Skip to content

Resource Recycling and the Landauer Limit

Featured Replies

I began a thread a couple of weeks ago on the recovery of eg phosphorus from waste streams and ran into a curious coincidence I'd never really considered before. That is that both concentrating a resource by a factor of two (per particle) and the setting or unsetting of one bit of digital memory (couple of provisos) result in the release to the environment of a minimum amount of heat given by:

q = -kBT ln(2)

Is this just a coincidence or is there some deeper link?

I'm going to be adding some thoughts to this as they crystallize, but please feel free to chip in.

I'm going to reframe this in a third case that I'm a little more comfortable with. It's a rather odd set up, but bear with me, I'd like to exclude the complexities introduced by 'the environment.

Consider a fully insulated cylinder containing N atoms, one of which is Xenon, the remainder being Neon.

If Xe is in the left half of the cylinder with probability 1, we can equate that with a memory bit being set. If the probability is O, the bit is cleared. Generally, p(L) = 0.5 and the bit state is indeterminate.

Now include a semipermeable piston that can traverse the right half of the cylinder. Its pore size allows free passage of Ne but blocks the larger Xe atom. Moving the piston to the cylinder midpoint sets the bit, returning it to the right hand wall renders the bit indeterminate (after a certain delay).

This compression of the Xe will tend to increase its momentum, but for large N, particle collisions will disperse this rapidly and predominantly among the Ne atoms rendering the process (almost) isothermal (despite the superficially adiabatic set up).

The EoS for Xe can be expressed as:

PXeV = kBT

Using dW = PXedV it is fairly easy to show that the compression work ('setting the bit')

W = - kBT ln(2)

As QNe = -W

QNe = kBT ln(2)

DSXe = - kB ln(2)

DSNe = kB ln(2)

DSUniv = 0

  • Author

In theory (if not in practice) the excess pressure of the Xe on the left--facing side of the piston can be used to drive the piston back, recovering the work spent in setting the bit. The Xe decompression will tend to reduce the momentum of the Xe (reducing its ''temperature''), but this is recovered by its interaction with the previously slightly heated Ne atoms, recovering the ''waste heat" and converting it back into shaft work with 100% efficiency. Basically, all the figures in the above case are duplicated with reversed signage.

This is interesting since I've read that one reservation on the Landauer limit (I'm a total novice on information theory) is that it may not apply in a fully reversible adiabatic system. I guess in a roundabout way, this is what I've done here by setting up a pseudo-isothermal process in an adiabatic setup that is also reversible.

My gut reaction to the objection is that the theoretical reversibility may well be hopelessly impractical to realise IRL, but I'm going to have to sleep on this one I think. See how I feel about it tomorrow.

To close for now, I seem to have a classical thermodynamic representation here that is at one and the same time

a) a typical thermodynamic compression/expansion cycle

b) a concentration doubling of a resource in some arbitrary medium.

c) a deletion of a digital bit of memory (in the Maxwell's Demon refutation sense)

Identical mathematical model therefore identical mechanisms?

Create an account or sign in to comment

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.