Everything posted by sethoflagos
-
Messages to the president...
Is the it primary function of this site to communicate solely in a language both accessible to and acceptable to the "dinobrains of many of our fellow citizens" By "our" do you mean "(US of) American"? Is the consequent difficulty of communicating non-trivial ideas at a level that is both unambiguous and comprehensible to members from different cultures, whose first language may not be American English, of utterly no consequence? Inclusivity???? IMO your spelling of the word "prioritise" with a zed does nothing positive for the side of the debate you take. Compare and contrast. 😉 Do you see a majority narrow political consensus in contributors to this forum? I don't. Not for a moment. I see a bunch of very distinct individuals with a broad range of opinion. (ie Not all of us are Nazi dinobrains!) I admit, that was perhaps a bit of a wind-up on my part. (soz) As was the bit about your army being a model of socialism (soz @MigL ) I don't get out much.
-
Messages to the president...
Yes, I get this. His public statements on the national stage have to stay within the Overton window of 2020s America and may not fully reflect the depth and nuance of his personal beliefs. Maybe the odd little coded scratching noise to reassure progressives amongst East Coast academia etc. who are miore politically literate than the majority. He's probably pitching it about right to get across the key messages.
-
Messages to the president...
True, but the current polarisation in the US is on the authoritarian/liberal axis, not the capitalist/socialist axis .If this were true, he would support an orthodox socialist position along the lines of the our old (1918) Clause IV (UK Labour Party Rule Book) Sanders doesn''t support this. If he supports the intermediate mixed economy version of social democrats such as the SPD (and yours truly, moreorless) then he keeps it very much under wraps. There's no talk of common ownership of the health service, education, utilities, mass transit systems etc in the above clip. Perhaps I just wasn't listening at the right time. But that''s my understanding of a centre-left economic policy position. Funny how no one over there questions common ownership of the military. Guess Hegseth is the only true socialist leader you have.
-
Madhouse Politics and Green Energy - Solutions please.
To be clear, R here represents staged interventions by the grid to maintain frequency within statutary limits in response to imbalances, I, between generation and demand. In my day, 20% of UK average load was met by three stations (Ferrybridge, Eggborough, and Drax) strung out along just 15 miles of the Aire Valley at the heart of the grid. 14 turboalternators churning out 8 GW This centre was bolstered by a similar capacity generated by a string of somewhat smaller stations (Rugeley, Drakelow, Castle Donington, Ratcliffe-on-Soar, High Marnham, Cottam, and West Burton) on the Trent Valley. Between them, their huge combined angular momentum provided the cental 'flywheel' of the system, to which all more remote generation units were forced (by physics) to follow in both frequency and phase. The resulting high value of En resulted in exceptionally low fluctuations of grid frequency, and consequently very rare need for direct intervention by the grid. Hence, the historically excellent stability and reliability of the UK grid. As the paper referenced suggests, the transfer from coal to renewables will greatly reduce the rotational kinetic energy of grid supply. Essentially, it will become dominated by the considerably smaller nuclear component. And hence, if grid stability is to be maintained, there is going to be a far greater reliance on grid intervention, R. And key stages of this must activate within one second of notice. This is the real challenge to be faced by the transistion to renewables. Everything else is simple in comparison. A highly accessible brief overview of the points I tried to make above direct from the horse's mouth.
-
Messages to the president...
To be clear, by European standards, Bernie Sanders is a centre-right liberal capitalist. There is no significant constituency on the left in the US either amongst the general population or the political establishment. The only current coherent movement in the US is the authoritarian, might-is-right brigade on the right flank (whether coloured red or blue). The centre collapsed many years ago and despite the recent mid-term results remains on a long-term downward trajectory. It may be exhilarating to hear the new young crop of progressive voices, the Talaricos and Mamdanis etc. But make no mistake, they will be coopted one by one into the fold of the current political establishment over the next few years, or simply fall by the wayside. There is no centre ground in which they can put down roots. Yet I don't think the cause is as utterly hopeless as the above paragraph may at first suggest. Perhaps the current impetus can be harnessed into forming a sort of Tony Blairish New Labour flavoured constituency around the broad economic policy outlined by Sanders. Uniting the highly disparate demographic groups necessary to form a majority coalition under such a flag would require a lot of hard work by many talented people willing to set aside their significant personal policy differences on non-economic issues. It may well need a new party. It certainly needs numbers. Lots of them.
-
Messages to the president...
