Skip to content

Eise

Senior Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Eise

  1. But it never was! Even that the 'laws of nature' are called 'laws', laws nature must obey, this is a wrong way of speaking: laws of nature are abstract descriptions of how nature behaves. One finds this metaphorical way of speaking also with scientists, but most (I hope) know this is just a matter of speaking. And if you describe this machinery, you do the same as describing how it works, just as the existing 'laws of nature'. The 'laws of nature' are not a map. They are rules which a map must obey, to be a valid description of (part of) physical reality. The laws of nature, and the boundary conditions of the system you are interested in, determine the map. As a simple example: the exact prediction of when a sun eclipse starts is an example of such a map. We use Newtonian mechanics as 'the laws', and the boundary conditions are given by the positions and velocities of the moon earth and sun (and maybe tiny corrections because of other planets) to create this map.
  2. Really? Deuteronomy 4:19, New Revised Standard Version, Updated Edition And when you look up to the heavens and see the sun, the moon, and the stars, all the host of heaven, do not be led astray and bow down to them and serve them, things that the Lord your God has allotted to all the peoples everywhere under heaven.
  3. Yep. But see one of my disclaimers: For a better understanding, I would suggest to read Dennett's Consciousness Explained. He was one of the most science oriented philosophers, and only passed away about a year ago, he definitely was not a 'freewheeling philosopher': his intellectual feet were thoroughly grounded in neurology, cognitive science and philosophy. It's a difficult (and long) read, sure, but it pays off to recognise the 'philosophical baggage' you are heavily leaning on.
  4. Sounds good OK, but beware of 'greedy reductionism'. And I think your 'simply' also appears in that (short) Wikipedia article as 'nothing-buttery'. In Intuition Pumps and Other Tools for Thinking Dennet calls it the 'just-operator'. And the same for you, @DrmDoc, many times worse than for iNow. This same 'engine propelling that function' is also propelling the liver, kidneys, etc. But we had that argument already, and I will not dive in again.
  5. Nope. I am assessing it by what mental capabilities would be needed to explain the organism's behaviour. I already mentioned elephants. I could add delphins, wales, crows, parrots etc. (and iNow mentioned octopuses, which I at least not disagree with.) In short: all animals that show behaviour, for which it is needed to have a cognitive map of their environment, and the possible alternative for their actions in the environment (sometimes known as planning). And capable of learning, of course. When the behaviour of an organism can be fully explained by simple 1 to 1 reactions on changes in their physical and chemical environment, where such a 'cognitive map' is not necessary, I assume it has no consciousness. And then I would ask: what kind of complexity? This 'simply' (an example of the 'just-operator') and this added 'complexity' do not fit well in your sentence. In fact, if you would leave out that 'simply', we are not that far apart in our conceptions. For me consciousness arises in at least some minimal kind of complexity of underlying automatons. Science that wants to understand consciousness is worth nothing when it stops understanding consciousness before explaining why exactly these automatic reactions lead to consciousness. You are not wrong: but you are just giving up to understand consciousness, seeing the complexity in front of you. And of course 'just' homeostasis' doesn't do the job either...
  6. Granted, I exaggerated. But otherwise, yes, a bit more nuanced. But not much. Assigning consciousness to plants and bacteria is a few steps too far. Yes, there are rationales for how plants, bacteria and jelly fish behave. But it is us that recognise these rationales. Plants, bacteria, and jelly fish do not behave the way they do by recognising there rationales them selves. But we do.
  7. As can those of humans Sure, we can also explain life and consciousness on the level of elementary particles, no? I cannot, no. I’ve not formalized my thinking on this to that level of specificity. Well, at least I have some suggestions. One of them is when it turns out that we can only explain the behaviour of an organism by assuming that it has a mental picture of its environment and its position in it. Automatic reactions like 'swim away because some unpleasant environmental substance is around me' doesn't count. Elephants making a detour, because they know there is water on that way certainly would. Bacteria and jelly fish do not do that. So this is definitively not enough: A thermostat would fit that definition.
