Skip to content

Friedmann equation for transforming observer - a certain kind of space transformation applied for cosmology

Featured Replies

Friedmann equation for transforming observer - a certain kind of space transformation applied for cosmology

Hi all, i try to keep this thread as short as possible. If you remember my post about same subject this is solely for the reason i managed to derive Friedmann equation to my model. But if not, don't read it, i introduce this model from the beginning here. This text has everything i hope in right Place.

This model is for me a mathematical self-consistency like effort: Transforming matter gives certain kind of Friedmann equation and some interesting differences in cosmological observations. (this quote is taken from the last words section)

I don't use latex. However, these equations should be very easy to read.

CONTENTS:

------------

Space transformation - what it is (generally speaking)?

Model: isotropic length transformation

Two different kind of coordinate systems

Important Theorems

The first Friedmann equation

Equation 1 - non-shrinking coordinates, in steady time

Equation 2 - non-shrinking coordinates, in accelerating time

Equation 3 - for Shrinking or transforming observer

Exponential L - a good starting point

Some initial results from iteration

Last words

Space transformation - what it is (generally speaking)?

-----

Space transformation is generally a transformation of one, several or most of the physical properties of the area of space that affects on the physical objects inside the area. It also can be alternatively transformation of physical object or property of physical object where some of the properties of the object changes. It may or may not be attached to some physical object.

Space itself can transform, it may contract, bend, curve, twist.

The transformation can depend on time. oscillate and for example remind of standing wave motion while there is no wave going back and forth in it. in this case it looks like a standing wave but it is not a wave at all. This is very general and philosophical description.

Space transformation is a new kind of class of hypothetical phenomena. All of this is hypothetical unless if you count gravitational field as a certain kind of space transformation and describe Minkowsky's spacetime as certain kind of space transformation.

Space transformations may have nothing to do with special relativity or Einstein's field equation, it is additional hypothetical phenomenon what neither of these theories know nothing about or does not describe them mathematically.

Just to give a suggestion, space transformations may have explanation power for explaining particle-wave duality or explaining renormalisation. In both of these cases it may be possible to assume that there is some kind of space transformation that takes Place near a particle or in the surroundings of a particle. But the space transformation - whatever it is, itself may be difficult to observe directly.

But here i concentrate only one hypothetical type of space transformation: isotropic length transformation. And i demand that it has some special kind of properties.

Model: isotropic length transformation

-----

I am thinking the model where some but not all of the expansion of the space in cosmological scales is coming from that all matter in the universe undergo isotropic length transformation. - this is a phenomenon that has never been observed. This transformation happens in areas which contract towards their center. The size of such areas of contraction is not strictly speaking defined. The size must be bigger than solar system - otherwise we would see distances in solar system to grow.

In the isotropic transformation, i introduce four Basic assumptions or demands

1. All lengths transform by factor L

2. The duration of all events gets shorter by factor L

3. All energies and masses increase by factor 1/L

4. all electric charges remain unchanged

I also demand that this isotropic transformation satisfies the principle of relativity of natural laws, which states that transformed observer, when L is not changing or dL/dt = 0, observes all laws of nature to remain unchanged in his perspective in the area of transformation.

Example if a box and observer inside it has contracted such that L = 0.5

=>

-all lengths have contracted by factor 0.5

-duration of all events have become shorter by factor 0.5

-all energies and masses have increased by factor 2

-all electric charges have remained unchanged

But according to relativity principle , transformed observer does not observe anything different in the laws of nature inside a box. He also measure no changes in any length, duration, masser or energies inside the box. But if he can see from the window in the box to outside World, he would measure the inverse changes there.

This hypothetical isotropic transformation can exist in relative rest. If the transformation is moving, it is subject to special relativity.

By doing simple dimensional analysis and assuming the relativity principle to be valid or true, i can work out how different physical properties change

1 all velocities, Planck constant

1/L acceleration, frequency, temperature

1/L^2 all forces and powers

1/L^4 density, Surface brightness

L^2 gravitational constant

L gravitational influence that is G times mass: G*M

This transformation keeps all velocities and Planck constant unchanged, but gravitational constant and gravitational influence changes.

If we concider what happens to gravitational field there are following changes

-the field size and all lengths change by factor L

-gravitational acceleration change by 1/L (note that the Place of measurement is shifted)

-the escape velocities remain unchanged (note that the Place of measurement is shifted)

The principle of relativity, if it is true, then gravitation and standard model of physics both transform according to equations of change above, including all of their parameters. Even the strength of Higg's field in vacuum is changed by factor 1/L.