Properly publicised among the online community, an online petition in support of just those policies Bernie mentions (and absolutely nothing else) should get overwhelming public support. See how brave Schumer and co. are when 100 million signatures unite in common cause. Oddly enough, a few hours before the Bernie clip showed up, I was thinking about a Wealth Tax and wondered if going as high as 2% per annum might be politically viable. Didn't realise how myopic I was being.
-
Messages to the president...
Dear wannabe presidents You know it makes sense.
-
Messages to the president...
Will it be the Canard à l'orange tonight, Sir?
-
Can this contraption be calculated ?
Recommended Citation Wang, Yanbo, "A Study Of Two-Phase Flow Regime And Pressure Drop In Vertical Pipe" (2018). Theses and Dissertations. 2435. https://commons.und.edu/theses/2435 I'm not going to go through the full paper, but the correlation maps on pps 4-5 (horizontal and vertical flow respectively) are well-established. I've used them often in designing 2-phase steam/condensate systems, and elsewhere.
-
A G 7 8
- A G 7 8
Apologies to anyone whose already seen this. The title represents four cards, each of which is known with certainty to have a letter on one side and a numerical digit on the other. Which card(s) must one turn over to confirm that the set is compatible with the statement "All cards with an A on one side have a 7 on the other"? Please hide answers and reasons, and mention if you've seen it before.- How can people be persuaded (or compelled?) to do (or be?) good ?
Seems like my example set off some unexpected alarm bells. I really wasn't trying to trick anyone here. Anyway, the moment has now passed.- How can people be persuaded (or compelled?) to do (or be?) good ?
How? You've just spent three days denying the plausibility of a 'What if?' scenario that might accomplish this. (It was a just a thought experiment ffs 🙂)- Sparks of Life
The earth is a sufficiently large environment and a billion years a sufficiently long time for the term "almost certainly" to be pretty unconvincing. PS I had to switch my VPN to Italy to get that video to load.- Sir Patrick Stewart Passed away
For me, it has to be Sejanus from I Claudius (with Brian Blessed, John Hurt, Derek Jacobi, Sian Phillips, Margaret Tyzack, George Baker, Ian Ogilvy. John Rhys-Davies) - best cast for a TV drama series ever.- Sparks of Life
A better programme may have mentioned the word "catalysis" at least once. Also that if a particular chemical species does not exist at one particular time and place, then its removal rate is zero, while it's chance of production can never be. This asymmetry is enough to guarantee that if it can occur then sometime, somewhere, it will. For a truly self-replicating molecule, once is enough. The actual 'spark of life' was a rare but under the prevailing conditions, inevitable mechanism occurring at the molecular level. Without this insight, the global fireworks provided no real insight. Just the usual hyperbolic clickbait. Liked the geology side though, even if the biology was a bit of a damp squib.- How can people be persuaded (or compelled?) to do (or be?) good ?
Emily is fond of Abba and Aha! Perhaps she keeps So Many Dynamos tucked away in a drawer somewhere. Who knows.- Is It Time To Get Serious About Recycling Human Waste?
Pig slurry recycling is a pretty well-established farming practice. Actually, I've just had a rather memorable Kekulé/Ouroboros Dream moment I went to bed wondering if I was absolutely sure about the guff I'd posted above. I sort of knew the dilution entropy equation was right (I did check just in case), but I wasn't 100% sure I understood why. Three hours later, my subconscious (?) shook me wide awake and showed me an TS diagram of a standard Carnot Engine. Immediately, I became aware that dilution is analogous to a heat engine, concentration to a heat pump. Also that the same form of equation must apply to diminution (eg grinding), packaging, product distribution, bag filters, electrostatic precipitators, chemical precipitation, rainfall and much, much more. Expansion of the universe perhaps (or am I getting ahead of myself). Also explained why the logarithmic term can be a ratio of concentration, mass fraction, density, temperature, partial pressure, activity etc., according to context. Beats having to actually think about it. But I better still work through it in the morning (which will probably now be sometime in the afternoon). And now I've got to find out what the hell homospatial and janusian processes are. Photosynthesis, respiration, and transpiration. It's a bag of worms! Unbagged dispersing worms! All eating their tails.- How Resistant Are Latex and Nitrile Gloves to Different Chemicals?
I want it on a greeting card that reads 'Of course I love you, Darling!'- Is It Time To Get Serious About Recycling Human Waste?
