Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
alt_f13

Why extreme heat makes you feel cold.

3 posts in this topic

I came to the conclusion whilst taking a hot shower.

 

You actually are feeling cold. The cold receptors that have been heated are losing heat to the nearby cells that are not as hot. Even though the water may not be very warm, if the cold receptors are very warm compared to the cells around it, they can still give enough heat away to make you feel cold in that area.

 

Yes, no?

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

No, I'm afraid. Your theory looks sound when viewed from the perspective of thermodynamics, but there are two flaws:

 

1) It ignores the role of warmth receptors

2) It assumes that a shower of water at any given tempterature could result in cutaneous cells in direct contact with each other being at distinctly different temperatures.

 

Warmth and cold are mediated by separate populations of thermal receptors, and temperature sensitivity is punctuate, i.e. these receptors innervate areas of the skin (about 1mm dia.) where thermal stimulation elicits the sensation of either warmth or cold (depending on the stimulus > or < 34 degrees C).

 

Thermal receptors respond to changes in skin temperature, and each (cold and warm) have a preferential range of sensitivity. Cold receceptors respond optimally within a range of 1 degree to 20 degrees below normal skin temp (~34 degrees C). Warmth receptors respond between 32 degrees C and around 45 degrees C.

 

When you apply a warm or cold stimulus, the appropriate (warm or cold) receptors fire rapidly in response to the sudden change, but if the stimulus is constant, the volleys decrease in frequency (habituation), which is why we go 'OohAhOohAh' when we first get into a hot bath or shower, but without changing the water temp, just go 'Aaaahhh' after a minute or two.

 

There is another type of thermal receptors (not specific to thermal stimuli) called polymodal receptors. These have a wide dynamic range and respond to heat stimuli (>45 degrees C), noxious cold and mechanical stimuli of sufficient intensity to cause pain. These receptors begin to take over where thermal receptors leave off (at stimulus temps outside their range, thermal receptor activity is reduced).

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0