Skip to content

Messages to the president...

Featured Replies

1 hour ago, sethoflagos said:

You might appreciate this little nugget of analysis

While I appreciate that the general public needs better media literacy, this guy at 'Second Thought' is also showing his own particular biases.
If I shouldn't consider Ground News, or any other sources, because of bias, then I shouldn't consider his either.

Take ALL news sources into consideration ( yes, even Fox ), but don't turn off your brain and just ingest the news; do some critical thinking. The reason for a particular news outlet viewpoint becomes evident, and you can usually discern factual information from pushed agenda/ideology.
If nothing else, Ground News helps recognize these patterns.
) no, I'm not a subscriber )

28 minutes ago, MigL said:

While I appreciate that the general public needs better media literacy, this guy at 'Second Thought' is also showing his own particular biases.
If I shouldn't consider Ground News, or any other sources, because of bias, then I shouldn't consider his either.

That's rather his point. There is no such thing as unbiased journalism. A centrist position more often than not supports the status quo which is effectively a vote in favour of maintaining existing power structures. That is very far from an unbiassed position. Those who present it as such, such as Ground News, are being dishonest.

I'd sooner listen to an honest conservative such as Professor Tim Wilson or Rory Stewart, and do so on a daily basis. I may not always agree with their conclusions, but I always respect them. We actually have much common ground except on a few minor issues like public ownership of the banking sector and leaving disarmed big game hunters to the tender mercies of a dominant male leopard. I do not waste time listening to anyone from the Murdoch empire, religious fundamentalists, or certain elements on the left who have shown themselves to act consistently in bad faith. Even when they're telling the truth they're lying (see Kierkegaard for that one).

A good case for promoting media literacy, and for outlets that are not corporate owned. Guardian, Mother Jones, 404 Media, ProPublica, Prism, et al.

15 hours ago, sethoflagos said:

You might appreciate this little nugget of analysis

I did. Being a registered, card-carrying Cretaceous Period dinosaur I would also enter a plea for revitalizing the role of print/text news, given the evidence that brains forced to decode little chicken scratches can retain and reflect on information better.

I liked also the takedown of the faux-objectif aggregators out there.

12 hours ago, sethoflagos said:

There is no such thing as unbiased journalism. A centrist position more often than not supports the status quo which is effectively a vote in favour of maintaining existing power structures. That is very far from an unbiassed position. Those who present it as such, such as Ground News, are being dishonest

Yes! Or I would put it, "There is no good journalism without someone's perspective." (Whether or not that's a bias, in the pejorative sense, is what the reader/viewer must determine - as your video goes into)

14 hours ago, sethoflagos said:

I'd sooner listen to an honest conservative such as Professor Tim Wilson or Rory Stewart, and do so on a daily basis. I may not always agree with their conclusions, but I always respect them.

Good faith arguments go a long way to build trust. I think it is a mistake to assume that there is objectivity as it basically leads to a nihilistic assumption that no information is useful.

I will also get a step further and add the postmodernist contention that information does not exist in isolation. Even in natural science, where we implement a lot of practices to reduce bias, it is to some degree (or certain workflows) inevitable and we rely on eventual error correction to address them. These approaches unfortunately are way too slow for public discourse, especially nowadays.

There is also the connected issue of scientism, unfortunately often used in bad faith, where some scientific findings are taken as objective truths in a particular context to provide credence for a certain argument. However, often the unknown are then often either ignored (or in case of science skepticism, overblown).

5 hours ago, TheVat said:

A good case for promoting media literacy, and for outlets that are not corporate owned. Guardian, Mother Jones, 404 Media, ProPublica, Prism, et al.

Правда? 😉

6 hours ago, TheVat said:

I did. Being a registered, card-carrying Cretaceous Period dinosaur I would also enter a plea for revitalizing the role of print/text news, given the evidence that brains forced to decode little chicken scratches can retain and reflect on information better.

... and to paraphrase @MigL , read more than one. And more than just the headlines (which are very often contradicted in the text).

Back in the '70s it used to be a standing joke that you could get a fully balanced view of the news by reading just two dailies: the Financial Times and the Morning Star. Though they differed slightly in their editorial conclusions, the quality of political analysis in both was (and possibly still is) consistently impressive, but also strangely similar (which was the in-joke). It was surmised that both drew from the same pool of Tankie journalists.

