Jump to content

Gas in a vacuum?


Recommended Posts

This thought came to me as i was smoking a cigarette last night. As i blew the smoke out, a big cloud formed. A fan was blowing nearby and slightly contorted the shape of the cloud. I noticed that it took basically the same shape as the gas clouds we have seen that are involved with the birth of a star.

 

It made me think that if there is no air resistance in a vacuum(space), how does a gas cloud spread out and take the form it does.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This thought came to me as i was smoking a cigarette last night. As i blew the smoke out' date=' a big cloud formed. A fan was blowing nearby and slightly contorted the shape of the cloud. I noticed that it took basically the same shape as the gas clouds we have seen that are involved with the birth of a star.

 

It made me think that if there is no air resistance in a vacuum(space), how does a gas cloud spread out and take the form it does.[/quote']

 

I think mabye if you gave up smoking it would give you extra time to concider it. :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

i usualy hear that it spreads out because it spins (which as we know lowers the pressure it would exert on anything, but i's a near vacuum, so there's not much for it to exert pressure on)

 

:confused:

 

How does spinning lower the pressure?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think mabye if you gave up smoking it would give you extra time to concider it. :)

 

i am planning on quitting. I have since the day i started. But how does that give me extra time to consider anything. And what good would considering do, when i know nothing about my question.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hmmm,,,the star being born would have a gravity,,this gravity would attract the gases,,but also other material,,like rocks,,,lots and lots of rocks,,,all sizes,,,then these rocks also begin to collect together forming new planets,,,all of this swirls around the sun,,,or newly formed sun,,,or newly forming sun. Which then gives it that cool spirlly effect that we all like so much. But i have no source to back my claim up. therefore,,i will call it speculation.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

bernouli's principle.

 

I don't see how this applies to the situation. Bernoulli's priciple is that a moving fluid exerts less pressure. Nothing specifically about spinning, and no direct application to a cloud of diffuse gas in a vacuum.

 

It seems like it's diffusion, and nothing more.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ok, im trying to understand how gas would act in a perfect vacuum. If gas was in a perfect vacuum, wouldnt it just sink to the bottom. And if there was a large source of gravity acting on it wouldnt it move in a straight line directly to the source.

 

So, its generally said that space is a vacuum. But we know that space is not a perfect vacuum. Maybe space shouldnt be thought of as a vacuum. Maybe the atmosphere of space is made of particles too small for us to measure. Therefore, it shouldnt be considered a vacuum, but an entity that is there but acts like a vacuum to things that are on a bigger scale than what the atmosphere is made of.

 

Is that making any sense. I need to read more about the atmosphere of space.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If gas was in a perfect vacuum, wouldnt it just sink to the bottom

 

If you put a gas where there was once vacuum, it would no longer be vacuum. There is nothing such as a gas in vacuum. As soosn as a gas comes into such a volume, unless it is an enormous quantity, it would merely diffuse out. In case of enormous volumes gravity will come into picture too.

 

Maybe the atmosphere of space is made of particles too small for us to measure

 

Atmosphere means air cover, since space has none, wrong to use that term. Particles too small for us to measure, wats all that about ? Not just imaginative but given todays knowledge of physics probably impossible.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

i think u thought it would sink to the bottom because it is denser than a vacuum. there would be nothing for it to be denser than. and that only applies within the effects of gravity, say on a planet. the gas would diffuse, unless it was an enormous ammount, then it would clump togather do to it's own gravity

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If you put a gas where there was once vacuum' date=' it would no longer be vacuum. There is nothing such as a gas in vacuum. As soosn as a gas comes into such a volume, unless it is an enormous quantity, it would merely diffuse out. In case of enormous volumes gravity will come into picture too.

[/quote']

 

The notion of vacuum = "perfect vacuum" isn't used very much in science applications. What is used most often is that a vacuum is a region that has a pressure significantly lower than 1 atmosphere.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I don't see how this applies to the situation. Bernoulli's priciple is that a moving fluid exerts less pressure. Nothing specifically about spinning' date=' and no direct application to a cloud of diffuse gas in a vacuum.

 

It seems like it's diffusion, and nothing more.[/quote']

 

i was answering a question

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I figured it would be like the experiment with a feather and a marble, or whatever, in a tube that has all the air sucked out. And since there would be no "atmosphere" they both drop at the same speed. Wouldnt a gas be heavy in that situation, and just drop to the bottom. How would it diffuse out if there is nothing to resist its fall. If im not mistaken i do believe that gas does have mass, and would therefore fall to the bottom.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I figured it would be like the experiment with a feather and a marble, or whatever, in a tube that has all the air sucked out. And since there would be no "atmosphere" they both drop at the same speed. Wouldnt a gas be heavy in that situation, and just drop to the bottom. How would it diffuse out if there is nothing to resist its fall. If im not mistaken i do believe that gas does have mass, and would therefore fall to the bottom.

 

The problem is, gas IS atmosphere as such. When we are talking at pressures of the ISM (interstellar medium) which are in the range of 10^-11 to 10^-13 mbar gases no longer behave in the same fashion as they do at atmosphere (i.e. they do not flow). This is because the molecules in the gas are often total independent due to the fact that their mean free path (the average distance between collisions) is huge as their are so few molecule per unit volume. The effect of gravity on individual molecules is small compared to their Kinetic energy (in Ultra High Vacuum Chambers gases are wizzing around at about the speed of sound) so they just bounce around inside the container. In space, however, there is no up or down, so despite the molecules in the ISM having low kinetic energies (T = a few K) they just move around in a random fashion - on the large scale this, however, is expansions as molecule that are head away from a high pressure region are less likely to experience a collision than those heading towards it. As there are few collisions and the gases are very cold - expansion occurs very slowly in space.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The problem is, gas IS atmosphere as such. When we are talking at pressures of the ISM (interstellar medium) which are in the range of 10^-11 to 10^-13 mbar gases no longer behave in the same fashion as they do at atmosphere (i.e. they do not flow). This is because the molecules in the gas are often total independent due to the fact that their mean free path (the average distance between collisions) is huge as their are so few molecule per unit volume. The effect of gravity on individual molecules is small compared to their Kinetic energy (in Ultra High Vacuum Chambers gases are wizzing around at about the speed of sound) so they just bounce around inside the container. In space, however, there is no up or down, so despite the molecules in the ISM having low kinetic energies (T = a few K) they just move around in a random fashion - on the large scale this, however, is expansions as molecule that are head away from a high pressure region are less likely to experience a collision than those heading towards it. As there are few collisions and the gases are very cold - expansion occurs very slowly in space.

 

 

 

Good post. Thats the best explanation so far. Do you know how these stellar nebula's get started? Is there like some central point that sucks everything in, or do the gases just coincidentally run into each other and interact respectively.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.