Do you think these two researches are particularly compatible with each other?

I've read some works of Emilio del giudice about coherence domains in water.

However I saw this interesting article on Brownian Collisions which make the formation of these coherence domains something quite hard to possibly exist.....

Here is the article:-

https://www.researchgate.net/publication/328024287_Limits_on_Quantum_Coherent_Domains_in_Liquid_Water

Also here are two more articles on coherence domains in water;-

https://m.scirp.org/papers/90862  (umm click download pdf cuz scirp articles on the site are presented in a very hard to read manner)

https://www.researchgate.net/publication/333531765_Deep_into_the_Water_Exploring_the_Hydro-Electromagnetic_and_Quantum-Electrodynamic_Properties_of_Interfacial_Water_in_Living_Systems

According to me I think the bottom two articles are linked are essentially based on not taking into consideration the problem of decoherence and Brownian Collisions......

What is your take?