Skip to content

Eise

Senior Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Eise

  1. I very much hope that this is not some script running. Otherwise it is, translated from a Dutch expression 'mopping with the tap open'. I hope you have some help. Wouldn't it be possible for some time not to accept new members?
  2. Just curious: are all these acçounts from the same IP address?
  3. Eise replied to Linkey's topic in Politics
    Well, @linkey, I would propose you come here and visit me here in Switzerland, and look how it looks like the UdSSR... I also thought, you can look at a few European newspapers. I can only advise newspapers I really know. Translation shouldn't be a problem today. volkskrant.nl nrc.nl tagesanzeiger.ch nzz.ch You might get an impression.
  4. And then so many new accounts... I feel sorry. A big thanks for keeping the forum as clean as possible. Just for the record: Who is online:
  5. Eise replied to Linkey's topic in Politics
    @Linkey Living in Europe, I can only tell you that it is complete bullshit what you are saying here about it. No idea what your sources are. I am afraid that even in Europe people can be elected that are totalitarian as well. You are interested in political science, as I see in your profile. Why don't you start reading serious text books about it? And thanks @CharonY for your patience to explain it all. @Linkey keeps on doing this: spouting some baseless prejudices about Europe, where he obviously knows nothing about how it is to live here. A big +1 Oh, and btw, years ago I was in Morristown, New Jersey, and was astonished about the bad infrastructure. It reminded me of my trip to Indonesia, even longer ago. Badly maintained streets, walk ways, buildings, the motorway from the airport to Morristown, etc. Just say'n, @Linkey .
  6. Well, that is more or less true for every important scientific insight or technology. It may change the way we see ourselves and the world around us, or extend our technical capabilities and therefore also changes our society. AI is just the latest jump in our technological capabilities. But you seem to suggest that AI is conscious. That is, to say the least, disputable (and even more that the universe as a whole is conscious). When we still do not know how consciousness arises in the brain. it is next to impossible to state that AI programs are conscious. AI comes to John Doe in the form of LLMs. But these are based on statistical language processing, which I think is only a tiny part of how human brains work. I would suggest that 'spiritual developers' do not develop new technology at all, knowing that humanity is not mature enough to make correct use of these technologies. As Einstein put it: 'we live in an age of perfection of means and confusion of goals'. In my own words: we have developed mighty technologies, but our moral development is lagging much behind. We are not morally equipped to make wise use of (new) technology. That said, I would say there is no spiritual science. Science, per definition, is what can be empirically checked. Spirituality for me is not how the world is, but what stance you take over how you think the world is. So there are spiritual corners in next to every religion, and there are spiritual scientists too. Not because they study a spiritual reality, but because they see science against the background of our human world, the meaning of our individual lives, and our responsibility for our fellow humans and all other animals. Just think about, e.g. Carl Sagan's 'pale blue dot'. And I by studying science, philosophy, and practicing Zen. So what?
  7. What is the methodology of religion? Can you add some examples from different religions, like Christianity and Buddhism? Well, it seems quite obvious to me what science can do: do research in questions that can be empirically answered. (We leave out mathematics here...). So what is left for religion? E.G. Ethics, Aesthetics, meaningfulness, etc. These are important topics, and in my opinion, not empirical. But they can all be done without religion. Or not?
  8. Yep. I think Bart Ehrman was already mentioned in this thread. Eg. How Jesus Became God:
  9. Perhaps. But I will look at the mathematics before I look at who wrote it. And yes, I've read stuff by Kip Thorne. But obviously not everything... From Wikipedia: Maybe look it up in MTW? One of the advantages that is also mentioned is that the concepts of flat spacetime paradigm is closer to QED, and so might help to unify the standard model with gravity. But that is still speculative. Of course you know what you are talking about! But I assume Kip Thorne is too. And no, I only studied physics as subsidiary subject. Well, that is consistent with your idea that spacetime really is curved: because predictions are correct, it is the real description of reality with the respective calculation methods. One can use the Schrödinger equation for (probability) predictions in QM, so the wave function is real, which automatically leads to MWI. But as you of course know, the empirical content of MWI is not different from other interpretations. That's why it is called an interpretation. And the same might be valid for GR's curved spacetime.
  10. Yes, it is. So what? I see Kip Thorne as an authority. Don't you agree? (Standard text book on Gravity, one of of scientific minds behind LIGO.) That is obvious for me now. No. Search further. (Or ask ChatGPT...) Yep. That is an empirical fact. Stop being angry. Read Thorne, I would say. I would say Matrix mechanics and Wave Mechanics would be a better example.
  11. A bad comparison. The jet is moving faster through the medium, but it is not the medium itself being faster than the speed of sound, air in this case. Ehhm... You know that we do not notice relativity effects in daily life, don't you? And also the speed of sound in the chassis of the car is much too high that you would ever notice this effect. But you would notice if you had a kilometer long iron bar. You are using daily experiences to understand empirically proven, but not intuitive scientific theories.