The transformation changes energies, so it may violate the principle of conservation of energy (unless there is some kind of source for energy where the energy comes from)

Next, i assume that all matter in the universe has the same transformation factor and undergo this transformation. There are transformation areas that transform towards the center of the area.

The size of such areas must be larger than solar system since we don't observe any changes in the distances between the planets and the sun. For example earth-sun distance is observed to grow only by 15,4 cm/year. If the rate of apparent expansion is same magnitude than Hubble parameter, earth-sun distance should increase by 10.4 m/year or less if the solar system would not transform as a complete system.

Two different kind of coordinate systems

-----

There are two different kind of coordinate systems: non-shrinking coordinates and shrinking coordinates. In non-shrinking coordinates only ordinary expansion of space is observed and matter is observed to undergo transformation. In shrinking coordinates both apparent and ordinary expansion of space is observed.

Following equations describe how shrinking observer observes any radius and infinitesimal time interval related to similar quantities observed in non-shrinking coordinates

r' = r/L radius or length

dt' = dt/L infinitesimal time interval

' -mark generally is a property that transforming observer observes

L is so called shrinking function

Example: if non-transforming observer measures some object's length to be 10 m, and the shrinking function L has value 0.5 then transforming observer would measure the length of the exaclly same object to be (10 m)/0.5 = 20 m .

t can be called a stationary or steady time of non-shrinking coordinates

t' can be called as accelerating time of shrinking coordinates or shrinking observer

Also following equations show how transforming observer observes the same energy and mass related to non-transforming observer

E' = E*L energy

m' = m*L mass

What is happening in non-shrinking coordinates is that ordinary matter undergo isotropic length transformation that happens in areas that contract towards contraction centers. Therefore the density of ordinary matter changes like 1/L and duration of infinitesimal time intervals changes like L. But since the areas of contraction do not move, in cosmological scales the density changes only because the mass of the matter is increasing like 1/L.

Important Theorems

-----

THEOREM 1: I claim that the metric, that shrinking observer observes, that is now partially apparent, satisfies equation for Robertson Walker metric

dtau'^2 = c^dt'^2 - a'dr'^2

where a' = a/L

' -mark generally is a property that shrinking observer observes

a' is scale factor that is observed by shrinking observer

a is scale factor in non-shrinking coordinates that describes the ordinary expansion of space.

L is now so called shrinking function. L(t_0') = 1 and dL/dt' < 0

and in non-shrinking coordinates the ordinary expansion of space satisfies ordinary Robertson Walker metric:

dtau^2 = c^dt^2 - a*dr^2

I here assume that the space is flat - the curvature term is zero.

THEOREM 2: I also claim that this transformation gives all similar cosmological observations than ordinary Robertson Walker metric does.

Observations are:

-cosmological redshift

-cosmological time dilation

-Surface brightness is inverse proportional to 4th power of redshift

-angular diameter-redshift relation

There are two exceptions however:

1.relativistic and compact matter may shrink at slower rate than ordinary matter. Black holes may not shrink at all after they have been born. This is because of time dilation.

2.there is delay effect in gravitation since the gravitational field transforms and if it updates at the velocity of light. But the transformation may happen and gravitation may update simultaneously however in shorter length scales. IF there is delay, then Distant object feels the 'old' gravitation field instead of the 'new' field. but this is very Small effect.

The first Friedmann equation

-----

The Friedmann equation can be written in three different forms:

1. Friedmann equation in non-transforming coordinates in constant time

2. Friedmann equation in non-transforming coordinates in accelerating time

3. Friedmann equation for transforming observer in accelerating time

Equation 1

-----

All the physics happens in non-transforming or non-shrinking coordinates, so i have to write Friedmann equation first in these coordinates. It is

H(t)^2 = (8piG/3)[L*rho_m,0/a^3 + R*rho_r,0/a^4 + rho_Lambda]

The density of ordinary matter changes by factor 1/L but the gravitational constant for ordinary matter change by L^2. Therefore G*rho_m changes by factor L

The gravitational constant for radiation is the same as gravitational constant of the matter that has emitted it (this is an assumption). Most of the radiation in the universe is coming from recombination era, therefore the gravitational constant for radiation is close to L_rec^2 times different than G for light emitted by normal matter in present time.

Therefore factoiral function R is in the moment of recombination same as L_recombination^2 but it increases over time slightly since there are some sources of radiation in the universe and this radiation adds up into the function R.

NOTE that now terms in right side of equation change not only because the density of matter and light change but because their gravitational influence changes. These terms now do not solely depend on density anymore but they depend on gravitational influence of matter and radiation.

