I would agree that there is no definition of an intentional God that works in logic, and that for many people a God without intention is not a God.

 

But let's give religion some credit for thoughtfulness. Check out the doctrine of Divine Simplicity, or the definition of Tao or Nibbana. Religion without God does not suffer from the problem raised by Dr Rocket.

 

 

But let's give religion some credit for thoughtfulness.

No, let's not.

Thought is an intrinsic human trait.

On the other hand, organised religion persecutes those who think anything outside their dogma.

So, while it may be true that some religions are in favour of thought, it's not a characteristic of religion in general.

Let's keep it serious.