It is really based on logic reasoning. Well, let it be Telomere or other DNA strands, whichever gets reset during the mitosis process might be the key to aging. There really shouldn't be any DNA damage on the sperm cells, if the amount of damage equals to the number of ages of a person, a damaged sperm could give rise to a 5, 10 years old, which is impossible. So somewhere along the line there should be a perfect reset, let it be lengthening the Telomere or repair the gene damages, clearly something is able to reset the damage to DNA.
Short reasoning:
Damage to my DNA causing me to age to 29 years old -> Create damaged DNA sperms -> Sperm give rise to 29 years old baby is clearly impossible
P.S. Endy0816, you are right, Telomere does sounds like the key to aging