Jump to content

Two Questions Regarding a Corollary about Uniqueness

Featured Replies

Here's the corollary: Let X be a nonempty set and f : N×X → X be a function. For each x ∈ X there exists a unique sequence x(1), x(2), ... such that x(1) = x and x(n+1) = f(n,x(n)).

 

Question 1: What exactly does x(1) = x mean? In the same context, what would x(2) equal?

 

Question 2: What does the second part of this equation mean x(n+1) = f(n,x(n))? Is it an ordered pair for an x-y graph or...?

 

 

I'm assuming these are questions you're asking for yourself, and not questions you have to answer for an assignment. Mods forgive me if I'm incorrect. tongue.png

I'm assuming N is supposed to be the natural numbers. We have some function f that has the Cartesian product of N and X (i.e. all the ordered pairs (n, x) for n in N and x in X) as its domain and X as its codomain.

 

The corollary states that if we take any x in X, then there exists a unique sequence starting with x (this is what x(1) = x means) and defined by the recurrence relation x(n + 1) = f(n, x(n)), or alternatively x(n) = f(n - 1, x(n - 1)). Thus, letting x(1) = x, we have that x(2) = f(1, x(1)), x(3) = f(2, x(2)), etc. The precise form of this sequence will depend on the definition of f. All we know is that each term in the sequence must be an element of X (since X is the codomain of f).

As an example, let X be the rational numbers, and let f be defined such that f(n, x) = nx. Then, taking x = 3/5, we have that

 

x(1) = 3/5,

x(2) = f(1, x(1)) = (1)(3/5) = 3/5,

x(3) = f(2, x(2)) = (2)(3/5) = 6/5,

x(4) = f(3, x(3)) = (3)(6/5) = 18/5,

x(5) = f(4, x(4)) = (4)(18/5) = 72/5,

 

and so on.

Edited by John

  • Author

I'm assuming these are questions you're asking for yourself, and not questions you have to answer for an assignment. Mods forgive me if I'm incorrect. tongue.png

 

I'm assuming N is supposed to be the natural numbers. We have some function f that has the Cartesian product of N and X (i.e. all the ordered pairs (n, x) for n in N and x in X) as its domain and X as its codomain.

 

The corollary states that if we take any x in X, then there exists a unique sequence starting with x (this is what x(1) = x means) and defined by the recurrence relation x(n + 1) = f(n, x(n)), or alternatively x(n) = f(n - 1, x(n - 1)). Thus, letting x(1) = x, we have that x(2) = f(1, x(1)), x(3) = f(2, x(2)), etc. The precise form of this sequence will depend on the definition of f. All we know is that each term in the sequence must be an element of X (since X is the codomain of f).

 

As an example, let X be the rational numbers, and let f be defined such that f(n, x) = nx. Then, taking x = 3/5, we have that

 

x(1) = 3/5,

x(2) = f(1, x(1)) = (1)(3/5) = 3/5,

x(3) = f(2, x(2)) = (2)(3/5) = 6/5,

x(4) = f(3, x(3)) = (3)(6/5) = 18/5,

x(5) = f(4, x(4)) = (4)(18/5) = 72/5,

 

and so on.

These are my own questions to make sense of the corollary. Unfortunately, my professor does not seem to think that additional information is needed for the not-so-genius math students. Thank-you so much!

  • 4 weeks later...

Here's the corollary: Let X be a nonempty set and f : N×X → X be a function. For each x ∈ X there exists a unique sequence x(1), x(2), ... such that x(1) = x and x(n+1) = f(n,x(n)).

 

For each [latex]x\in X[/latex], let [latex]x_1=x[/latex]. Then let [latex]x_2=f(1,x_1)[/latex]. Then let [latex]x_3=f(2,x_2)[/latex], [latex]x_4=f(3,x_3)[/latex], [latex]x_5=f(4,x_4)[/latex], … and so on. This is what’s called a recursively defined sequence. The existence of such a sequence is obvious; the corollary asserts that it is the only one possible.

 

By the way, could you state the theorem or proposition to which this result is a corollary?

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.