Apparently not. So I''ll have a little monologue on the thermodynamics of phosphorus recovery. Recovering anything from diluted form invokes an unavoidable entropic cost of TdS = RT ln(source concentration/product concentration) Therefore a ten-fold concentration with waste heat exhaust to 300K costs an absolute minimum of 5.7 kJ/mol or 180 kJ/kg (phosphorus) ~ 0.050 kWh/kg ~ $0.01 /kg Doesn't sound much, does it? Commercial phosphorus in some arbitrary form is ballpark $1 /kg based on currently worked reserves. Each of us produces ~ 1 g of phosphorus in about 1 kg of urine per day, a thousand-fold dilution. Hence due to logarithmic dependency, a three-fold cost wrt ten-fold dilution ~$0.03 /kg) Spread over 8 billion people that's a surcharge of ~$90 million per annum to meet ~ 20% of current world phosphate fertiliser demand (currently a ~$75 billion pa industry) Compare with extraction from deep seawater @ ~ 100 ppb (107-fold dilution) where that minimum waste heat cost rockets up to $0.07 /kg Now all we need is the technology to perform the processes efficiently, the CAPEX financing, and the will-power to face up to future unavoidable challenges. No biggie.- How Resistant Are Latex and Nitrile Gloves to Different Chemicals?
Never bothered with gloves when handling spam or chemicals. Still got most of my fingers.- How can people be persuaded (or compelled?) to do (or be?) good ?
I won't push it, but human society does have some debatable signs of domestication : fairly low in-group violence; a bit of neoteny - flat face, short canines etc. This is the paradox: This is not a binary choice: balances have to be struck. One reason I lean more toward the Golden Mean than the Golden Rule.- How can people be persuaded (or compelled?) to do (or be?) good ?
Would it not cause some reduction in gene pool diversity? If exercised carefully could this 'survival by judicial selection' over many generations help to gradually improve social cohesion? Your statement seems to suggest by logical extension that you don't see 'domestication' as being guided by such processes, which would be counter to my (albeit lay) understanding. I think our understanding of Hobson''s Choice is a little different (set work in our school Eng Lit class)- How can people be persuaded (or compelled?) to do (or be?) good ?
Thought experiment for you. Imagine you are part of a nomadic hunter-gatherer community in palaeolithic East Africa. One evening around the campfire you have a debate amongst the elders about whether or not to stop your traditional practice of lethally excluding excessively sociopathic adolescents from your community. a) What impact might the decision have on everyday levels of reciprocal behaviour within the community? b) Does a) produce a paradox? c) Which is the 'good' option: the reciprocal, or the non-reciprocal?- How can people be persuaded (or compelled?) to do (or be?) good ?
We are, and always have been, moulded by society from birth (conceivably a little before that). For better or for worse. I say that, because it is not a matter of 'good' or 'bad' per se, Rather a matter of behaving in sympathy with one's immediate environment. And this environment expands from the womb to immediate family, to extended family to community. And for most of our history, there it stopped. The common good was literally behaviour that served the interest of one's community of several hundred to perhaps a thousand people in one's immediate environment. This is what we are evolved to do, and along the way developed cultures to justify, record, and embed the necessary conditioning process. Does it retain currency? Of course it does. I suspect I'm not the only one here to have covetted a neighbour's wife on occasion, yet managed not to take it beyond a fleeting private fancy for... reasons. Does it really matter whether those reasons are based on fear, altruism, empathy, or religious conviction? I'm not overendowed with any of those, yet still always steered towards safer waters. Apparently, even the 'covetting' bit was a mortal sin so I wouldn't claim that this choice was necessarily 'good'. Just seemed the better option at the time. The key point is that the social conditioning worked one way or another. @exchemist gives a very good example of how this idea is still valid in the vastly extended communities of our modern nation states in his attitude to income tax. What I would like to discuss further is the role of the tax advisors who didn't understand his disinterest in tax avoidance. Tax advisors don't even make a pretence of acting in the common good. At least not the one's I've met. They are representative of a class of people who actively promote personal greed (another of the classical vices) over the interests of wider society for their own nefarious gain. This splinters society individual by individual and normalise destructive behaviour. By extension, I would extend this to the entire edifice of neoliberalism, as individual greed does seem to be a founding principle of that economic model. It seems to be spectaculary successful at fracturing societies. And then there is the principle of 'divide and rule'. How could this ever be a successful agent of social cohesion? The clue is in the name. The xenophobia that might have helped prehistoric tribes survive amongst hostile neighbours was at least partly understood as divisive in classical times. It is entirely out of place in modern nation states. There's still hope. Many of us still have access to the ballot box. And Ukraine has recently shown us how to deal effectively with chatbots. Simulpost with @TheVat - A G 7 8
Important Information
We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.