Science Forums: How could Ilan Ramon’s Diary Survive the Fall from Space? - Science Forums

Jump to content

Welcome to ScienceForums.Net!

Welcome to ScienceForums.Net! We welcome science discussion at all levels — from beginners to researchers, covering topics from biology to computer science, and much more. Registration is fast and free, and allows you to post on the forums, so register now and join the discussions!
  
After you've registered, come in and introduce yourself, or visit the forum index. If you need any help  registering, posting, or if you just have some questions about our site, please feel free to contact us at staff at scienceforums dot net.

  • Start new topics and reply to others
  • Subscribe to topics and forums to get automatic updates
  • Create a ScienceForums.Net Blog!
Guest Message © 2012 DevFuse
Page 1 of 1
  • You cannot start a new topic
  • You cannot reply to this topic

How could Ilan Ramon’s Diary Survive the Fall from Space? Rate Topic: -----

#1 mooeypoo 


Icon
Oh look, Pwnies!

Quote

A little while ago, the Israeli Museum in Jerusalem opened an exhibit featuring some of the torn, slightly burned pages of Col. Ilan Ramon’s personal diary from the shuttle Columbia. Ramon was the payload specialist onboard STS-107 (the spaceshuttle “Columbia”) that disintegrated during re-entry from space, killing all 7 crewmembers onboard. The diary survived the re-entry and subsequent crash, and was found in a field next to Palestine, TX.
Ramon’s personal diary fell close to 37 miles (almost 60 km) through the extreme conditions of re-entry. Unlike its human owner, it has survived the process and is now being restored and presented to the public in the Israeli Museum in Jerusalem.
During the weeks and months after the Columbia disaster, pieces of the debris were still being collected from wide areas in Texas. small pieces of insulation that detached from the outer parts of the shuttle to pieces of the Astronauts’ space suits. In an article covering the subject on “Universe Today”, The Israeli Museum curator is quoted as saying that “There is no rational explanation for how it was recovered when most of the shuttle was not.” It is no wonder, then, that many are awe-struck at such an apparent miracle.
But is there, really, no rational explanation for the survival of the diary? None at all? I doubt that. And when I doubt, I check it out, which is exactly what I am about to do.


Read more here.

Feel free to criticize, discuss, and make your own hypotheses (based on evidence, of course)
Find a Graduate Program in Physics, Astronomy and Related Fields
(From the American Institute of Physics)

Visit my Science@Home Website: http://www.smarterthanthat.com


If I was helpful, let me know by clicking the [+] sign ->
0

#2 User is online  insane_alien 


Genius
well, it could have been sucked out of a hull breach when the shuttle began to disintegrate and due to its high surface are to mass ratio rapidly decelerated before much frictional heating occured. also, the low oxygen up there would have prevented it from combusting as normal.

its actually quite feasible that it survived a partial reentry.
Tired of waiting around for a reply on the forums? Use IRC, 'I don't know how' is no longer an excuse.

"Special" Relativity, stupid ideas seem smarter when they come at you really fast.
0

#3 mooeypoo 


Icon
Oh look, Pwnies!
Yes, tht's what I claimed too. What do youthink of my hypothesis? (it's continuing in the link i supplied)
Find a Graduate Program in Physics, Astronomy and Related Fields
(From the American Institute of Physics)

Visit my Science@Home Website: http://www.smarterthanthat.com


If I was helpful, let me know by clicking the [+] sign ->
0

#4 Gilded 


Primate
I think terminal velocity is pretty much key here, good that you mentioned it. A diary isn't exactly the most aerodynamic object ever, and its structure prevents it from breaking into thousands of pieces even if it does drop from high enough to achieve terminal velocity.
Gonna paint the table, gonna paint it fine
Gonna use H2SO4 because the wood is PINE!
-
#sfn IRC chatroom - Where the fun never stops
0

#5 mooeypoo 


Icon
Oh look, Pwnies!
BTW, a bit of news -- I was BABlogged :D

http://blogs.discove...-a-non-miracle/

yay!
Find a Graduate Program in Physics, Astronomy and Related Fields
(From the American Institute of Physics)

Visit my Science@Home Website: http://www.smarterthanthat.com


If I was helpful, let me know by clicking the [+] sign ->
0

#6 DrDNA 


Perceived Expert In Some Field
Any idea what was in it?
Maybe that had something to do with it.

HELP! HELP! I'm being repressed!
0

#7 mooeypoo 


Icon
Oh look, Pwnies!
Actually, there is some ideas - some of it is on display in the National Museum in Israel.. Some was "censored" by his wife, and some they just couldn't make sense of.

It's really very interesting :)
Find a Graduate Program in Physics, Astronomy and Related Fields
(From the American Institute of Physics)

Visit my Science@Home Website: http://www.smarterthanthat.com


If I was helpful, let me know by clicking the [+] sign ->
0

Share this topic:


Page 1 of 1
  • You cannot start a new topic
  • You cannot reply to this topic

1 User(s) are reading this topic
0 members, 1 guests, 0 anonymous users