Blog post: swansont: Follow That Law!

In his opinion for the court in the case, Mayo Collaborative Services v. Prometheus Laboratories, No. 10-1150, Justice Breyer started with first principles.

 

“Einstein could not patent his celebrated law that E = mc2[sic]; nor could Newton have patented the law of gravity,†he wrote.

…

In general, Justice Breyer wrote, an inventor must do more than “recite a law of nature and then add the instruction ‘apply the law.’ â€

 

“Einstein, we assume, could not have patented his famous law by claiming a process consisting of simply telling linear accelerator operators to refer to the law to determine how much energy an amount of mass has produced (or vice versa),†he wrote.