Reality isn't black and white, and it is reality that we are trying to figure out.
How many experiments and observations has been used to confirm relativity? I'm quite sure it's more than two. Luckily they all agreed with the theory. Probably because it's correct.
But there are many theories, who are also not black and white, and who can be confirmed with many experiments. What if one of them has five experiments to validate it, and one that does not? Even an improved version still does not. Then we need to re-evaluate the theory, right?
PS. I hold the highest regard for our theories, but I must insist that they are just interpretations of smaller facts put together.