Ed84c:

 

There is no such thing as a beaker of protons. Im not sure if its possible to have a solitary proton floating in a beaker of water anyway.

 

pH measures the hydronium ion concentration of water. people will commonly write H+ ions when referring to these - this is purely for simplicity.

 

When an acid dissolves in water, it dissociates into a proton and its conjugate base. The proton, however, does not exist as a proton. it combines with a water molecule to make a hydroxonium (or hydronium depending on the textbook) ion, H3O+. Not a lone proton.

 

Say acetic acid (vinegar).

 

CH3COOH + H20 ----> H30+ + CH3C00-

 

I hope this is clear enough for you, schools tell pupils H+ ions float about in water so they dont have to mention big words. Im not trying to insult your intelligence here - they dont go into detail about acid - base reactions until 5th year (in Scotland anyway, no idea about US).

greg1917 said in post # :

There is no such thing as a beaker of protons. Im not sure if its possible to have a solitary proton floating in a beaker of water anyway.

That was my little hypothetical that I comically inserted into the discussion. It was a silly way of saying "strongest possible acid (even if it can't exist)".

You like saying silly things dont you.

 

TALK DAMMIT TALK.

it would be very difficult to have a beaker of pure H+ ions because they would burn through the beaker. sorry I couldn't help relpying ( i notice the stupidest things.)

spacin, you could not have a beaker or anything filled with hydronium cations. it is just impossible. anions would be attracted

so out of curriosity if you had hydrogen gas mixed with water and then exposed it to an extreme positive charge you have the potential to create a very powerful acid?

I like the idea because it is like the one ihad, and ill be damned if I end up like the people throughout this thread that fill it full of technicalities, , but i think that would also seperate the water and eventually probably explode. Plus the electrons are very tightly bound towards the inside of a H atom.

eh, youd have to put something in the water to rip the electrons off the hydrogen, and the thing that the hydrogen and ______ create would have to have a really low dissociation constant

i bought a 5lb back of iowa protons on ebay the other day..1.99. and they didnt skimp. only thing was, some of the protons have strange growths:/

only thing was, some of the protons have strange growths:/

you have GOTTA BE F**ING kidding us right!?

lol, yeah, it happens to cations......

YT, do you not see the overexemplified sarcasm in my statement?

omfg

 

no matter where you go....people are stupid.

 

thanks for the good laugh.....haha

disco, what's your implication?

I'm not 100% sure, but I think the strongest acid is antimony pentafluoride.

Just checked, I'll quote from the Guiness Book of Records 2003:

 

"Normal solutions of strong acids and alkalis tend towards pH values of 0 and 14 respectively, but this scale is inadequate for superacids, the strongest of which is an 80% solution of antimony pentafluoride in hydrofluoric acid (fluoro-antimonic acid). The acidity function of this solution has not been measured, but even a weaker 50% solution is 1,018 times more powerful than concentrated sulphuric acid"

 

Now, that's not one I'd like to put my hand in!

Hope this helps.

antimony pentafluoride isn't an acid. also, a 50% solution of antimony pentafluoride in hydrogen fluoride is 10^18 times more acidic than 100% sulfuric

Ahh well, complain to Guinness. There beer isn't too bad, but I guess they should get their facts right first!

no worries

I first heard about that acid when I was in high school. The textbook had a listing of the strongest acid, and H2Sb2F6 was listed as the strongest. (I can't remember the exact formula, but it's the acid being talked about in this thread). It's some pretty strong stuff. hehe.

This is not much related to the title but I want to consult on.

Does carbon dioxide like sulphur dioxide gives ions when it is dissolves/react in water?

I'd think it won't since aqeuous carbonic acid is unstable, I think:P

what sort of things can it react with then? Platinum?

"The acidity function of this solution has not been measured, but even a weaker 50% solution is 1,018 times more powerful than concentrated sulphuric acid"

 

The Finnish edition doesn't have that mistake Good to see that the guy who translated the book actually fixed something.

 

"H2Sb2F6"

 

Most likely HF:SbF5

@r1dermon, lol. It’s almost as good as some guy that was selling dried leave from his tree. or the empty folder from some ones desk top (computer).

and just to top it off some girl from the UK sold her virginity but that was removed so she made her own website, she got 6K as far as I know.

 

You can buy almost anything on eBay, a gift to all.