3 hours ago, CharonY said:

Good faith arguments go a long way to build trust. I think it is a mistake to assume that there is objectivity as it basically leads to a nihilistic assumption that no information is useful.

With you so far. Echoes of our recent discussion on the nature of Truth here.

3 hours ago, CharonY said:

I will also get a step further and add the postmodernist contention that

... resisting the urge to withdraw to the small room under the stairs, stick my fingers in my ears, and hum nine verses of "Alle Menschen müssen sterben".

3 hours ago, CharonY said:

information does not exist in isolation.

A bit confused now. Do you mean in the Holistic sense (ie. emergence vs reductionism)? Or contingency (necessary vs contingent truth)? (which seems closer to the sense of your final paragraph).

21 hours ago, sethoflagos said:

A bit confused now. Do you mean in the Holistic sense (ie. emergence vs reductionism)? Or contingency (necessary vs contingent truth)? (which seems closer to the sense of your final paragraph).

Sorry, it it was not particular thought out or written and on re-reading I do mix up concepts there. I was thinking about contigent truths (in my mind I was thinking about biological concepts, which are typically of this nature) where folks consider them essentially necessary truths and build their argument from there. Not sure if that clarifies anything, but I am deep in weeds of digging through omics data and it tends to scramble my brain for a while.

48 minutes ago, CharonY said:

Sorry, it it was not particular thought out or written and on re-reading I do mix up concepts there. I was thinking about contigent truths (in my mind I was thinking about biological concepts, which are typically of this nature) where folks consider them essentially necessary truths and build their argument from there. Not sure if that clarifies anything, but I am deep in weeds of digging through omics data and it tends to scramble my brain for a while.

Thanks for the clarification.

Yes, indeed. The model of the thing is not the thing itself. Now where have I heard that before?

1 hour ago, sethoflagos said:

Thanks for the clarification.

Yes, indeed. The model of the thing is not the thing itself. Now where have I heard that before?

The map is not the territory?

On 11/15/2026 at 9:03 PM, CharonY said:

There is also the connected issue of scientism, unfortunately often used in bad faith, where some scientific findings are taken as objective truths in a particular context to provide credence for a certain argument. However, often the unknown are then often either ignored (or in case of science skepticism, overblown).

This is actually a really difficult problem to address in the post-truth wilderness we now find ourselves in.

I realise that I'm possibly pushing my luck by posting Vlad Vexler to this forum, but this is his introduction to the scientism vs science skeptic issue in a more general sociopolitical context. If I'm barking up the wrong tree here then apologies in advance.

4 minutes ago, StringJunky said:

The map is not the territory?

Quite 👍

54 minutes ago, sethoflagos said:

I realise that I'm possibly pushing my luck by posting Vlad Vexler to this forum, but this is his introduction to the scientism vs science skeptic issue in a more general sociopolitical context. If I'm barking up the wrong tree here then apologies in advance.

No dendrological problems but six minutes in I realized that, given Vlad's slow and deliberative style, I could read his comments in 1/4 the time of listening which would mean I had just read the whole thing before having to stop and attend to other matters. So I'll get back to this, and I'm very much wanting to hear his whole vlog.

Not griping on you in particular, it's just a waking hours versus information firehose world situation, where I do better with text than videos. And I think that's part of what drives the SFN guideline on always providing transcript or equivalent article.

(By way of example, consider the reading time this excellent ProPublica muck-rake requires versus the time it would take for a Vlad V. paced presentation of the same information:

Tariff refunds go to CEO bonuses rather than reimbursement

ETA - he does provide a transcript in the "more info" area under the video if one leaves the embed and goes to YT, so I grumpily acknowledge that a transcript was there for me. Drat, could've read it by now. 🤪😄

56 minutes ago, TheVat said:

ETA - he does provide a transcript in the "more info" area under the video if one leaves the embed and goes to YT, so I grumpily acknowledge that a transcript was there for me. Drat, could've read it by now. 🤪😄

Sorry. I was being lazy. (and my screen's doing the green/magenta flash thing again)

Chapter 1: The political paradox

Hello, very beautiful community. We keep electing and re-electing crooks.

Moreover, it's transparently clear to some people at least that that's what these people are going to be like when they take power. And yet, we keep electing and reelecting them. And that seems like it's one of the paradoxes of the day. And it's especially strange that you're sitting there or walking or tidying your living room while listening to me and you're thinking, "Well, hang on. Vlad goes on about how this wave of irresponsible authoritarian populists is only now building. So, we're going to get more of this. So, how is that even possible? we keep electing and reelecting crooks and the more transparent that seems to be the case, the more we're going to keep doing it."