  8. First, I did not mention a CNS, I said 'the nervous system as a whole'. Secondly, it seems to me that your criterion for what behaviour counts as 'conscious behaviour' gets lower and lower. I am with you with octopuses, but jelly fish and even slime molds? I think their 'intelligent behaviour' can easily be explained by chemical or physical gradients, on which they react automatically. What about plants that 'follow the sun', or roots that 'search for water'? What about bacteria? Can you more explicit about what your criteria for being conscious are, maybe with some examples, especially close to the border line conscious-not conscious?
  9. Good counter example. Then it would be interesting to give an octopus a some tasks in an MRI. But I foresee some practical problem with such a setup... 😉 The background of my arguments, is that our consciousness is an emergent property of the nervous system as a whole. That could be true for an octopus as well. At least they also seem capable of learning. So from my, admittedly 'Dennettian view', would be if his 'multiple draft' model of consciousness could also work for the different organised nervous system of an octopus.
  10. You obviously don't know much about life in Europe (says I, a Dutchman living in Switzerland). You are suffering heavily under rightwing propaganda.
  11. Yes, but same as the authors of the article: not the cortex alone.
  12. Hi DrmDoc, I think one should read this very precisely. I made the the important phrases bold. activating the prefrontal cortex: One can read this as: the thalamus selects where consciousness is needed. For consciousness, the prefrontal cortex must be activated rather than cortical areas alone: I read this as, the prefrontal cortex has no direct connection with the senses. The thalamus makes some kind of 'pre-selection' when consciousness is needed, Both are supported by the observation that when learning something new, consciousness is heavily involved. But with enough training, one sometimes can react correctly before consciousness is even involved. (Consciousness is relatively slow). Then look at the symptoms when somebody suffers a stroke in the thalamus: absent or abnormal sensation on one side of the face, arm, and leg sensory changes involving: touch pain temperature pressure vision hearing taste mild or moderate weakness on one side of the body My interpretation would be that that because of the stroke the pathways to other parts of the brain are disturbed. And from the article's final paragraphs: Bold by me again. From that it follows that I do not agree that iNow's proposal would work: Maybe all 'higher organisms' have a thalamus. But they are missing the cortex that would make their actions conscious actions. AFAIK all vertebrates have a thalamus. Here I completely agree with @TheVat: sense of self and consciousness are not the same thing. Same for me. No. I hope you see why in my above comments.
  13. Yes, I am a machine. A very advanced biological machine. It means that I am able to picture my environment, see my position in it, and able to reflect on the possible effects of my actions. Because I learned language in a natural environment, I also learned the use of the concept of 'I', and how to use it. That also made me capable of recognising my peers, and value them as such. And what are 'flavours of sensation'? Of course I know what sensations are, but the fact that I can categorise them doesn't make them 'qualia'. Maybe you should read Dennett's critique on the concept of qualia. You can read it here (pdf of chapter 12 of 'Consciousness explained'). I cite the epigraph of that chapter, for everyone that isn't interested in reading the complete chapter (43 pages...): Thrown into a causal gap, a quale will simply fall through it.
  14. I don't perceive qualia either. I perceive things around me, or hunger or thirst. But I never perceived one single quale in my life.
  15. No joke. I had to use sometimes. The point was this: I had software with which I could open a virtual desktop on another server, which was configured completely in French, including the keyboard. To type the correct characters I used such a 'key map'. E.g if I wanted to type a Q I had to use the A-key. So this is a 'correspondence' map, not what the real French keyboards look like. This is what the French look at: Another mean thing: if you want to type a number, you must use the shift key. Exactly the opposite of any other national keyboard I know of.
