I don't know how you got the problem you describe. I've never mentioned anything like that. I have mentioned two other problems earlier in the thread. Problem A: Problem B: Emphasis is on "compass only". No straightedge, no straight lines, nil, nada, niet! The question in the thread was NOT how to solve these problems. I've solved both of them. (Without drawing any straight lines.) My initial solution used a point where two circles constructed on an intermediate step