I assume that rho_Lambda is constant in non-shrinking coordinates. The direct consequence of this is that transforming observer would measure rho_Lambda to change like L^4 (if he could somehow measure this density).

I could mention shortly about densities.

In non-transforming coordinates the density is

rho = (1/L)rho_m,0/a^3 + rho_r,0/a^4 + rho_Lambda

Since rho' = L^4 rho and a = La' the densities of matter, radiation and lambda are for transforming observer:

rho' = rho_m,0/a'^3 + rho_r,0/a'^4 + L^4*rho_Lambda

Equation 2

-----

There is connection between accelerating time t' and stationary time t such that

dt' = dt/L

=> H(t) = H(t')/L

=> H(t')^2 = (8piG/3)[L^3*rho_m,0/a^3 + R*L^2*rho_r,0/a^4 + L^2*rho_Lambda]

This is equation 2.

Equation 3

-----

since

a = La'

=> H'(t') = H(t') - (1/L)(dL/dt')

=> [H'(t') + (1/L)(dL/dt')]^2 = (8piG/3)[rho_m,0/a'^3 + (R*/L^2)*rho_r,0/a'^4 + L^2*rho_Lambda]

This is equation 3. It is valid after the time of recombination. Before the time of recombination the 3rd equation is

[H'(t') + (1/L)(dL/dt')]^2 = (8piG/3)[rho_m,0/a'^3 + rho_r,0/a'^4 + L^2*rho_Lambda]

Before recombination the radiation is continuously emitted and absorbed. Therefore there is no correction term for gravitation effect in front of radiation.

(you can work out eq.1 and eq.2 for time before recombination by same reasoning.)

Exponential L - a good starting point

-----

Exponential L means that proportional change in observed redshift in light that is moving freely in space is constant for shrinking or transforming observer:

dlambda/dt' = k * lambda(t')

where k is constant.

since a' = a/L

= > dL/dt' = -k * L(t') and remembering that L(t_0) = 1

=> L(t') = exp[-k(t'-t_0')]

IF i make assumption that L is exponential L(t') = exp[-k(t'-t_0')]

then (1/L)(dL/dt') = -k

and the equation 3a becomes

[H'(t') - k ]^2 = (8piG/3)[rho_m,0/a'^3 + (R*/L^2)*rho_r,0/a'^4 + L^2*rho_Lambda]

and equation 3b before recombination becomes

[H'(t') - k ]^2 = (8piG/3)[rho_m,0/a'^3 + rho_r,0/a'^4 + L^2*rho_Lambda]

This is quite similar to Friedmann equation in Lambda-CDM model.

NOTE:But if L(t') is exponential, then L(t) = 1 - k(t-t_0) as a function of steady time t which means that the matter will transform into zero in non-infinite amount of steady time t but in infinite amount of accelerating time t'

Some initial results from iteration

-----

I assumed that L = exp[-k(t'-t_0')] where k is constant.

The k that is contraction constant, must be fitted to observations of Hubble constant in present time H'(t_0') . Other restriction is that a'(t_recombination) = 1/1100. Hubble constant at the time of recombination can be calculated to get da'/dt' at the moment of recombination. k in the left side of the equation can be ignored in recombination moment since it is very small.

By doing iteration such as bracketing, it is possible to find value for k and rho_Lambda and then it is possible to draw curve for a'(t') and for example estimate how long ago recombination happened (t_rec' - t_0') in the past.

When i assumed that rho_Lambda is zero, the exponential L gives somewhat similar curve a'(t') than Lambda-CDM model in the past but the curve is slightly too steep and i get the age of the universe to be somewhere between 12 to 12.8 Billion years.

I remember AI suggested that k somewhere near k = 1.0 * 10^-18 [1/s] when rho_Lambda = 0

Therefore the function L must be less steep than exponential function of time t' or the density of dark energy rho_Lambda is not zero.

Last words

This model is for me a mathematical self-consistency like effort: Transforming matter gives certain kind of Friedmann equation and some interesting differences in cosmological observations. But this phenomenon - isotropic length transformation may not truly happen in cosmological time scales to matter in the universe.

The function L is unknown, it may be something else than exponential and in principle it may depends on something else also than only depend on time.

Nobody has ever seen transformed particles in the history of science. On the other hand they may not be produced in particle collisions. The red-shifted or blue-shifted light from transformed matter looks similar than Doppler-effect in spectral lines. Cosmic rays may have small amount of this kind of particles. I don't know how well a mass of cosmic ray protons have been measured in cosmic ray observations.

i stop here.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.