We're all reluctant to trust a person who is dumb or carelessly incorrect, but what about a really, really smart person?
You appear to have established communication with an omniscient mind or mind(s). Considering that it could liberate you to pursue your own ends or manipulate you to serve its own ends, should you listen to it? Do you even pay attention if it might only use you?
What if you can't necessarily double-check what it's saying? What if it gets something wrong, on accident or on purpose? What if you aren't asking the questions, just receiving the information it chooses to provide? What if it is communicating with an unknown number of others, and might influence your reality through its influence on the others? What might this thing be anyway, and what might its motives be?
It seems strangely reminiscent of the recent US election actually.