Jump to content

Genady

Senior Members
  • Joined

Everything posted by Genady

  1. How does it relate to Astronomy and Cosmology?
  2. When we look at the image of, for example, a spiral galaxy, we do not look at it in the disk plane, but close to perpendicular to the plane. The thickness of Milky Way's disk is about 1000 ly. We don't see through the disk, so we see about 500 ly thick image. The maximal difference in "past times" is thus about 500 years.
  3. We can take in account the motion of stars in a galaxy and estimate their positions at one instant of time. As the past times you mention are only different by several hundred years, we find that on a galaxy scale this does not have any visible effect on the image we get.
  4. We receive at present the signals from different times in the past and we separate them if we know relative distances to the sources. For example, we can see simultaneously the Sun and the Moon, but we know that we see the Moon as it was one second ago and we see the Sun as it was 8 minutes ago. The same with galaxies and all.
  5. And then, there is Freeman Dyson (F. Dyson, “The World on a String,” New York Review of Books, May 13, 2004)
  6. From Susskind & Cabannes, General Relativity: The Theoretical Minimum (p. 227):
  7. The direction of spin is continuous. The spin of the electrons can have any one of continuous 3D directions.
  8. Generally, an observable value can be uncertain AND conserved - there is no contradiction. For a simple example, consider an entangled Bell pair of two electrons with opposite spins. The spins of the electrons are maximally uncertain but they certainly sum to zero, i.e., are certainly opposite to each other.
  9. Exactly. This was my message:
  10. We were discussing this example:
  11. Right. The fluctuations are above and below a positive average, but not below zero average.
  12. Please explain: if the average is zero, then a slightly smaller value would be negative, wouldn't it? Energy is conserved in every possible outcome, not only on average. In no quantum or particle experiment conservation of energy was ever violated.
  13. Momentum is conserved on every line and at every vortex of every Feynman diagram. The path integral calculation sums up all available paths, not only straight ones. There is an inconsistency in this claim: energy is non-negative, so if it becomes positive even temporarily, its average cannot be zero.
  14. In QM, as well as in QFT, momentum is conserved. Lagrangians are translationally invariant. Momentum conservation follows by the Noether's theorem.
  15. I've had an experience with the nitrogen narcosis, some myself and more in other divers (students and those I was guiding.) I would not describe it as being drunk, but rather as being euphoric and very unfocused. As the divers ascend and the effect disappears, they often don't have any recollection of what they were doing and what happened while they were affected, similarly to what happens immediately after waking from being sedated by a drug.
  16. Not necessarily. There are ways to have even infinite number of infinite universes in a multiverse. And if some of them are finite, they do not necessarily have a center, edges, etc.
  17. I think that this solution uses a prior result to the effect that which can be derived using CDF (and perhaps integration by parts).
  18. They're going around forums promoting this article: link removed
  19. OTOH, from the article: Sounds quite mystical to me.
  20. I want to add to the @Markus Hanke's explanation above, that there are two more spatial coordinates, the "latitude" and the "longitude", which apply in the same way inside the EH as outside it. They are not shown on the Kruskal diagrams.
  21. It depends on a "seeing" event. Draw two 45o light rays up from any event: it can be seen at any event on these rays.
  22. You said "unprimed c" twice, so I don't know what you mean. Anyway, event C is seen at event C'.
  23. The 45o line that goes through the origin and the events C and C', is a worldline of EH. The greyish area above it and to the left, with the events D, E, D', E', is inside the BH. The white area to the right and below - outside the BH. The hyperbola separating the light grey and the dark grey, with event F on it - singularity.
  24. Here the green arrow shows that the unprimed observer being at event D sees the primed observer being at event M' (approximately):
  25. This will help. As Susskind says in the General Relativity: The Theoretical Minimum, This is the figure 5, for reference:

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.