8 minutes ago, swansont said:

Newton was a proponent of light being a particle. His aether was for transmission of something other than light.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Luminiferous_aether

Feel free to open a thread where you predict the observed results with classical physics.

Start with explaining spin classically. 

I was going to attempt to work with @Mordred on this but you locked said topic. So I sent him a pm on the subject in question. If he takes on the project I will attempt to do so, then I will post the topic. 

Edited December 25, 20177 yr by SuperPolymath

13 minutes ago, SuperPolymath said:

I was going to attempt to work with @Mordred on this but you locked said topic. So I sent him a pm on the subject in question. If he takes on the project I will attempt to do so, then I will post the topic. 

You had no model, and asked that it be locked. 

5 minutes ago, swansont said:

You had no model, and asked that it be locked. 

It was an attempt to work with a user who had the necessary education to help me model-build, & I never once asked you to lock it. I said move it to trash can before resorting to locking it entirely, at least from there it could be moved back into speculations in the event a model would arise from the concepts. 

 

 

1 minute ago, SuperPolymath said:

It was an attempt to work with a user who had the necessary education to help me model-build, & I never once asked you to lock it. I said move it to trash can before resorting to locking it entirely, at least from there it could be moved back into speculations in the event a model would arise from the concepts. 

Moving to the trash locks the thread. 

Model building (from scratch) is not what we do here.

3 minutes ago, swansont said:

Moving to the trash locks the thread. 

Model building (from scratch) is not what we do here.

It's not from scratch, you have everything up to GR, pre-QM. 

10 minutes ago, SuperPolymath said:

It's not from scratch, you have everything up to GR, pre-QM. 

The new stuff - what you intend/need to show - is from scratch. 

5 minutes ago, swansont said:

The new stuff - what you intend/need to show - is from scratch. 

Everything is still dictated by motion under GR. 

 

4 hours ago, SuperPolymath said:

Everything is still dictated by motion under GR. 

 

GR is not motion it is Gravity, SR is motion polymath.

5 minutes ago, Vmedvil said:

GR is not motion it is Gravity, SR is motion polymath.

All gravity has motion. It's called frame-dragging. 

Edited December 26, 20177 yr by SuperPolymath

Just now, SuperPolymath said:

All gravity has motion. 

Yes, but it is governed by SR and generated by GR.

7 minutes ago, Vmedvil said:

Yes, but it is governed by SR and generated by GR.

GR states that matter tells spacetime how to curve & this curve (gravity) propagates at C for that level of reality (1.6x10^-35 meters through 13 billion light years) & tells matter how to move via SR, there are infinite smaller levels composing an infinite larger levels, that is a governing property & generating property Vmedvil, but it's all deterministic because it's all (including SR) governed by GR, Vmedvil.

In either case @swansont was incorrect. This wouldn't be modeled from scratch. 

 

Edited December 26, 20177 yr by SuperPolymath

8 minutes ago, SuperPolymath said:

GR states that matter tells spacetime how to curve & this curve (gravity) propagates at C for that level of reality (1.6x10^-35 meters through 13 billion light years) how to move, there are infinite smaller levels composing an infinite larger levels, that is a governing property & generating property Vmedvil, but it's all deterministic because it's all (incuding SR) governed by GR, Vmedvil.

In either case @swansont was incorrect. This wouldn't be modeled from scratch. 

 

Ya, you are talking to someone way different I know what the Electromagnetic Energy Stress  Tensor says do not confuse me with Swan.

Maxwell's equations

Edited December 26, 20177 yr by Vmedvil