Jump to content

Need Help with this Matrice Problem

Featured Replies

OK, I am having a problem with this economic theory by Piero Sraffa. He says that production affects value, that's not the hard part. Here is his first example of a hypothetical economy:

280 qr. wheat + 12 t. iron --> 400 qr. Wheat

120 qr. wheat + 8 t. iron --> 20 t. iron

 

I figured, hey what the heck, just set the value of a ton of iron to x and a qr. of wheat to y.

280y + 12x = 400y

120y + 8x = 20x

Then subtract and we get:

12x = 120y

120y = 12x

Thus 10 qr. wheat is exchangeable for 1 t. iron.

 

But now he introduces the production with a surplus of 175 qr. wheat. There is a "rate of profit" scalar "r" that is [math]0\geq r\geq1[/math]and then we multiply both (1+r)(inputs).

 

He then says OK given

(1+r)(280y + 12x) = 575y

(1+r)(120y + 8x) = 20x

then magically comes to the conclusion r=0.25 and that 15y=x. I don't understand that little minor part.

This isn't exactly a matrix problem. What you have there is a non-linear equation in three variables; no amount of playing with matrices is going to give you the answer you're looking for. You should probably note that there is another trivial solution, x = y = 0; for the rest of this post I'll assume that we've already found this result and hence dividing by x/y won't be a problem.

 

Finding the 15y = x part is fairly easy. You can simply do the following:

 

[math]\frac{(1+r)(280y + 12x)}{(1+r)(120y+8x)} = \frac{575y}{20x}[/math]

 

Then simplify to [math]20x(280x + 12x) = 575y(120y+8x)[/math]. Expand and simplify to give you [math]24x^2+100xy-6900y^2 = 0[/math]. Now, this may look nasty and horrible but assuming you fix y, you can find x - it's just a quadratic equation.

 

So from this we get [math]x = \frac{-100y \pm \sqrt{10000y^2 + 662400y^2}}{48} = \frac{-100y \pm 820y}{48}[/math]

 

Now this is obviously going to give us two answers, and we want the positive one. So ignore the negative result (which would give x = -115y/6).

 

Hence we get [math]x = \frac{720y}{48}[/math] and the result follows.

 

Finding r is fairly trivial from this. Simply expand the two equations and add them together to get something along the lines of:

 

[math]-175y + r(400y + 20x) = 0[/math]

 

Now use your previous result to get: [math]r(400y+300y) = 175y[/math]. Divide through by y and simplify to get your answer.

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.