Jump to content

Water from thin air


mildredx

Recommended Posts

A sheet of plastic film, horizontally sloped, a few feet off the ground, will cool down much faster at night than the ground.
Warmer, moisture bearing, air next to the ground will rise, water will condense on the cool plastic, nd run down the slope into a container.
This should give you some water for the next day, although I've never done this; Only seen it in movies/TV.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The trick is to get something cooler than the dew point of the surrounding air so that moisture in the air condenses on the surface in a manner that it can then be collected. MigL's suggestion does all that (it can be as simple as a piece of plastic stretched between, say, four rocks weighted down by four more with a small pebble sitting in the middle to get a bit of slope, and a cup underneath the lowest point to catch the accumulating water.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Shouldn't this be in Homework Help if it's for a project?

 

16 minutes ago, J.C.MacSwell said:

The trick is to get something cooler than the dew point of the surrounding air so that moisture in the air condenses on the surface in a manner that it can then be collected. MigL's suggestion does all that (it can be as simple as a piece of plastic stretched between, say, four rocks weighted down by four more with a small pebble sitting in the middle to get a bit of slope, and a cup underneath the lowest point to catch the accumulating water.

It's slightly more complicated than that, because the surrounding air is often very (very) dry so your apparatus would have to be very very cold to reach dewpoint.

The purpose of the plastic tent is to evaporate some of the liquid water and concetrate it just under the tent.
This greatly raises the humidity of the air just under the tent.

So this tent does not have to be so cold, in fact you can often see condensation under polythene sheeting.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, studiot said:

Shouldn't this be in Homework Help if it's for a project?

 

It's slightly more complicated than that, because the surrounding air is often very (very) dry so your apparatus would have to be very very cold to reach dewpoint.

The purpose of the plastic tent is to evaporate some of the liquid water and concetrate it just under the tent.
This greatly raises the humidity of the air just under the tent.

So this tent does not have to be so cold, in fact you can often see condensation under polythene sheeting.

What I meant by surrounding air was the air immediately surrounding the cool surface...so probably a bad choice of wording. And as you suggest raising the humidity of that air can also help, especially in dry air conditions.

What MigL described is typically done overnight, taking advantage of the warmth remaining in the soil and the cooler exposed plastic. You are describing something closer to a solar still. It can be quite productive if there is a lot of moisture in the soil, even with the plastic likely to be above the ambient temperature. In this case it is best if the plastic is sealed around the perimeter.

At some point we are crossing a line of getting the water from "thin air" if that is the goal.

Edited by J.C.MacSwell
Link to comment
Share on other sites

32 minutes ago, J.C.MacSwell said:

What I meant by surrounding air was the air immediately surrounding the cool surface...so probably a bad choice of wording. And as you suggest raising the humidity of that air can also help, especially in dry air conditions.

What MigL described is typically done overnight, taking advantage of the warmth remaining in the soil and the cooler exposed plastic. You are describing something closer to a solar still. It can be quite productive if there is a lot of moisture in the soil, even with the plastic likely to be above the ambient temperature. In this case it is best if the plastic is sealed around the perimeter.

At some point we are crossing a line of getting the water from "thin air" if that is the goal.

But the air doesn't usually surround the surface.

Water for instance does not condense on the top surface of the same polythene.

Take a piece of plastic that nowhere near covers or tents a region of air and see just how far you have to cool it to creat condensation on either top or undersurface..

 

So however you cause the evaporation it is also important that the resulting higher humidity is not allowed to escape.

And yes the 'desert still' (also effective in the open ocean) is the ultimate version of this.

To go to forced cooling, you would be talking about desalination plant, which I don't think is the purpose here.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 minutes ago, studiot said:

But the air doesn't usually surround the surface.

 

It doesn't with the plastic, no. But it generally does for the most part where the cooled surface is exposed to the air. I was picturing a dehumidifier when I initially wrote that before remarking on MigL's suggestion.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yes, the dehumidifier is a scaled down version of the industrial plant I mentioned.

1 minute ago, mathematic said:

You could buy a dehumidifier.

True, the device has apparently to be different from that which someone else has already made.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I want to mention that I tested Migl idea last night and the plastic sheet had a lot of water droplets on in.  Did not measure it as I didn't have it in a slope.

Studiot, I just want to mention that this is NOT HW and should not be part of Homework Help! I am doing this with my other science friends as who accomplishes the best result.

Migl and J.C. MacSwell

Thank you for the idea. 

I plan to do the following:

 

I want to experiment with digging a hole in the ground (colder temperature helps reach dew point) and using a sheet of plastic or cone shaped metal that the water will condense on and run down to drip into a container.

Please advise

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Sounds feasible - what you propose is similar to what they have already suggested..  Secure the sheet across the hole and put a small weight/pebble in the middle to create the slope...  The water will collect in the sheet.  I guess you could puncture a small hole in the centre too and have a container underneath to collect the drops. This way you will get any condensation collecting under the plastic as well maybe.

 

Good luck. :) 

Edited by DrP
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, mildredx said:

I want to experiment with digging a hole in the ground (colder temperature helps reach dew point) and using a sheet of plastic or cone shaped metal that the water will condense on and run down to drip into a container.

Please advise

Good survival trick:

 

Edited by iNow
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hello MigL,

LOL Nothing like that, although I wish I was on a reality show to see how long one can go with little bits of water until the finish line.  I belong to a group of science females and we were just thinking if such thing was possible.  We took a look at WATERSEER and they called it a "Busted" experiment.  This forum changed that.  Thanks to everyone here.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, mildredx said:

Hello MigL,

LOL Nothing like that, although I wish I was on a reality show to see how long one can go with little bits of water until the finish line.  I belong to a group of science females and we were just thinking if such thing was possible.  We took a look at WATERSEER and they called it a "Busted" experiment.  This forum changed that.  Thanks to everyone here.

Actually, in the desert, I do not believe this will be very effective.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 minutes ago, Raider5678 said:

Actually, in the desert, I do not believe this will be very effective.

Yeah. No magic involved. There has to be sufficient water in the air, and the collecting surface needs to be maintained below the dew point. Tough to do that in very dry conditions.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.