8 replies to this topic

[Erina]

Are the carcinogens, carried in smoke, from BBQ meat more detrimental to one's health than second hand smoke from a cigarette? I understand that grilling meat is different to barbecuing it, I've even read that smoke from burnt toast is bad, so, how much scientific proof is there of this?

I've been around online but I can't find anything concrete, anybody know?

Thanks.

[iNow]

No, neither in type of carcinogens nor in amount.

[StringJunky]

No, neither in type of carcinogens nor in amount.

Are you saying they are equal in potential harm?

[iNow]

Are you saying they are equal in potential harm?

No, that was not my intended meaning. Why do you ask?

[StringJunky]

No, that was not my intended meaning. Why do you ask?

I was trying to make sense of your answer which, clearly, I got wrong.

[iNow]

I was basically suggesting that there is a risk of cancer from inhaling any type of smoke, including that from BBQ or burnt toast. However, cigarettes seem to contain more carcinogens than either of those types of smoke, and also we tend to inhale a much higher volume of smoke directly from cigarettes than we do from BBQ or toasters.

[Erina]

So when somebody says that grilling smoke is worse than cigarette, it's not true? Is there much proof, from unbiased sources, that second hand smoke causes cancer?

Thanks.

[iNow]

http://www.cancer.go...eet/Tobacco/ETS

http://www.cancer.or...econdhand-smoke

http://www.straightd...ng-cause-cancer

[StringJunky]

I was basically suggesting that there is a risk of cancer from inhaling any type of smoke, including that from BBQ or burnt toast. However, cigarettes seem to contain more carcinogens than either of those types of smoke, and also we tend to inhale a much higher volume of smoke directly from cigarettes than we do from BBQ or toasters.

Thanks for the clarification.