Everything posted by MigL
-
Why use the atomic bomb on Japan?
Most people recognize the difference between an unprovoked action, and a re-action to it. If you walk up to me and punch me in the face, no one will fault me for breaking your arm in response. ( not implying you would; you seem a nice enough person 🙂 ) It's brutal, but it's reality; if you don't want the consequences, don't do any harm to others.
-
We are tricked by our brains
The reason you can 'picture' the 2dimensional surface of the sphere/world is because you ;ive in three dimensions. To see a volume loop back on itself, you would need to live in 4 dimensions. The volume is effectively embedded in a higher dimensional manifold. You cannot picture it, however, you can demonstrate it mathematically. Space-time is a 4dimensional manifold, however, we have no need ( nor can they have any effect ) for embedding dimensions, so we call any topological curvature intrinsic, whereas an embedded topology would be extrinsic. I think you've hit the nail on the head; failure to elevate your thinking is leading to your confusion.
-
RIP Daniel Dennett
I'm not very familiar with him or his work, and frankly, I've never seen any validity in tilting at windmills like Religion; you cannot disprove a belief. But after Eise's glowing review of his life/works I will try to educate myself. I probably wouldn't understand his Philosophical leanings, but I like red wine ( a little too much ) also, and have pictures of myself on a tractor.
-
Why Lorentz relativity is true and Einstein relativity is false
You seem to have assumed there should be simultaneity, where relativity says there is none. Your analysis incorrectly uses a common 'now' for the two observers. Things have to be caused for them to happen, and causality moves at c . ( Dan should take the +1 back )
-
Asteroid defense ideas
Not very realistic Airbrush. A ten kilometer asteroid would require a rocket two orders of magnitude larger ( at least ) to perform that sort of stunt. As TheVat explained, the farther away you can influence the asteroid's trajectory, the less force is needed to produce sufficient deflection. I'd go with small and high speed, coupled with adequate detection time ( pre-impact ).
-
Planetary Defense: Shielding Earth from Asteroids
I thought this thread was about planetary defense against large asteroids on collision course with Earth. I never worried much about it, but it might be time to have a back-up plan. After all, Bruce Willis is retired with a form of dementia, and Ben Affleck is constantly drunk and in rehab. And I don't think Steve Bushemi, Billy Bob Thornton, Owen Wilson, and Michael Clark Duncan can do it on their own; even if Liv Tyler lends a hand. ( yes, it's a reference to the movie Armageddon 😄 )
-
Over 95% of this year’s US planned electric capacity is zero-carbon
Quite a few businesses that rely on min wage employees are still having difficulty finding people to work. I know of restaurants that have since closed on Monday and Tuesday, as well as for lunch, as they need available staff for busy weekend evenings. I remember Tim Horton's coffee shops closing in the evening for lack of staff, for about a year after lockdown ended; it has since gone back to normal. Most bars stay open till 11 pm, and only on Thurs/Fri/Sat till midnight, whereas it used to be 2 am closing. Fast food places, like McD, used to be staffed by young people after school/evening/weekend, now I see a majority of older retired people who used to only do weekdays previously. While CERB is not the cause, it is making the 'change' worse. I myself remember going to local farms, when I was about 12 to 15, to pick fruit like strawberries, cherries, peaches, etc. No 'self respecting' teenager will do that now, and the Government has to subsidize foreign workers ( Mexicans, Jamaicans, etc ) to help farmers pick their fruit. Is the Government going to have to subsidize foreign workers to work in fast food restaurants and bars also ? There was once a 'stigma' associated with handouts ( welfare, panhandling, etc ), now it is expected, as witnessed by the large numbers of young panhandlers. Handouts ( like CERB should be there for people who cannot take care of themselves, for whatever reason; not for people who don't want to take care of themselves. And Ontario's min wage is $16.55 ( going to $17.20 in October ); of course that is in our 3/4 dollars. I'm starting to get the impression that 'somewhere in the Americas' is actually ( or, used to be ) in Canada, as you seem to know a lot of stuff about Canada most Americans would not. Not that that's a bad thing; arrogant Americans should know more about us 🙂 .
-
Curious device
In this 'transmission', no energy is gained by incorporating magnets, and you would be better off using simple gears. I don't think you understand what the magnets are doing in your design. They are simply used as a force generating mechanism, as would be the teeth of gears. One big difference is that this force is limited by the strength of the magnets and the geometry of the magnet/finger system, as opposed to the the tensile strenth of hardened steel, which limits forces in a gear system. IOW, at best you have the same frictional losses in your system so you will always get less output than input, and the amount of power you can transfer is severely limited by the magnetic coupling. ( I tried to be as nice as possible and gave a serious response, without laughing )
-
Over 95% of this year’s US planned electric capacity is zero-carbon
We had a package during COVID also. Our Government paid people $2000 Can per month to stay home. Now, our economy is still struggling to recover, because small business can't find people to work, and the Government has a crap-load of debt that is still fueling inflation. But it's not like you guys don't have your problems. No doubt, if D Trump manages to get re-elected President, he'll be telling everyone how well the economy is doing under HIS Presidency.
