Alenruffneck

So I've been watching some documentaries involving black holes and the information paradox involved with quantum mechanics which says information can never be destroyed... I had an idea to this theory involving black holes and thermal or 'hawking' radiation that doesn't contain information as its released, in a sense it's blank data... I understand everything we see can be traced back in some way to show all its "lifelong information" so I ask anyone to take a recycled water bottle, and give me a detailed description of everything the atoms in that bottle ever were before they were a scrap bottle. Not just scraps of plastic remolded into another bottle, but according to the theory, anyone should be able to trace and describe everything those particles ever were since their inception into existence... So can anyone follow the particles of a recycled water bottle (or anything) back through time on this planet, time in a nebula, time in a star, and where they all were billions of years ago? Or just simple the information we see today? And I mean- dates, times, matter, everything for the past 10 billion years? Or just oh it was here, then there, now here... according to the theory, you should be able to trace it all back to its inception with details and tell me exactly what it is... can anyone do that? Or can we accept there are ways information can be 'wiped' and brand new with a clean slate? If if not, explain... cause I feel if nobody can, than in information paradox is just another way of saying 'we have no clue'