That doesn't make any sense. It seems to be one of the great paradoxes of the age. And it's very important to talk about this because the vast majority of you watching this have your nicely set up informationational ecosystem. And I would predict that most things that you absorb in thatformational ecosystem represent a form of denial about this very important issue. And that denial is both a sociological mistake if you like, maybe even a philosophical mistake, but it's also a mistake that costs quite a lot politically. It's a mistake that the vast majority of resistance liberals continue to make in the West.

Resistance liberals are people who say, "Let's not elect Farage. Let's not elect Trump."

We could put ourselves in that camp if you like even though that label is designed to apply to people who are saying not Trump and not far in an unconstructive way. But the vast majority of people in that category are profoundly wrong about this issue and their being wrong is enormously consequential.

Now I'm going to do a proper presentation about this perhaps on the main channel perhaps off YouTube. So for now all I'm going to do is take us further into this conversation. We have in fact begun it because I've been mentioning for a couple of years that in the modern west there is a conflict between agency and truth and that that conflict is genuine. Right? That conflict is not just a product of misunderstanding. And most resistance liberals would like you to think that it is a product of misunderstanding. And if only Trump voters were less ignorant and less morally malign or less impacted by malign Russian interference, they wouldn't have all those silly views they have about the world.

So, I've put that out there for us, but I've never really elaborated on it, and I won't today except to just take us two or three steps, little steps further, ankle deep into the water, and we'll come out because this is going to be an ongoing conversation. I'm going to do a proper treatment of this as well.

Chapter 2: Truth and political agency

This is a big conversation because the relation between politics and truth is one of the basic discussions in the history of the west. One of the most famous contributors to that conversation is Plato. And we've been having in our culture this conversation for a very long time. The difficulty we face with it now is that there is a tendency for people to come along and say when a voter takes a position that is simply not factually grounded and makes a critique of current politics, makes a critique of the status quo with an objection that is not real, backed up by facts that aren't real.

That the problem there is misinformation or disinformation and then that being fixed in the mind of the voter. So we respond to this if you like not with sociology but with a theory of mind. And I'm afraid to say the number of people who are cleareyed about this is about 77 in the Englishspeaking public sphere if you take it in the broader sense and even include academics um um who are not really public figures but from time to time appear here and there and make little utterances. So it's a very small number of people who are getting this right.

What is a relief is that a lot of people are getting this intuitively right without properly understanding it. And one of the things that's nice about the new wave of the younger generation of Democrats we've just witnessed in United States is that a lot of them get it intuitively. Some of them could understand it in the way we'll discuss it too. We'll be interested in that. So Pete Buddhaj or Zoran Mamdani would be interested in it. Abdul Sai wouldn't. He's too practical. But he has an intuitive understanding of it. And a lot of these younger generation dems have an intuitive understanding of the point we're about to begin making. That's very positive.

Chapter 3: The failure of liberal critique

So what's the problem? And what's the mistake and why is it costly?

The mistake is really to think that objections to the political status quo that are based on wild misinformation are just invalid. And why are they invalid? Well, it's obvious. They're based on misinformation. They're just not factually accurate. Now, you might say there could be a legitimate concern, a legitimate critique somebody might express that itself stands even though it's backed by false facts. We're not talking about that. We're talking about a critique that is both backed by false facts and is itself a mistake.

But hang on, if it's backed by false facts and even if you applied better correct facts to it, it would still be invalid.

What's valid about it?

Imagine you're having problems in your marriage and you're sitting with your spouse and he or she says, "I've had enough of this bloody broccoli risotto. Should we keep eating it every night?" And you think this is the first time we've had a broccoli risotto. What is going on, honey? Um, you sound upset, but in fact, you don't have any reason to be upset because we haven't had broccoli risotto before. We've had pumpkin risotto, but even that is rare. We very rarely eat rice altogether in our family. So you don't have any reason to be upset. It's okay. If you like, I can even tell you what we ate each night of the year and then you'll see that you're mistaken.

Now you see that there's something really wrong with this, right? Even a person who is very neurodiverse and very not aware of their neurodiversity would still not be able to respond like this. They'll still realize there is something going on. My spouse is distressed and they are distressed in a way that looks more than just a product of them having a bad night. Um, it looks like they've got some kind of issue with something. Maybe they can't name it. Maybe they don't even know what it is.