-
We are tricked by our brains
I don't like Dimreepr's analogy, but I'll try to use it. Picture yourself living on that salt flat, which is level as far as the eye can see, and seems to go on forever. You start walking in one direction ( at a great speed ) and eventually you lose sight of the salt flat, and run into mountains and forests. Even cities and bodies of water that you have to swim across ( again at great speed ) until eventually ( after quite a while ) you come back to the same exact spot on the salt flat. But from the opposite direction. Clearly the surface of the world is finite; but there is no boundary. So where is the center of the world's surface ??? Now ( and this is a big step ) extend your thinking to 4 dimensional intrinsically curved space-time.
-
Over 95% of this year’s US planned electric capacity is zero-carbon
It is not the size that is revolutionary, rather the approach used. The American Government has chosen to reward industry for switching to low carbon emission processes. Most other country's Governments ( our PM in Canada also ) have chosen the stick approach, subjecting small industry to punishing carbon taxes, which keeps them from making the changes to low carbon processes, and the vicious cycle eventually drives them out of business. It is this far-sighted thinking that allows the American economy to perform much better than ours.
-
We are tricked by our brains
Rookie mistake. There is no such thing.
-
Introducing Edge theory. It's like String theory, except...
I just knew pyramids were going to be involved ... Now you've included picture salad ( not topology ), but still no meat.
-
We are tricked by our brains
I think you need to discuss this with @Maartenn100 . He claims there is no past. At least one of you must be wrong. I'm going to edge my bets and say you both are.
-
Introducing Edge theory. It's like String theory, except...
If you repost, try to use less word salad in your WAG. We like a little mathematical meat with our dinner.
-
Simple logical mathematical reasoning why time can not exist 'outthere' in the reality of the noumena
Philosophy that ignores science is a Lewis Carroll 'rabbit hole'. And you know what they say of people who assume ...
-
Introduction to My Hypothesis
Even what you consider moderate to highly 'plausible', is not. Never mind that last one concerning 'consciousness'.
-
The spacetime interval versus a chain of causative events
I'm not well versed enough in QFT to know whether those fields have coefficients in the same way. Or they may be just defined as 1, as is the index of refraction. Keep in mind that permeability refers to the magnetic field and permittivity to the electric, and, since both have units, with a suitable choice they could both be set to 1.
-
War Games: Russia Takes Ukraine, China Takes Taiwan. US Response?
True. All the fascist labelled states, Franco's Nationalists in Spain, Mussolini's Fascists in Italy, Hitler's National Socialists, and even Peron's Argentina, as well as Stalin's communists in Russia, Pol Pot's Communists in Cambodia and Mao Zedong's Communists in China used the same 'actions'. They were better classified as strong dictatorships where dissention is not tolerated, and results in death. The labels have no meaning because, even when you have a popular uprising to protest oppression by the wealthy few, as in the French Revolution, it soon descends into murdering chaos. It seems we humans only know one method. Instead of discussion to gain consensus, we choose to silence opposing ideas; in the extreme cases, mentioned above, by eliminating the people with the opposing ideas.
-
The spacetime interval versus a chain of causative events
Those coefficients define ease or effort for radiation to pass through that medium ( or lack thereof ). For example, when we say the index of refraction of free space is 1, as opposed to glass at 1.5, is n=1 a property of space ? Or is it a lack of that property.
-
Introduction to the Theory of Unity
Why does everyone think there is a need to 'harmonize' Quantum Mechanics with General Relativity ? The two models are well suited to each of their areas of applicability. But there is no doubt that the universe is probabilistic in nature. This non-determinism is 'smoothed out' by large numbers to make it virtually deterministic at larger scales. We are currently at 18-19th century levels of understanding with the two models as we were with Newtonian particle dynamics of gases, and Thermodynamic theory of gases. It took Statistical Thermodynamics to bridge the gap, and give us a more inclusive view of Gas Theory. The large numbers of Statistical Thermodynamics 'smooth out' the transition between the two models; yet the two models also remain valid in their respective applications, and are still used. Some day we may have a model which bridges the gap between QFT and GR, incorporating the most fundamental ideas of both, but that won't mean current QFT and GR cease to be valid where applicable. I am certain, however, that whatever theory manages to bridge the divide, will not, in any way, mention consciousness ...
-
War Games: Russia Takes Ukraine, China Takes Taiwan. US Response?
Don't know what Dima is on about, and I don't particularly care. But "The West is turning Fascist" ?? That's when labels stop having any meaning. You'll recall that Fascists and Communists ( which Russia still claims to be ) are ideologically opposed, and the eastern part of WW2 was fought about those ideological differences. And the reason, given by V Putin, for invading the Ukraine, and liberating its people from the oppressive Nazi fascists. Similarly, it seems that those we label fascists, like D Trump and his brown shirts ( who march on the Capital ) are V Putin ass-kissers and sympathizers. D Trump has said numerous times how much he admires V Putin, and how he'd allow him to have Europe if the Europeans don't pay their bills. This isn't a case of Nazis, Fascists, or Communists. Its despots, Democracies, and wanna-be despots who are willing to throw away our Democracy for personal gain.
-
A Speculative Description of Dark Matter and Dark Energy
What Mordred said. And present your ideas here for discussion, not through a pdf .
-
RIP Nobel Laureate Peter Higgs
His epitaph " he changed Cosmology and particle Physics, 50 years before anyone else realized it "
-
Do you look different to yourself in pictures than you do in the mirror?
I don't know ... The left and right sides of my face are always swapped in the mirror. Maybe 'handsomeness' has chirality 😄 .