  16. Well, in the end I bought the device. Together with the app, it is super. A few examples: Running measurements: Of course you can zoom. The grey lines are measurements every second, the coloured lines are running averages. The latter are stored in the device, and can be exported as csv. (I do not understand 'Hardness' yet. It suggests the strongest line in the spectrum, on which a guess is made about the isotope, Thorium-232 in the example.) Then there is the complete spectrum, but it looks as a complete mixture: The magenta vertical line I put there, to find out which isotope produces the peak. I red-framed the device's suggestion by what this line is produced. It also shows other lines (red/green) that show other frequencies that might be expected, but the fit is poor. And then the export: I put it into Excel and made a graph of it: Everywhere I go, the levels are different (counts/second). The higher levels are from my living room. my 'home office' has less radiation as my living room: wooden floor in the first, stone floor in the latter. So you can exactly see when I had my breaks. The first night I left the device in the living room, as baseline for future measurements (stored it in the device) The next day I went to work, and interestingly, the level decreases during the trip. Moving away from the mountains? Opposite turning home, of course. Coffee breaks can be recognised, I assume because of the tiles outside. Toilet and entry hall have nature stone tiles... Second night I took the device upstairs to my bedroom After sleep I was a short time in the living room, then went for a swim, returned to my living room, and went to work again. On average I got 1.51 µS/h, which would make 1.32mS/year. That is above the limit for persons not working with radioactive sources... (in CH). For professionals it is 20mS/year. Still a lot to learn, but I am not disappointed! Oh, btw, this is what the device looks like:
  17. Easy workaround: click on your avatar, you get (example of my account: And click the button. Works for others too, only with another text on the button:
  18. As far as the HUP is involved, sure. Remember AM radio? There were times that radio stations started broadcasting shortly before the program started. At that moment, you could tune very precisely, namely at the narrow point where the radio became nearly silent. As soon as the program started, there was no precise point anymore, you could already hear the program if you did not tune in exactly: the bandwidth had increased, because the frequency was not precise anymore. The extreme case were very short pulses: lightning. One could hear that over more or less all AM bands, so the frequencies were extremely spread out. I am wondering about the unequality Studiot mentioned: compare with 'Küpfmüller's uncertainty principle (1924)': delta f . delta t > 1/2 Replace f with E/h and you get: delta E . delta t > h/2 Pretty close to the HUP, isn't it? Basic knowledge for radio amateurs, I would say.
  19. I think you should make clearer what the differences between philosophy of consciousness and science of consciousness are. Science should always take a 'third party' viewpoint. It looks at its object of interest from a neutral view point, i.e. knowledge it gathers, must be valid for other observers too. This, per definition excludes the 'me' and 'you' perspective, exactly the perspectives where consciousness is most 'visible'. So how you define consciousness is a methodological restriction to which all science is necessary subjected. Your definition, 'the awareness suggested by an organism's observed behavioral responses to stimuli', is so to speak a proxy for science to investigate consciousness. Dennett suggests another approach: heterophenomenology, which opens a door at least to the 'you perspective'. And do not forget one of my disclaimers: There is no such thing as philosophy-free science; there is only science whose philosophical baggage is taken on board without examination. Philosophy speaks with many voices, you pick out just one: and nowhere I mentioned an 'etheral, overriding sense of self that comprise our individuality'. Sure: there must be an evolutionary advantage for this complexity of behaviour. But what is interesting is that this seems to lead necessarily to consciousness,in the first and second party perspective. At least it is difficult to see how a (human) animal can anticipate what will or might happen in its environment, and even more, can see what might happen dependent on its own possible actions, and then select its action dependent on the most advantageous action without being aware of itself. Really? The kidneys do this too, it is 'chemical substances cancelling'. But with the kidneys we can safely take the third party perspective: here this perspective is not a crutch to approach the object of research. Eh? Well this is highly speculative. And why should I perceive this? Nothing in the purely scientific approach suggest that perception by 'I' plays a role, because it is excluded from the beginning, as an methodologically limitation of science. Unless one takes first- and second party perspectives seriously, one is far away from an explanation of consciousness. Heterophenomenology is an Ansatz to break this barrier.