Okay. If they can't name it and they don't know what it is, could we get them to a place where they can name it so we're not going back and forth about the broccoli risotto?

What I've described now is completely normal, healthy relationship bridging.

Chapter 4: Agency and inarticulate critique

The political equivalent of that is to say that if a voter is complaining that there's a conspiracy of lizard people. They are running the world and that's why their life is going badly and because of that they're going to vote for Donald Trump's son in 2040.

Now what we can do there is see that something is going on with that person. They are feeling depleted politically. They've had enough with politics in some way. Something feels very, very bad or very painful to them about the current political situation they're in. It looks to us like they're trying to blow up the system for reasons that don't make sense. tied to facts that aren't facts that they've got a problem and we can look at what that problem is.

I can tell you what that problem is. That problem is a lack of agency. That problem is that these people feel that they don't even exist politically. That powerful political and economic interests at centers of concentration of political and economic power. Just don't count them as though they were quite real. That's how they feel. It might be that that isn't how they feel. It might be that they feel something else, but they're going to feel something else underneath the lizard people are running the world. So, I'm going to vote for Donald Trump's children in the years to come.

Now, let's reverse this and let's say we're saying their concern is not valid because we're talking about lizard people. What would we need to think to take that position? Here is where we're beginning to just go ankle deep in the water, but only ankle deep.

You're going to need to think that inarticulate critique has no place in politics. You're going to need to think that the distraught articulation of your spouse about the broccoli risotto has no place in politics. And to think that you need to think the following. You need to think that critique of the status quo politically can only be made using hermeneutical resources. Resources to do with interpreting political reality that the status quo makes available.

That is an implicit assumption in the thought of most liberals today. It's a ludicrous risible assumption.

Once you get to a certain level of sophistication, it's not a conversation about whether this is a good or a bad assumption. It's a laughable and intellectually unserious assumption. It colors the world view of most people you might read in the Atlantic, in the New York Times, on YouTube. And the reason this view is so silly and so damaging is that it's obvious that a status quo especially at a difficult moment when there is a transitional historical period something is falling apart something else is not falling warming in its place. It's obvious that at that period the status quo is going to leave people inarticulate about what's wrong. And so there is something wrong. They feel that there is something wrong.

But you're saying they should be silent and only speak if the status quo has given them the hermeneutical resources to speak which it hasn't.

Chapter 5: The tyranny of limited discourse

So this is a tyrannical constriction of political imagination.

Most objections to most political orders are going to be hard to articulate within that order. It's easier sometimes, harder other times depending on the historical moment. If you've got a high trust homogeneous society, it's going to be easier to articulate yourself. If you've got the biggest crisis of crisis of trust in 150 170 years, which is what we've got in the West, and you've got a very difficult moment of historical transition, it's to be expected that the most serious and the most legitimate complaints about the contemporary political reality by people who are most excluded by it are going to come from a place of inner articulacy.

So the idea that inarticulate critique is invalid is silly. And the assumption that it demands that the only valid critique of the status quo has to be in terms of the interpretive the resources the status quo offers citizens is silly. But it's common. It's not 30% of people who write for the Atlantic who think it. It's the majority. And in fact, I wouldn't even say they think it. They half think it as a sort of assumption. If you listen to discourse to a lot of people I I like and many cases know from the biggest pro-democracy YouTubers to the biggest pro-democracy commentators and advocates and journalists out there, you're going to hear this assumption that renders inarticulate critique invalid. We're not going to listen to you because you said that something that's round is flat. You said that the lizard people are running things. You've given some statistics about economics or immigration that aren't even in the ballpark of reality. Your own relationship with your favorite political candidate, in this case Donald Trump, is in the realm of magical thinking. You're entirely thinking about politics outside of cause and effect. How am I meant to take you seriously? So, what am I going to say? We need re reeducation.

Right? So, if you make um a piece in the Atlantic, if you do a YouTube video, if you post on Twitter, well, we've got this paradox that people keep electing uh crooks and reelecting them. What's going to be the top comment? Wow, we badly need re-education.

But that's such an elementary sociological mistake.

Once you reach a degree of reflective sophistication about politics, that mistake doesn't look that much less embarrassing than the mistake of Trump voters could talk about lizards and so on.

