Everything posted by swansont
-
Your thoughts on Neil deGrasse Tyson
Outward is what you exert, but Newton's laws are about what is exerted on you. The force on an object moving in a circle (such as a rotating space station) is toward the center of the circle.
-
Your thoughts on Neil deGrasse Tyson
You say nope but then correctly point out that it’s centripetal force in both cases.
-
Your thoughts on Neil deGrasse Tyson
In freshman physics they point out that it’s centripetal force.
-
On Islam
! Moderator Note The phrasing of “tolerating” a religion and casting this in terms of immigrants, the implication that they are not part of the “developed world” and other parts, are contrary to rule 2.1. Wake up. Islamic people have already emigrated to western countries, and this alleged “barbaric” behavior is not seen. Replace the target with “Jews” and I’m guessing you can find similar discussion in past (and present) nazi literature.
-
Harris vs Trump;
50-50 chance, 9 out of 10 is just under 1% chance by random guessing, which is less than three sigma.
-
Any video evidence of unexplained phenomena captured by space telescopes ?
The scientists who gather the data get first crack at them. They are public domain; I think they are made available to everyone after a year. https://hubblesite.org/copyright “Unless otherwise specifically stated, no claim to copyright is being asserted by STScI and material on this site may be freely used as in the public domain in accordance with NASA's contract. However, it is requested that in any subsequent use of this work NASA and STScI be given appropriate acknowledgement.”
-
Your thoughts on Neil deGrasse Tyson
And the person who asked the question, and anyone else, is free to draw their own conclusion from that. Once again, this is not what I was addressing. You are assuming that a lack of commentary means something more; this is a phenomenon on social media where someone says, “I like dogs” and the response is “Why do you hate cats?” I don’t much care if it’s a failure of logic or active trolling. You addressed me by moving the goalposts, insinuating that I had somehow defended a proposition that had not been made. AFAICT the information I provided was factual and on-topic. And yet you keep trying to draw me into a confrontation. Truth be told, I haven’t watched much of NdGT, so I’m not in a position to critique or defend anything. I don’t watch much pop-sci physics (unless it’s in my wheelhouse and I’m commenting on it). That’s a choice. Being a dick is a choice, too.
-
Is this a recognized fallacy or tactic?
I don’t mind when assumptions are clearly labeled as such. It’s presenting them as if they were fact that I have an issue with. “If A then B” vs “A, therefore B”
-
Your thoughts on Neil deGrasse Tyson
The question I answered was “Can NdGT be called a scientist in your opinion, given that he's hardly published anything in 30 years?” I provided three papers he has. I didn’t attempt to address whether he’s a “working astrophysicist.” That’s not where the goalposts were. The thing is, my last first-author paper wasn’t much later than that, and have perhaps six of them. I’m on a few dozen papers total. I find this line of criticism kind of insulting. If someone used these criteria to suggest that I wasn’t a practicing physicist before I retired I would have told them to f%&# off into the sun.
-
Banned/Suspended Users
Anders Agerbo Andersen has been banned for spamming and soapboxing
-
Your thoughts on Neil deGrasse Tyson
The COSMOS collaboration involves >200 scientists. I’ve been on papers with lots of authors (dozens, at a particle collider, so lots of people work on the experiment in various ways) but that doesn’t mean I had a minimal contribution, and being very late can be because of how they list authors after the first author (like, say, alphabetical? Looks that way. T is late in the alphabet) You don’t have to like the guy, but this is just manufacturing reasons to bash him.
- On Islam
-
Why did Paul suggest that people should not marry?
You don’t get to change the parameters of someone else’s question just because it’s inconvenient
-
I may win a nobel for this: the dinosaur theory was bonkers!
! Moderator Note No, it doesn’t Feel free to ask questions to improve your knowledge, but we don’t have a WAG forum
-
I may win a nobel for this: 'The sun and the moon are planet earth...IN PARALLEL DIMENSIONS...
Because they happen to be at distances from the earth that their angular size is approximately the same. They aren’t exactly the same; the orbits are elliptical so the angular size varies. The moon’s orbit has changed over time, so this situation wasn’t always the case. ! Moderator Note Please try to include some science in your posts. Otherwise they will be moved to the trash
-
Why did Paul suggest that people should not marry?
“Normal” wasn’t part of this. The question was “What barbaric things do other animals do that humans don't?” Appending “normal” to this is a straw man (in case you’re not sure: that’s not something you should be doing)
-
Why did Paul suggest that people should not marry?
And rape exists in humans. Human women sometimes kill their husbands. Being punished by law is irrelevant to the point. The question was “What barbaric things do other animals do that humans don't?” (and the part about eating their mates is an exaggeration. It happens in one species of black widow https://www.burkemuseum.org/collections-and-research/biology/arachnology-and-entomology/spider-myths/myth-black-widows-eat)
-
Defining feminism in the digital age
To fend off the issue we saw in a recent thread, this does not mean treating women exactly the same as men. The issue here is also about equity, which not really the same as equality. Equal opportunities and equal outcomes, which don’t always happen by treating everyone exactly the same https://onlinepublichealth.gwu.edu/resources/equity-vs-equality/
-
Where Is The Science ?
If it’s just preaching, we’ll shut it down. If a pattern emerges that shows there’s an agenda, we’ll deal with it, but that sometimes takes time.
-
Defining feminism in the digital age
Is this a surprise? Social media is not academia. It seems to me you are leaning heavily on social media as your source here, and citing opinion rather than fact. People on social media have warped definitions for e.g. socialism, too. they want to use a hot-button word to evoke a response. That has more to do with people who like trolling than anything else. So what is it you want to discuss? Trolling on social media, or actual feminism? If it’s the latter, don’t be citing the former.
-
Where Is The Science ?
This is a statistical blip. One must remember that participation in these threads is voluntary.
-
Principle of Causality and Inertial Frames of Reference
! Moderator Note Then you do not have material that fulfills the requirements of the speculations section Do not reintroduce this subject
-
Strange happenings
Ghideon posted a screenshot that looks quite straight.
-
Strange happenings
A jump of any distance would follow a parabolic path, not a straight line. And a jump (especially upward) wouldn't be at ~constant speed
-
Strange happenings
What rodent would follow those paths, through the air?