  20. OK, I must make this more precise: the neural processes that give rise to consciousness are complicated. And I do not see what your operational definition of consciousness contributes to the discussion: First I would suggest to add as a rule of thumb: the bigger the spectrum of possible actions, the better capability to foresee possible futures dependent on one's own actions (from elephants taking a detour because they know there will be a place to drink, to human animals building the LHC) etc, the more conscious an animal is. So yes, the complexer the spectrum of possible actions is, the complexer the physical system must be to generate such behaviour. Second you are missing the first person perspective. I know I am aware, and because I can talk and coordinate actions with other individuals of my species, who also say they are aware, I attribute consciousness to them too. So what is missing: Metzinger, The Ego Tunnel But exactly that is what must be explained, if you want to explain consciousness. The kidneys strive for homeostasis too, but they produce waste and lead it to the organs that can get rid of it in the external world. So the question is why does the brain 'produces thoughts and behaviours', and not, as an example, body waste. And that exactly is what need to be explained: what is special about the brain that it can 'produce thoughts and behaviours'?* I cannot deny that some hierarchy between thalamus and cortex can play a role, I don't know enough about such matters, but I am sure that this Ansatz, how correct it may be, is never enough to explain consciousness. *If you want to be consistent with your definition of consciousness, you should only say 'behaviour'.
  21. A dangerous endeavor. 'Essentialism' , IMHO, is a wrong track when dealing with such a complicated phenomenon as consciousness. Do not take the analogy too far. I only want to show that some overall principle does not explain anything. A computer chip tries the whole time not to get an overall charge under changing inputs, and does it by the physical means it has: but it is exactly the complexity of how these processes are running that make the chip useful in a computer. Not that it evens out input and output currents. To say it cryptically: the essence of the computer chip lies in its complexity. Without understanding the complexity, you do not understand the workings of the computer chip at all. Same with the brain: without understanding the complexity, you do not understand the workings of the brain at all. And this difference exactly is what we must understand. Not what the brain has in common with other organs.
  22. Didn't you notice that I said 'extremely reductionist'. And that I said: To add: my position here is reductionist too: but to explain consciousness with such a global concept as homeostasis, is an example of 'nothing-buttery' ('nothing-but-ism'). The explanation of consciousness might lie in the mechanism how the brain arrives (or stays) in homeostasis. The most extreme case of nothing-buttery is of course to say we are nothing but hydrogen, oxygen, carbon, and some other elements put together. So I mix this elements in a vat (pun intended...) and exclaim 'Ecce homo'!. Does the liver, reaching for homeostasis, also produces conscious behaviour? I noticed that you did not react on my analogy of the workings of a microchip. You can be sure that a microchip really strives for getting the input currents and the output currents equal. But it explains nothing: a light bulb does that too. Without taking into account all the layers of how the components of a microchip work together, you explain nothing. Same with homeostasis. The rest of your reaction is just a repetition of what you said in your postings before. As a philosopher, I completely agree. But I would invite you to deliver reactions on the content of a thread. If you really have something to say, or to ask, you are welcome. I wonder if you ever contributed to a topic, or only do some chitchat in your postings. This is a discussion platform.
  23. OK, I chime in. Your position seems extremely reductionist to me. Striving for homeostasis is more or less what all organs do, so it does not explain much. As theVat, I also think you have dualist 'residues' in your thinking. Trying to locate consciousness in a part of the brain can be such a residue. Where is consciousness located? There where efferent neural paths meet afferent paths? Isn't there the control room of the homunculus? Are you sure your ideas are not another version of Dennett's 'Cartesian theater'? I have nothing against reductionism, but surely against its 'Greedy variant'. As an analogy: would you explain the workings of a microchip with its striving for equaling out input currents with output currents? (But it does, otherwise it would not work.) No, close to the lowest level, a microchip is transistors, then flip-flops, then logical gates, then adders and subtractors, functional subsystems etc, until you have a full blown computer that is programmable. It will not be much different (except maybe much more complex...) for the brain and the mind.
  24. A bad joke, yes. Better improve the quality of your posts. Only ask serious questions; take the answers seriously Only react on topics you have some expertise, Stop posting internet memes If you like humor, we have at least 2 threads for that: one general in the lounge, and one in politics And if you have only (your kind of) humor to share here, I suggest you look for another forum If you just go on like this, I'll request the administrators to close your account. This is a serious discussion platform.

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.