So I'm beginning to have a conversation with you. We're going to do this much more systematically. So, I'm not intending you to form a sense of what I'm saying yet or form your own reaction to it yet. I'm beginning this conversation with you whereby there might be a canvas and the canvas is called a conflict between agency and truth. And we filled out 4% of the canvas today just beginning to put things on the table. are culturing us into this conversation.

Chapter 6: Truth, empathy, and leadership

Now, let me step away together with you from the canvas and say something very important about what you actually need to do politically about this.

There are two broad buckets of how you respond to this. One says that truth is fundamental to the sustenance of democracy. That's my position. Position I strongly recommend not just because it's true but because cognizance of its truth is actually a precondition of the sustenance of democracy. The other bucket says no well truth is not that important in democracy. We need to tell the right kind of stories and try to get people to be compelled by the right kind of stories. stories that make our lives go better. That's a bucket in which you might find somebody talking about democracy like the late Richard Ry from the pragmatist tradition. And I'm saying that that is an elementary and dangerous mistake that's going to encourage Trumpist politics just the way this liberal evasion I've been talking about encourages Trumpist politics.

So you don't have democracy unless it's tethered to the practice virtue of truthfulness at an institutional level.

So what the hell do you do with voters who have genuine but in articulate grievances that are going to be expressed in the form of magical thinking. You prevent them from drifting deeper into post truth by holding them in that place where they're saying a particular set of things that aren't true. And as you hold them there, you begin to explore where their critique has come from. You have to be able to give them articulacy both about why they're feeling so wrong about the political situation and you have to give them articuly about any particular issue that might lie behind the magical thinking issue that they have put on the table as a form of critique.

The ballpark of the act of empathy you need is that when somebody says what the elites claim science says I reject. What the elites claim the reality of my country the world is I reject. The act of empathy you need there is that somebody is saying what the elites are telling me is something that I feel just disappears me and if I feel that is disappearing me I'm going to reject it. If I'm going to reject it, I'm going to say it's not true. Even though it might be true or true in some respects at least, or facts in the vicinity of whatever issue we might be talking about might be true, but I'm still rejecting them because as things stand, I feel that these facts, whether they're facts or not, disappear me.

So, how do you reappear people? How how do you make people feel that they reappear?

So you go behind the inarticulate critique and try to give people articulacy both on the particular issue and on the general subject of how you gain articulacy about grievance without falling into denial of basic truths and basic facts about the world.

You can do that quite easily. You just need to be bold and you need to be engaged. You need to be a good political communicator and a good listener.

Chapter 7: Reframing political engagement

So you fold the inarticulate magical thinking critique back into truthfulness. Not by shutting people down and telling them they've made an epistemic mistake. They need re-education, but by telling people that you hear that they've got a very, very serious grievance, and you're going to be there to explore what it is.

If you can articulate effectively somebody's grievance, they're going to recognize it and it's going to be much more compelling to them than the alternative of denying some fact about the world. And they're not going to need to deny that fact about the world. So it's very important that what I'm saying has nothing to do with the diminution of the virtue of truthfulness in democracy. I am an extremist about that. It's really essential in democracy. But I do take very seriously the idea that it is a sociological and philosophical and political mistake to dismiss inarticulate critique. And if liberals continue to dismiss inarticulate critique and half their democracies collapse, future intellectual historians will laugh at most people without notice. The major publications on all the platforms on the internet for being complicit in the demise of the politics they wanted to preserve by failing to hear people because people found no way to express themselves using the resources the status quo made available to them.

This is going to sound weird and strange. So what we're doing here is we're beginning to train a muscle that is absolutely not used to going in that direction. So this feels very strange, right? And so for a lot of you many many fibers in your body are going to be feeling no I don't need to go there because if somebody's wrong about seven things in their critique of the status quo and they make their entire critique based on these seven things they're wrong about then they don't have any kind of a valid critique. They are stupid, badly influenced by some kind of deleterious disinformation and misinformation. They're ignorant and so on. That's what that's about. The problem is epistemic, but it's not epistemic.

The epistemic problem is there. These people are factually wrong. But the the core problem is not epistemic.

The core problem is about people's sense of loss of agency.

Chapter 8: Politics as shared negotiation

Where does the mistake come from that so many intelligent people are so confident about telling people that they're wrong and that their critiques are invalid and they dismiss the entire space? It's it's nearly the most vital space we can attend to at tricky historical moments. the space of inarticulacy, the space of inticulate critique.