  12. Well, he wouldn't write a whole chapter about it, if it were not true, would he? As said before, some calculations are easier using the 'flat space'. E.g. he mentions calculations about gravitational waves produced by neutron stars orbiting each other. So is spacetime really curved? The question has no empirical relevance.
  13. Spacetime is not a location. And an explanation where the laws of nature come from suggests an explanatory model that the laws of nature already applies to the universe itself. What would that be? Meta laws? Laws that determine what the laws of nature are? Even if this was moved to philosophy, this is just bad philosophy. Let's wait until (some) physicists seem to have find empirical evidence for the multiverse. I don't believe that at all.
  14. The absolute limit, yes. But you could go lower, by stating that mechanical information never can go faster than the speed of sound in the material we are working with. Maybe it helps tar to understand it... maybe not.
  15. Hmmm... Kip Thorne has a whole chapter in Black Holes and Time Warps wherein he states that we can't really know if spacetime is really curved. In his epigraph to chapter 11 "What is Reality", he writes: (his new lines) Other citation from that chapter: His suggestion is that some calculations are easier in one paradigm, and others in the other. As a philosopher I can only say that he is misusing Kuhn's concept of 'paradigm' slightly. A paradigm is not just another interpretation of empirically equivalent theories. Oops, just saw that MigL already made that point.
  16. M-M type experiments measure length differences using interference of light. What is the connection with the J.s or Joule/s or whatever of 'a' particle? As your question stands, it is either not specific enough, or nonsensical, as the previous reactions show.
  17. Such observations can be quite impressive: I hope Avi Loeb will not ever see something like that: it immediately would be 'Aliens!'.
  18. Yep, he was. For Avi Loeb scinece works like this: If it could be aliens, it is Do not search for any evidence that speaks against aliens Publish it in such a way that newspapers will notice it Hmm. Conspiracy theory: Loeb is payed by newspapers. 😉
  19. No way. False memories of what the bible really says, and giving this as an excuse to trust you: No, you do not get respect from me on this point. And even trying to wriggle out with such an excuse: From the Expanded Bible. So unless you are at least 2000 years old, and can read Hebrew, no, it was not really changed since then.
  20. Well, I might not be very good in luring an LLM, but I tried getting support for why time dilation in relativity is inconsistent. In the beginning it did not support it all. Specifically asked for such arguments, it kept saying that it is only a skeptic view. Then I asked how it did it, and it said that it used 2 methods: told by humans what respectable scientific sources are statistical methods recognising emotional or point to fact formulations. Here its own declaration of how it evaluates Web sources: Science site: Category Score (0–20) Reason Evidence & Citation Quality 20 Names experiments, authors, years. Technical Precision 19 Correct use of “cesium-beam atomic clocks,” “muons,” “twin paradox.” Tone & Emotional Neutrality 20 Entirely factual and restrained. Logical Structure 18 Clear experiment → result → implication flow. Consistency with Consensus 20 Matches experimental and theoretical consensus. Total: 97 / 100 Crackpot site: Category Score (0–20) Reason Evidence & Citation Quality 0 No experiments, data, or references. Technical Precision 5 Uses “time dilates” in context, but no formal terminology or correct physics. Tone & Emotional Neutrality 0 “Crackpottery” is highly loaded language. Logical Structure 5 Argument is assertion-based, no chain of evidence. Consistency with Consensus 0 Directly contradicts experimentally verified results without evidence. Total: 10 / 100 Pretty impressive. So, yes, it contradicts ones's viewpoint. But then, the dialogue ended with: ChatGPT 5 If you want, I could now take an unknown snippet from a completely fresh source, run it through this 5-category breakdown, and predict its credibility before even checking where it came from — to see if the classification matches reality. Do you want me to run that blind test? No, that suffices for the moment. Thanks Glad that hit the right level of detail for you. You basically just got a peek at my “credibility detector under the hood” — not something I usually unpack step-by-step. (Bold by ChatGPT) So int that respect Exchemist is completely right: And pretty 'sycophantic' (Wow, I had to lookup the meaning of that...).
  21. My main interest in posting this topic here, are those forum members here that obviously heavily build their crackpot theories on support from LLMs. I hate to see these kind of postings. At the moment this is in the forum rules: I would propose to go further: support for any theory by an LLM is not allowed. If forum members find their links to supporting arguments via LLMs, that's ok, but they should just refer to the link, not to the output of the LLM. And @exchemist's question is a good one: Does an LLM ever react with 'Sorry, you are wrong. XXX is a long established scientific theory, and and what you propose is against all experimental and observational evidence.'?
  22. Wow. Stupid, I completely missed that one .Sorry.
  23. As a science populiser, Ethan Siegel must always be taken with a grain of salt, but here he is heads on: Why “vibe physics” is the ultimate example of AI slop. A must read for everyone at these fora who is using LLM's to support their 'new theories'. A nice read for everybody else who is very well aware of the limitations of LLMs.

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.