaluate a duration by comparing it with a half-life. We don't generally do so, but that’s because of practical utility, rather than epistemological utility If one only looks at conservation of energy, is it possible this just places a limit on how much energy it takes to run a time machine? Or that it merely imposes some restriction on free will/determinism or how we think about what time travel entails? Does a rock sent into the past actually disappear from the present? You have all the other things from the past that persist, but this suggests the rock somehow doesn’t. I submit that this merely puts a limit on what time travel could be but does not, by itself, forbid it.
  14. Indeed But one need not know anything about lasers in order to use one, nor must one contemplate the ontology in order to use an equation. A person can use an equation without knowing, or contemplating, its physical meaning. Some equations are developed while not understanding the mechanism behind the behavior they describe. And there are the many examples where the equations are just mathematical conveniences that do not refer to things that physically exist. Equations describe behavior of what we observe. There’s no requirement that the model describe reality.
  15. My point exactly. Not all of physics requires ontology. You should probably steer clear of trying to guess at what I’m convinced of. My take on the statement was that any ontology is found in how you use the equations, i.e. trying to model what we observe, not in the math itself. I have no idea how that would be off-topic for the discussion that was taking place.
  16. On some earlier occasions where someone insisted that physicists must incorporate more philosophy I asked which school would help me align a laser into an optical fiber. They were unhelpful in explaining. Perhaps you can explain the ontology involved. In my many years of learning physics, there was never any discussion of ontology. I know that some people do investigate it, but you seem to be insisting that you must. I’d like you to explain that. So your objection to The Vat’s statement is moot. It’s only when you added your own spin on it that there’s something to discuss. There’s nothing inherently wrong in the discussion, but for someone decrying confrontation, it seems like an interesting choice to springboard the discussion off of a manufactured disagreement
  17. Which do you want to discuss - ontology, or physics? But is there ontology of the math, or does ontology only come into play when you add the context of physics to it?
  18. Since you insist on posting crap with no substantiation, and persist in not explaining the relevance to your thesis, I don’t see why you should be allowed to. Are you really claiming that Swiss social benefits remained the same from ~1850-2020 or so? And without providing a reference for it? Even going back just 70 years we can see how much buying power has decreased “today's prices are 4.64 times as high as average prices in 1956, according to the OECD and the World Bank consumer price index for Switzerland. A franc today only buys 21.5% of what it could buy back then.” https://www.in2013dollars.com/switzerland/inflation This site has info; just the mention of new programs added thoroughly debunks your claim https://www.historyofsocialsecurity.ch/timeline All of the Russian army fighting in Ukraine are volunteers?
  19. Not for length or time, but there certainly are for mass and energy. One can’t take a general attitude that Planck scale describes the granularity of nature. One must explain why it does for some parameters but not others if you’re going to ignore how they are tied to gravitation and the limits of GR.
  20. What is meant by “hardware energy floor”? What is n, which does not appear in your equation?
  21. Do GRBs show this dispersion? What equation predicts the amount? And this limit is…what? Let’s see your falsifiable mechanisms
  22. Rather long-winded explanation of the obvious (these frequencies are a multiple of the fundamental) but the salient issues are the model of how this arises, what testable predictions it makes, and what experimental evidence supports it. The various frequencies that I mentioned result arise from QM. Your mechanism remains mystical in the sense that you don’t say how it arises. Physics doesn’t claim the Planck time is a fundamental limit of discreteness
  23. How do you show this discrete nature? Quantized solutions occur in QM despite the continuous nature of the math. Is the discussion about ontology or is it about physics?
  24. It quite literally “pulses” in a vacuum How does this “frame rate” tie into any atom’s oscillation rate, for whichever transition you want to investigate? Why does Rb-87 oscillate at 6.8 GHz? Or Rb-86 at 3 GHz? H at 1.4 GHz? (and these are just the hyperfine transitions in the ground state. There are a lot more possibilities) QM provides an answer that does not invoke the Planck time. You’ve provided no model and no evidence to show this. Math is not science
  25. The conclusion we’ve drawn is that the spin is quantized. Not that space is. A conjecture that demands much more rigor in order to consider.

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.