But why do people dismiss it? I think people dismiss it partly because social understanding is a very difficult thing in the scientistic culture.

Partly because there is a certain kind of Perhaps economics and especially so social science driven tendency to think that the way you get politics right is by analyzing it correctly. That's to say, it's a view of politics that conflates it with the kinds of social practices that occur in an argument or in a formal academic debate that might happen in constitutional context. That's to say these are people who are inclined to take politics as an argument. It's not an argument. It's a negotiation, a shared negotiation of space. And when difficult historical moments come along, that space of inarticulacy and your capacity to engage with people who find themselves in that space and help them with their articulacy.

That's what leadership is all about in difficult historical moments. Leadership is not about self- congratulatory telling people in a self- congratulatory way to wise up.

So the there is a certain kind of scientistic arrogance there certain kind of economic centricity there that inclines people to think of politics as an argument rather than as a negotiation of shared space.

If you think of the broccoli situation as an argument, your spouse is just wrong. If you think of it as a negotiation of shared space, your partner is hurt and inarticulate about his or her hurt. It might be that you didn't hurt them, might be that you did, but they're hurt by something. And that needs to be held by the relationship. If you don't hold it, they're going to go off and deal with it their own way by withdrawing, having an affair, losing the capacity to intimately be connected with you and so on. further losing trust in the relationship.

So funnily enough, these people who prioritize argument, who prioritize accuracy, analytical clarity and systematicity are themselves making a mistake that is deeply embarrassed by all of these values because it's a completely unserious position to try to expel inarticulate critique and the special philosophical mistake in it. We're only ankle deep, so we're just touching on this special philosophical mistake in it.

Is the mistake of thinking that either you've got to critique the status quo with the resources it's made available to you or you don't have a valid critique. But the very point is that when a status quo is in turmoil, in transition, when it's screwed up, it's precisely not going to give you the resources to critique what is genuinely wrong with it. unstable, wonky, crisis ridden political formations. Do not give citizens resources to understand and articulate what's wrong.

Right? We're training the muscle. We're gonna keep training the muscle.

@sethoflagos

That was brilliant. This is something the frau and I have been talking about for a decade (not broccoli risotto), on how one has a dialog with people who have, as Vlad puts it, an inarticulate sense of wrongness. That we don't brush off a real conversation because "those people need a remedial education in civics." (Oh I've been so guilty on that one!) They feel the government isn't working, and depriving them of agency, even human visibility at all. But the current political snd ideological structures don't give them the epistemic tools to see what the core of the problem is. Blame the lizard people. Blame the smug high priests of scientism. Blame immigrants capturing neighborhood pets and cooking them in the...risotto. (loved the marital conflict example) Blame élites!

The epistemic problem is there. These people are factually wrong. But the core problem is not epistemic.

The core problem is about people's sense of loss of agency

Can anyone here imagine what the world would look like now if Hillary Clinton had absorbed Vexlers salient points around 2015? His video essay offers us a clear-eyed perspective on those awful years when US liberals and the Democratic Party adopted the most self harming strategy possible.

ETA: And I later felt like a shit for even mentioning Vexler's speaking style when I read this elsewhere:

2003, during post graduate studies at Oxford University, Vlad contracted Myalgic Encephalomyelitis (M.E.), a debilitating health condition of the brain & nervous system.

He was unable to walk, talk or read for two years.

Today, he is largely housebound with limited daily function. Managing his symptoms is a constant process.

Living with this condition, which clinicians consider as debilitating as HIV or MS, gives Vlad a unique perspective on disability & the tragic element in life, as well as the beauty.

Edited by TheVat

1 hour ago, TheVat said:

That was brilliant. This is something the frau and I have been talking about for a decade (not broccoli risotto), on how one has a dialog with people who have, as Vlad puts it, an inarticulate sense of wrongness. That we don't brush off a real conversation because "those people need a remedial education in civics." (Oh I've been so guilty on that one!) They feel the government isn't working, and depriving them of agency, even human visibility at all.

I simply present this as a concrete example of what I meant above by the phrase "sober political analysis". No rhetoric, no self-righteous hystrionics, not even any doctrinal "politics" in the sense we normally understand. It's applicable wherever one stands in the party-political landscape (the ethical value judgments come later). Without this basic empathetic understanding of where people's general mindset is, any prescriptive solution you propose isn't going anywhere.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.