Skip to content

White bread... [nutrition]

Featured Replies

Hello all.

Read similar since long ago, in multiple publications, white bread being bad :

image.png

--> Is a 'hot dog' a better and convenient nutritional meal for diabetics ? -- Why is then the bran removed ? -- Is it sold aside to make more money ? -- A person who does not know if has diabetes or risk of it can be killed by the bread industry ? 🙄

Decided to ask the same 'genius'

image.png

Another :

image.png

2 hours ago, Externet said:

Hello all.

Read similar since long ago, in multiple publications, white bread being bad :

image.png

--> Is a 'hot dog' a better and convenient nutritional meal for diabetics ? -- Why is then the bran removed ? -- Is it sold aside to make more money ? -- A person who does not know if has diabetes or risk of it can be killed by the bread industry ? 🙄

Decided to ask the same 'genius'

image.png

Another :

image.png

This is simplistic. So long as you eat white bread as part of a meal, as say the French do, you won't get much of a spike in blood sugar, because the rate of digestion is slowed down by the other stuff you are eating at the same time. I should have thought white bread with a salad or a vegetable soup, say, is probably not much different from eating wholemeal bread.

There is all manner of dietary advice out there designed to shock you and make you waste money on fancy diets. A lot of it is alarmist bullshit. In my view you are far better off cutting down on sugar itself (sweet desserts, cakes etc) and especially sweetened fizzy drinks. We have all eaten white bread for centuries, with little ill effect, as part of a sensible diet.

Diabetic or not, anything not whole grain is a poor nutritional choice. Too high glycemic, often vitamin-poor, and nutritional fiber in whole grains has prebiotic benefits in the gut that help prevent all kinds of ailments. Look out for faux-healthy labelings like "multi grain" which will generally be fifty percent or more white flour. White flour turns to sugar rapidly in your stomach. Ditto white rice.

2 minutes ago, exchemist said:

So long as you eat white bread as part of a meal, as say the French do, you won't get much of a spike in blood sugar, because the rate of digestion is slowed down by the other stuff you are eating at the same time.

Well, amount is the problem. Per a former boss who had a doctorate in nutrition, "burying the cookie" only works up to a point. And diabetics really should replace a white bread with whole wheat. Low glycemic foods trigger the brain like sugar does, making a diner want to gorge on them.

1 hour ago, TheVat said:

Diabetic or not, anything not whole grain is a poor nutritional choice. Too high glycemic, often vitamin-poor, and nutritional fiber in whole grains has prebiotic benefits in the gut that help prevent all kinds of ailments. Look out for faux-healthy labelings like "multi grain" which will generally be fifty percent or more white flour. White flour turns to sugar rapidly in your stomach. Ditto white rice.

Well, amount is the problem. Per a former boss who had a doctorate in nutrition, "burying the cookie" only works up to a point. And diabetics really should replace a white bread with whole wheat. Low glycemic foods trigger the brain like sugar does, making a diner want to gorge on them.

Diabetics, yes, no doubt, should be careful. But for most people with a reasonably balanced diet, I don’t see a risk. France seems to have one of lowest rates of diabetes in Europe and baguettes with every meal are a staple.

https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/diabetes-rates-by-country

Or are all “white” flours the same? Is there something about industrial white bread that makes it worse than traditional bread?

  • Author

Thanks, gentlemen. Just discovering rice has the husk and bran removed to become of lesser nutrition and selling the bran at ~24 times the price of rice. 😢 Is there an explanation other than greed ?

image.png

image.png

Just noticed this is not the 'other sciences' chapter but the amateur science one. Goofed again. Please move if deserved. ☹️

44 minutes ago, exchemist said:

Or are all “white” flours the same? Is there something about industrial white bread that makes it worse than traditional bread?

One of the engineers I used to work with, left to join a chemical company in Niagara Falls, New York, where they make an additive which helps bread stay 'fresh' a lot longer.
I remember when white, soft bread used to go moldy in a couple of days; now it'll keep for two weeks !

Like anything else, the right amount is good for you, while too much is always bad.
As you need carbs, starches, and even sugars, one trick I learned from my brother ( who is diabetic, but not on insulin ) is to pair with proteins and fiber to control the blood sugar peak, as has been mentioned by @exchemist .
Another trick is to drink alcohol ( a glass of wine will do ), as this forces the liver to prioritize metabolizing of the alcohol over releasing glucose into the blood.

While my blood sugar is has been checked yearly for the past 35 years, it has always been under control ( so far ) but like many people, bread is a 'comfort' food for me, and I could eat a 500 gm steak, with salad, and not feel satiated.
Adding a little starch, like rice, potato, or my favorite, bread, does the trick.
The problem with too much white bread ( or any kind of bread, for non diabetics ) is that starchy carbs lead to what commonly called ( in North America ) 'typical European physique'; thin arms/legs etc. but large around the middle ( barrel bodied ).
I'm already starting to see signs of that, as my food intake has kept steady ( I like eating ), but my activity levels, other than resistance training, have decreased ( since retirement in April ), so I've been trying ( it's hard ) to cut my bread intake drastically.

I could use Ozempic, but apparently that can cause reduced blood flow to the optic nerve in some people, and I already have a major case of optic nerve damage due to Glaucoma ( for over 30 years ).

13 minutes ago, MigL said:

One of the engineers I used to work with, left to join a chemical company in Niagara Falls, New York, where they make an additive which helps bread stay 'fresh' a lot longer.
I remember when white, soft bread used to go moldy in a couple of days; now it'll keep for two weeks !

Like anything else, the right amount is good for you, while too much is always bad.
As you need carbs, starches, and even sugars, one trick I learned from my brother ( who is diabetic, but not on insulin ) is to pair with proteins and fiber to control the blood sugar peak, as has been mentioned by @exchemist .
Another trick is to drink alcohol ( a glass of wine will do ), as this forces the liver to prioritize metabolizing of the alcohol over releasing glucose into the blood.

While my blood sugar is has been checked yearly for the past 35 years, it has always been under control ( so far ) but like many people, bread is a 'comfort' food for me, and I could eat a 500 gm steak, with salad, and not feel satiated.
Adding a little starch, like rice, potato, or my favorite, bread, does the trick.
The problem with too much white bread ( or any kind of bread, for non diabetics ) is that starchy carbs lead to what commonly called ( in North America ) 'typical European physique'; thin arms/legs etc. but large around the middle ( barrel bodied ).
I'm already starting to see signs of that, as my food intake has kept steady ( I like eating ), but my activity levels, other than resistance training, have decreased ( since retirement in April ), so I've been trying ( it's hard ) to cut my bread intake drastically.

I could use Ozempic, but apparently that can cause reduced blood flow to the optic nerve in some people, and I already have a major case of optic nerve damage due to Glaucoma ( for over 30 years ).

Interesting. I found when I stopped rowing that my desire for bread went down, and when I retired it went down further. Nowadays I find 1/4 to 1/3 of a baguette is sufficient for my lunch (or dinner if I am having bread as the starch component) whereas it used to be over half. But there’s no diabetes in the family so maybe I am luckier than some.

But the French have about a fifth of the diabetes of the Americans, in spite of eating a lot more bread. I can’t help thinking the problem lies elsewhere in the diet. (esp. soft drinks with meals, a practice most French despise.)

Create an account or sign in to comment

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.