Jump to content

Anti-Life: Can we make live with reverse handedness


Recommended Posts

So life is made from chemicals with specific handedness. But as far as I know, it should in theory work just as well with all the handedness reversed. I'm not sure if we could actually make one though, due to technological difficulties. If we could make life with the opposite handedness, how would you go about making it?

 

And a related question, could we eat the result?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

we could eat the result fine. although it may not have the same nutritional benefit. such as with glucose.

 

there are two forms of glucose, L-glucose and the common D-Glucose(reffered to as dextrose in food and pharma) dextrose will taste sweet and can be metabolised while L-glucose tastes slightly less sweet and cannot be metabolised(makes a good sweetner)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

We could synthesize bio-molecules of the opposite chirality [i.e. D versus L amino acids], but it is expensive and cumbersome as we can't use natural products as a major feedstock in many cases. Stereo-isomerization of amino-acids is not fun; multi-step process, requires strict control of conditions to avoid side reactions.

I think our best bet would be to genetically engineer a micro organism to do the chemical dirty work for us by consuming achiral nutrients and producing "unnaturally chiral" biochemicals

Link to comment
Share on other sites

So life is made from chemicals with specific handedness. But as far as I know, it should in theory work just as well with all the handedness reversed. I'm not sure if we could actually make one though, due to technological difficulties. If we could make life with the opposite handedness, how would you go about making it?

 

And a related question, could we eat the result?

 

STUPIDEST QUESTION EVER (go easy on me, I'm a physicist, not a biologist): What do you mean 'specific handedness'? I assume you don't mean 'right handed' people or (like me!) the brilliant left-handed people.

 

What's "Handedness" in this context?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

STUPIDEST QUESTION EVER (go easy on me, I'm a physicist, not a biologist): What do you mean 'specific handedness'? I assume you don't mean 'right handed' people or (like me!) the brilliant left-handed people.

 

What's "Handedness" in this context?

 

I'll save you some time. Chirality is the chemical term for "handedness". This is a measure of the ability of a non-centrosymmetric molecule to rotate a plane of polarized light. In organic chermistry we use the formalisms R and S to say right and left handed respectivley. Biochemistry uses D and L, Inorganic chemistry uses [math]\Delta[/math] and [math]\Lambda[/math].

Edited by mississippichem
Link to comment
Share on other sites

This is not theoretically possible without inverting all the chiralities of physical particles and amino acids and sugars and nucleotides all the way from the Origin of the Universe to the emergence of the first cell.

 

Peace,

 

Ik

 

 

Shouldn't there also be something in here about a gyre? I feel like there's a gyre missing.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Good one, PhDwannabe, yes, gyres are levoral and dextral, accounting for the two hands that I use on this keyboard and the chiralities that exist throughout the cosmological, physical, chemical, and biological realms.

 

 

<whispering to self> ...dextral, yes... Yes, that clears things up significantly.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yes, dextral (right-handed chirality, gyrates counter-clockwise when viewed en face - bottom of image) and levoral (left-handed chirality, gyrates clockwise when viewed en face - top of image). Here's a heuristic (hopefully it works, first time uploading image): post-31642-084550000 1282086305_thumb.jpg

 

Peace,

 

Ik

 

Edit: Good, the image appears. Knowing that will be helpful in terms of facilitating discussion and explaining how I exist and work in the Universe.

Edited by TheTheoretician
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1 month later...

My understanding is the majority of organic molecules found in life on earth are L- (left handed). There is no functional reason that life could not have evolved (here or elsewhere) using predominantly D- (right handed) molecules...however, we cannot substitute D- for L- in our biological needs.*

 

For example, Motrin is a chiral molecule. Because of the difficulty in separating D- from L-, Motrin tablets contain an equal dispersion (racemic) mix of L- and D-...however only the L- enantiomer is functional. The D- enantiomer is simply disposed of by the liver.

 

Thus, theoretically, when Captain Kirk (or Stargate Universe if I want to update) travel around foreign planets to find food, there is at least a 50/50 odds that the food they found would be incompatible with our biology. I don't know under what circumstances this incompatibility would be toxic...but the aforementioned Motrin example infers it would just be a waste of food.

 

Perhaps the real purpose in engineering D- enantiomer foodstuffs would be to create the next big diet craze?

 

Interesting link...

 

http://en.wikipedia....popular_fiction

 

* From the MIT lecture series "MIT OCW: 7.012: Introduction to Biology" available from iTunes"

Edited by BurningKrome
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thus, theoretically, when Captain Kirk (or Stargate Universe if I want to update) travel around foreign planets to find food, there is at least a 50/50 odds that the food they found would be incompatible with our biology. I don't know under what circumstances this incompatibility would be toxic...but the aforementioned Motrin example infers it would just be a waste of food.

In both Star Trek and Stargate, life throughout the galaxy was seeded from life evolved on Earth.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.